This establishment is one of my favorites! I came across it about two years ago and their food is phenomenal. I have never had a bad experience here at all - from food, to wait staff, etc. Their Lobster BLT is to die for, but it hasn't been on the menu for awhile. I hope they bring it back - one of the best things ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George Holden
I've eaten at this place since I was a teenager. It has always been excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gregory C.
A buddy of mine recommended this place. Stopped in here Saturday Night at 8:30pm. The place was deserted. Not a single customer. There was no bartender at the bar. The place was empty. Walked up to the bar a shouted "Hello, Is anybody here" and slapped my hand on the bar top to make some noise. About a half minute later a guy comes running up from the basement and shouts "What the fuck are you banging on the bar for?" At first I thought he was joking, but by the look on his face I could tell he was seriously mad. I said "I guess you don't want any paying customers" and left Fuck this place.
Nick Proton
Great times. Amazing friendly people. Will be back soon for another pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janine T.
For the longest time my mom has been talking about this place. It's been there for since maybe the 50s or 60s. Small place on the corner with the original sign and from the looks of the inside the original interior, you would think it's just a dive bar when walking in. It had the original register and it could possibly be cash only. I did not see a credit card machine but I am not sure. We ordered three pies over the phone. One regular, one pepperoni and one sausage, peppers, onions and black olives. Wow was it amazing. One of the best slices. The dough is just different. I usually hate order pizza to bring home because the pizza is just soggy from being in pizza boxes. This pizza was not soggy what so ever. The sauce was absolutely incredible as well. The owner was so nice which was a very nice touch. My mom recently had hand surgery and he made a point to inquire about it and tell her he hopes she feels better. Very nice service, the pies did take longer then expected but it was worth the wait. This place is an absolute gem. No slices just pies.
Francisco Castillo
Best kept secret in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
william wall
I haven't been to Teddy's in many years, my sister used to live in Elmont, but I have to say that their pizza was the best that I have ever tasted, thin crust and delicious...I have to make a point to return again very soon!!!
Gypsy Traveler
Love this old school, home feel and friendly place❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Linda Gannon
Lived around the corner on Donovan went there many times miss that place- places like this are few and far! Miss NY now live in SC. Maybe when I’m up there I will come by and have a pizza.
Jennifer Hope
Haven't been in years but I think about this pizza all the time. I stopped in one tome and the owner was so nice and talked to me as he made the pie himself. It was some of the best pizza I ever had. I would go again if I had a car to get there!
I grew up in Elmont and have been eating Teddy’s pizza my entire life. The place and pizza are the best! I have so many memories of going there with my friend and his dad. I’ve taken my kids there to eat the pizza and whenever I’m back on LI, I call and order a few pies to bring back home to Westchester. I’ve eaten lots of pizza and Teddy’s is at the top! Please keep the business going!
Jay L.
best place for pizza in elmont !!! my whole family has been going here for years and i also grew up in this pizza this place is AMAZING
Abhay N.
I visited this place recently with a small group. Really poor customer service and a lack of basic hygiene earns this place 1 star. I have no idea how this place hasn't been closed down due to the many health code violations I saw. It felt like walking into an episode of Hoarders. King Umberto's is just down the street, and so much better.
Brian Schmidt
My dad grew up eating this pizza and introduced our family to it. It has ruined all other Pizza for me. The greatest. Didnt know it was still open. I wonder if its the same as the good ol days.???
Rosario Muscarella
Time has stood still and its great.So is the pizza!
This establishment is one of my favorites! I came across it about two years ago and their food is phenomenal. I have never had a bad experience here at all - from food, to wait staff, etc. Their Lobster BLT is to die for, but it hasn't been on the menu for awhile. I hope they bring it back - one of the best things ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've eaten at this place since I was a teenager. It has always been excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A buddy of mine recommended this place. Stopped in here Saturday Night at 8:30pm. The place was deserted. Not a single customer. There was no bartender at the bar. The place was empty. Walked up to the bar a shouted "Hello, Is anybody here" and slapped my hand on the bar top to make some noise. About a half minute later a guy comes running up from the basement and shouts "What the fuck are you banging on the bar for?" At first I thought he was joking, but by the look on his face I could tell he was seriously mad. I said "I guess you don't want any paying customers" and left Fuck this place.
Great times. Amazing friendly people. Will be back soon for another pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For the longest time my mom has been talking about this place. It's been there for since maybe the 50s or 60s. Small place on the corner with the original sign and from the looks of the inside the original interior, you would think it's just a dive bar when walking in. It had the original register and it could possibly be cash only. I did not see a credit card machine but I am not sure. We ordered three pies over the phone. One regular, one pepperoni and one sausage, peppers, onions and black olives. Wow was it amazing. One of the best slices. The dough is just different. I usually hate order pizza to bring home because the pizza is just soggy from being in pizza boxes. This pizza was not soggy what so ever. The sauce was absolutely incredible as well. The owner was so nice which was a very nice touch. My mom recently had hand surgery and he made a point to inquire about it and tell her he hopes she feels better. Very nice service, the pies did take longer then expected but it was worth the wait. This place is an absolute gem. No slices just pies.
Best kept secret in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I haven't been to Teddy's in many years, my sister used to live in Elmont, but I have to say that their pizza was the best that I have ever tasted, thin crust and delicious...I have to make a point to return again very soon!!!
Love this old school, home feel and friendly place❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Lived around the corner on Donovan went there many times miss that place- places like this are few and far! Miss NY now live in SC. Maybe when I’m up there I will come by and have a pizza.
Haven't been in years but I think about this pizza all the time. I stopped in one tome and the owner was so nice and talked to me as he made the pie himself. It was some of the best pizza I ever had. I would go again if I had a car to get there!
Restaurantji Recommends
I grew up in Elmont and have been eating Teddy’s pizza my entire life. The place and pizza are the best! I have so many memories of going there with my friend and his dad. I’ve taken my kids there to eat the pizza and whenever I’m back on LI, I call and order a few pies to bring back home to Westchester. I’ve eaten lots of pizza and Teddy’s is at the top! Please keep the business going!
best place for pizza in elmont !!! my whole family has been going here for years and i also grew up in this pizza this place is AMAZING
I visited this place recently with a small group. Really poor customer service and a lack of basic hygiene earns this place 1 star. I have no idea how this place hasn't been closed down due to the many health code violations I saw. It felt like walking into an episode of Hoarders. King Umberto's is just down the street, and so much better.
My dad grew up eating this pizza and introduced our family to it. It has ruined all other Pizza for me. The greatest. Didnt know it was still open. I wonder if its the same as the good ol days.???
Time has stood still and its great.So is the pizza!