Farmingdale Pizza & Pasta

75 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale
(516) 755-1200

Recent Reviews

Mr. S.

Great pizza place that I tried out tonight. Regular pie was good chicken Parm was great. Will try again soon!!!

Jim K.

We ordered pizza from 3 Brothers and I was very disappointed. The pizza looked like it was old and reheated. I very rarely will write a bad review. We didn't eat most of the pizza and ended up throwing it away. There were 4 of us and everyone had the same opinion. The gluten free pizza was ok but not good enough for us to order from here again.

Lisa T.

We came here yesterday for some vegan eats, and it was such a pleasant experience! Our waitress was really helpful! She surprised us with two of the best desserts on the menu! The death by chocolate cake was out of this world! Every bite was rich and chocolatey, and tasted even better paired with a tall glass of cold soy milk! I was impressed by the extent of the vegan menu. Classic Italian dishes gone vegan- without missing the mark. You can't go wrong with the vegan mozzarella sticks or the oyster mushroom calamari. For entrees we had the eggplant rollatini and stuffed shells, both excellent! It was my first time trying cashew ricotta, and I was thoroughly impressed. Oh I have also heard that they serve the best grandma slice around!!!

Malaika F.

The food is ass. They barely put cheese on my personal pie and then the roasted peppers (which I assume is going to be a mix of red and green peppers) barely there as well. Do not go there and waste your money! You will be severely disappointed.

Ashley R.

0 stars if I could honestly. Ordered from this place every single day and always got the right order. As of recently, they can never get my order straight. Everytime I go into this restaurant and the female is taking orders, she takes every single white person in the store's order before mine, REGARDLESS if I walked in and walked up to the counter first. This time, I ordered a penne Al a vodka pizza NON VEGAN after waiting for every white man in the store to order. After 20 minutes of waiting, I asked the nice girl how much longer, she turns her back on me and starts cutting a pizza .. this is the woman who is handling MONEY ... NO GLOVES, hands all in somebody's pizza. The woman then says "it's in the oven" I asked again, " ok great, so how much longer?" She responds oh it's in the oven, then the cook screams out less than 1 minute. I finally get my pizza 5 minutes later instead of less than 1 minute but hey at least I got my pizza, so I thought. I opened my pizza after utilizing my entire lunch break to wait on this pizza just to see it's not even what I ordered! I called the restaurant and the cook answers the phone and says he wasn't told to make a penne a la vodka pizza. I said ok great but now I don't have food and I paid for this, he catches a ridiculous attitude and tells me I can come back tonight or tomorrow for a new pizza. THANKS, THIS PREGNANT WOMAN WILL STARVE NOW BECAUSE OF THIS RIDICULOUS WOMAN AT THE FRONT END! She needs to fired or sweeping, she clearly cannot keep up with the demand of orders up front.

Lily F.

I am super disappointed because I took advantage of the DoorDash "happy hour" and 3 brothers had a great deal so I ordered from here. I ordered a chicken parm hero, meatball hero, and penne a la vodka. For starters, they gave me two chicken parm heros rather than one chicken and one meatball. The chicken was literally just one chicken finger in a hero bread with cheese slabbed all over it. YUCK! The penne a la vodka photo in the DoorDash app had chicken on it so I was excited about that, and there wasn't even a chicken option for me to add it on, unfortunately, no chicken in the pasta and it was so bland. Sorry but I'm not a fan.

Adriana K.

Finding a hair in my side salad was bad enough but then I found another one in my eggplant rollatini. Unfortunately I am now too grossed out now to try anything else from their menu.

Stacee P.

This establishment is amazing.I was traveling from out of town and would not arrive until after they closed. Evwen said he would leave our food at 7 eleven. We are Vegan and the food was incredible, we couldn't wait until we got to our hotel. Thank you sooo very much!

Joe W.

very disappointed .. someone get this cook a timer oreded chix parm and fried ravilois and both got delivered burnt black .. couldnt even eaten it

C C.

See below John T. review. I was also present for this 'display' 4/28/23. Very nasty management. I witnessed several customers be disrespected and yelled at like children by an elder dusty looking tall white male who clearly has horrible communication skills and also could not be honest about timing. Tiny & disorganized, in the non dining area. Would give 0 stars but can't. I would never recommend & will no longer patron such a disgusting 'establishment' again. Food isn't even all that, to top it off.

John T.

I will never spend another dollar at this restaurant. When I arrived, the skinny old guy behind the counter was in a tiff with a doordash delivery driver, because he was confirming all the food was there. Then a woman waiting before me was asking a question and he was giving her an attitude, yelling "what do you want me to do, it's too much" referring to the orders coming in. Another woman said "if you can't handle the online orders then turn it off" so he grabs the tablet, rips the cord out and slams the tablet down "THERE, ARE YOU HAPPY?!" It was at this point that I spoke up. I told him he can't speak to customers that way. He said "if you don't like it, leave, you don't get your food" so I demanded my money back. He told me his name is Andy and he's the owner! If you're a piece of s**** you should stay in the back and let the rest of the crew run the store. Everyone else who works there has always been nice. Never in my life will I give this company any more of my money. Such a shame. If I could give 0 stars... I would. Unfortunately, 1 is the lowest I can go.

kittychik79

Very tasty food. Good amount of food given. Eggplant rollatini is excellent. Also loved the cauliflower steak. Updated from previous review on 2023-04-27

Gina L.

If I could give this place 10 stars I would. I have been coming here for years as this was one of the only vegan places or vegan friendly places around a few years ago. The staff is literally so friendly and the guy who makes the pizza is passionate about his job and genuinely an amazing person. The brunch is seriously out of this world, the vegan Buffalo wings are UNREAL and any non vegan would even love them, and the vegan Buffalo chicken pizza is insanely good. I have probably been to this place over 100 times in my life and I will continue to come back and back again. This is a perfect place for a group of people who have vegans and non vegans as there are two menu options that have lots of delicious food for people of all diet types and allergies. The vibes inside are like a more classic Italian restaurant and they have a decent amount of seating for a smaller restaurant. Parking is hard to come by, but usually not too big of an issue. Whether you eat in or take it out, this place is a must try.

Julie D.

Yummy food at an affordable price. Love all the vegan options that are available. Easy process for ordering takeout.

Jgatt

Great restaurant with a very extensive vegan menu! Sooo many options. My favorite is the eggplant rollatini! Also awesome desserts

Load More