Walk in there, waiting for some to help me with my order, they just walking around made eye contact with me say nothing to me then they go and help people that walk in after me.
Craig Kearns
Place was great when the old restaurant manager John was there. He recently left and the place went to garbage. I won’t be going back.
Failbaddon The Armless
Excellent calzone. Crust was great and they don't skimp on the filling.
Carole C.
I ordered by phone and was told that due to an event being held at the restaurant the normal time would be longer. She said 40 minutes. I arrived 55 minutes after ordering and was told that it would be a few more minutes. After almost 10 minutes more the counter man rang me up. The amount was $6 more than their menu price. As by this time I was in a hurry I took the food and left. This price gouging is a disgrace. Only go to this establishment if you like getting ripped off.
Kayla Moore
Came and got a slice to go didn’t give me napkins and didn’t ask if I wanted any seasonings . Kinda rude …
Cameron C.
12" pies are out of this world!!! Highly recommend. Tried the marg, Buffalo chicken, and pepperoni all great Buffalo chicken was superior. Will be back soon.
Nancy N.
Phenomenal experience. Top notch food, atmosphere, and wait staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all around. Went to the Witchcraft Halloween Pop Up hosted by Main Street Pizza in Farmingdale ~ it felt like you literally walked into the world of Hocus Pocus; the cast, the a and the food was off the charts ~The food was absolutely superb. Main Street Pizza definitely has me and my whole family as a customer for life.
Diana Lopez
Pizza is delish, friendly. This week they have Pumpkin Cheesecake..yummy ?
Rebecca J.
So, I don't know if my experience was because I ate here as part of the Hocus Pocus pop up event or what, but the entire experience was WAY overpriced and underwhelming. Tickets to the event were $30 a person which included the short show (my kids complained when it was over that it didn't last long) and a flimsy plastic Hocus Pocus cup. The food was so overpriced, I was shocked. Kids chicken fingers and fries were $17!! Talk about price gouging. My friend and I shared the risotto balls, $16 for 2 the size of gold balls!! They were tasty but came out cold and for that price it should have came with 4. My friend and I both got the pumpkin ravioli. Nothing special and again cold, $25 for 5 ravioli!! The prices were out of control for mediocre food and very small portions. I really felt taken advantage of with the entire experience and would not return to this restaurant or pop up event. Only positive was the place was nicely decorated for the event/Halloween. Wish I took pics of my food.
Larry B.
Stars lost not for food quality or service, but rather what I would consider price gouging. We have ordered from MSPC before and the food has always been good. Tonight while walking around at the music on main event we decided to dine at one of their outdoor tables. Strangely the menus on the table were extremely limited and made no mention of pizza but when we asked our waitress informed us it was no problem to get whatever from their full menu. Took a glance at their website and decided on the risotto balls and their vodka pie along with two sodas. Again, food was good and the service was friendly and reasonably quick. When we were done our server asked if we needed a printed copy of the check. Since we were outside and my son was getting antsy I said it was fine I'd just pay - was not expecting to hear the bill was over $60 for what we ordered though. Again, in a rush to get going I paid and chose the option on their tablet to have the receipt texted to me figuring I'd check out why it was so high later on. When I did what I discovered was prices that were a bit more than listed on their website. On their site the vodka pie is listed as $20, went to Uber eats where prices are often jacked up and that showed $22. Somehow dining in we were charged $29 for that same 18" pie. Risotto balls and soda were also higher on the receipt than advertised and weren't free refills because we were charged for four, pretty stupid when it's on tap but that one I'll take the blame for. I don't know if they were raising prices for the street fair or what but the wide gap between what's advertised and what was charged left a bad taste with me. Tread carefully is all I can say.
OMG. Jus had the most amazing healthy veggie slice homemade with fresh sautéed vegetables on an excellent slice of pizza. DELICIOUS. Main Street Pizza has some of the greatest pizza and Italian entrees in Long Island. And it's right here in Downtown Farmingdale. My new go to pizza place in the area. Thanks Guys
Alison Abeles
Consistently delicious food! Dinners and pizza are fantastic! Our whole family loves them.
rob castaldo
I wanted to like this place , but they have cancelled 2 orders on me in a matter of a couple of months. Both times nowhere near closing. Other times trying to get some of there special pies they could not make them cause they didn't have certain ingredients, but they call you back over a hour later to tell you.Food actually is good but I have been getting poor service.
Justin K.
$29 for pizza with half and half toppings. $6.75 tip. Burnt pizza. Bummer. Last time.
Ryan Grella
The Alice in Wonderland experience was top notch and so was the food and drinks! The actors, and staff were all fantastic and we had a great time! Can't wait to see what they do for Halloween!
Walk in there, waiting for some to help me with my order, they just walking around made eye contact with me say nothing to me then they go and help people that walk in after me.
Place was great when the old restaurant manager John was there. He recently left and the place went to garbage. I won’t be going back.
Excellent calzone. Crust was great and they don't skimp on the filling.
I ordered by phone and was told that due to an event being held at the restaurant the normal time would be longer. She said 40 minutes. I arrived 55 minutes after ordering and was told that it would be a few more minutes. After almost 10 minutes more the counter man rang me up. The amount was $6 more than their menu price. As by this time I was in a hurry I took the food and left. This price gouging is a disgrace. Only go to this establishment if you like getting ripped off.
Came and got a slice to go didn’t give me napkins and didn’t ask if I wanted any seasonings . Kinda rude …
12" pies are out of this world!!! Highly recommend. Tried the marg, Buffalo chicken, and pepperoni all great Buffalo chicken was superior. Will be back soon.
Phenomenal experience. Top notch food, atmosphere, and wait staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all around. Went to the Witchcraft Halloween Pop Up hosted by Main Street Pizza in Farmingdale ~ it felt like you literally walked into the world of Hocus Pocus; the cast, the a and the food was off the charts ~The food was absolutely superb. Main Street Pizza definitely has me and my whole family as a customer for life.
Pizza is delish, friendly. This week they have Pumpkin Cheesecake..yummy ?
So, I don't know if my experience was because I ate here as part of the Hocus Pocus pop up event or what, but the entire experience was WAY overpriced and underwhelming. Tickets to the event were $30 a person which included the short show (my kids complained when it was over that it didn't last long) and a flimsy plastic Hocus Pocus cup. The food was so overpriced, I was shocked. Kids chicken fingers and fries were $17!! Talk about price gouging. My friend and I shared the risotto balls, $16 for 2 the size of gold balls!! They were tasty but came out cold and for that price it should have came with 4. My friend and I both got the pumpkin ravioli. Nothing special and again cold, $25 for 5 ravioli!! The prices were out of control for mediocre food and very small portions. I really felt taken advantage of with the entire experience and would not return to this restaurant or pop up event. Only positive was the place was nicely decorated for the event/Halloween. Wish I took pics of my food.
Stars lost not for food quality or service, but rather what I would consider price gouging. We have ordered from MSPC before and the food has always been good. Tonight while walking around at the music on main event we decided to dine at one of their outdoor tables. Strangely the menus on the table were extremely limited and made no mention of pizza but when we asked our waitress informed us it was no problem to get whatever from their full menu. Took a glance at their website and decided on the risotto balls and their vodka pie along with two sodas. Again, food was good and the service was friendly and reasonably quick. When we were done our server asked if we needed a printed copy of the check. Since we were outside and my son was getting antsy I said it was fine I'd just pay - was not expecting to hear the bill was over $60 for what we ordered though. Again, in a rush to get going I paid and chose the option on their tablet to have the receipt texted to me figuring I'd check out why it was so high later on. When I did what I discovered was prices that were a bit more than listed on their website. On their site the vodka pie is listed as $20, went to Uber eats where prices are often jacked up and that showed $22. Somehow dining in we were charged $29 for that same 18" pie. Risotto balls and soda were also higher on the receipt than advertised and weren't free refills because we were charged for four, pretty stupid when it's on tap but that one I'll take the blame for. I don't know if they were raising prices for the street fair or what but the wide gap between what's advertised and what was charged left a bad taste with me. Tread carefully is all I can say.
Restaurantji Recommends
OMG. Jus had the most amazing healthy veggie slice homemade with fresh sautéed vegetables on an excellent slice of pizza. DELICIOUS. Main Street Pizza has some of the greatest pizza and Italian entrees in Long Island. And it's right here in Downtown Farmingdale. My new go to pizza place in the area. Thanks Guys
Consistently delicious food! Dinners and pizza are fantastic! Our whole family loves them.
I wanted to like this place , but they have cancelled 2 orders on me in a matter of a couple of months. Both times nowhere near closing. Other times trying to get some of there special pies they could not make them cause they didn't have certain ingredients, but they call you back over a hour later to tell you.Food actually is good but I have been getting poor service.
$29 for pizza with half and half toppings. $6.75 tip. Burnt pizza. Bummer. Last time.
The Alice in Wonderland experience was top notch and so was the food and drinks! The actors, and staff were all fantastic and we had a great time! Can't wait to see what they do for Halloween!