Whenever I have a special occasion or am charged with "bring a dessert" I love going to The Cakery. They have a wide variety of cakes, cupcakes, cookies, bars, cake pops, and cake balls. Their bakers are real artists who will work with you to create the perfect cake (cookie or traditional) that are as pretty to look at as they are to eat. It's tucked away in a shopping plaza so it can be easy to miss. It's worth the trip. My personal favorites: their bars (cheesecake, brookies) and cake balls (cookie dough is fabulous). Highly recommend if you want a sweet treat for yourself or a special event.
Sam Engel E.
They made my god daughter cake , cookies, cupcakes, cake pops look beautiful. The decorations were amazing delivery on time. Very professional.
Samantha Joshua-Mendez
We chose The Cakery as part of our wedding package from Factoria at Charles Point in Peekskill. Ashley helped us create a delicious cake based on the flavors of an Italian rainbow cookie and we loved it. Even though they forgot our cake decor (faux florals and personalized cake topper) they immediately acknowledged their mistake and offered a wonderful compromise to make it right. We appreciate the candor and service and would recommend them in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Samantha Joshua
We chose The Cakery as part of our wedding package from Factoria at Charles Point in Peekskill. Ashley helped us create a delicious cake based on the flavors of an Italian rainbow cookie and we loved it. Even though they forgot our cake decor (faux florals and personalized cake topper) they immediately acknowledged their mistake and offered a wonderful compromise to make it right. We appreciate the candor and service and would recommend them in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Morgan Trevor
The Cakery was incredibly easy to work with from start to finish!! Their take home kit was such a fun spin on cake tasting as we got to mix and match right from the comfort of our own couch. They absolutely nailed the beautiful design we asked for and their flavors cannot be beat!! Our guests are still talking about our funfetti and raspberry jam cake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
diane powell
I ordered four small specialty anniversary cakes, catering to the dynamics of each couple. Ashley was prompt in her communication and spot on with getting the execution correct. Cakes were delicious, including the gluten-free one ordered. Recommended by a friend that lives in Fishkill. Great experience!Dietary restrictions: Delicious gluten-free cake!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake They Made
Franny Crooks
Came here looking for a edible gift for my realtor. I'm not from the area so it was nice to find this gem. I ended up coming back to get some cake balls for myself and I was so happy that I did. The cake balls were 10/10 and customer service was top tier. One of the reps also told me where I can get dinner which was also 10/10. I will definitely be going back here when I revisit.
Heidi Schwartz
Working with The Cakery - was a phenomenal experience. Ashley listened to what we were looking for and created a simple yet exquisite wedding cake to cut that coordinated with the whole theme of the wedding. The dessert bar was delicious and beautifully executed. Ashely was easy to talk to and gave great advice on quantity, flavors and overall layout. The Gluten free options were a big hit. Oh and everything was DELICIOUS. I am definitely a customer!!
Tommy Heavren
The Cakery did a phenomenal job with our wedding cake! We enjoyed each interaction we had with them.They provided us with a great tasting experience, providing a tasting box for us to sample several flavors of cake and frosting at home. When we sent in our cake design request, they beautifully replicated the design we shared and created an elegant cake. They were happy to answer questions and help guide us through the process. They also worked well with our florist, who added some floral arrangements to the cake at the reception venue. The cake was a big hit with our guests! Several guests approached us with wonderful reviews of how much they enjoyed the taste and look of the cake! We are also thankful to the Cakery for providing us with our own special 10-slice "anniversary" cake that we could bring home. We highly recommend the Cakery, and we will definitely be back for other future events!
Eileen Stewart
We used the Cakery for our wedding this weekend and it was perfect. They worked with our venue and everything was coordinated behind the scenes. We loved the sample boxes when we did the cake tasting and we will be back for our anniversary! Thank you!
My wife and I live in Monroe, Connecticut. The Cakery was recommended by my daughter who lives in Beacon, NY. Last year, I had a birthday party for my wife here in Connecticut and asked my daughter to pick-up cupcakes for the party. OMG they were out of this world delicious. This year my wife had a baby shower for her daughter. She asked my daughter to again bring the ordered Cakery cupcakes with an English Garden theme. Not only were the cupcakes delicious, but they were also so beautifully decorated that everyone raved about them. My wife and I give The Cakery Fishkill 10 Stars not just the 5stars Yelp uses.
n tique
Ashley was recommended by the venue. She is very professional.The cake was exactly as we wanted, and the flavors were amazing.Thank you so much. ❤️
Zena Justice
We just moved to the area and discovered The Cakery. OMG! I’ve never had such amazing, beautiful and delicious cakes!!!! We are pleasantly surprised every time we purchase a cake. The owner and manager are seriously cake masters. I highly recommend for special occasions cakes as well as one just for fun! Cookies and cake balls are phenomenal as well.
Anthony Palermo
The team at The Cakery consistently brings the quality and flavor. Their cake balls are unparalleled and fantastically addictive. The staff is incredibly friendly and wonderful to work with. They are conveniently located and go out of their way to ensure customers are satisfied. Fortunately they are local, but I would travel as many miles as possible were I not nearby. If there was a rating above 5 stars I would surely give it!
Mary Sclafani
We had the best time learning how to decorate a cake. Ashley was a great instructor and made the experience so much fun!
Whenever I have a special occasion or am charged with "bring a dessert" I love going to The Cakery. They have a wide variety of cakes, cupcakes, cookies, bars, cake pops, and cake balls. Their bakers are real artists who will work with you to create the perfect cake (cookie or traditional) that are as pretty to look at as they are to eat. It's tucked away in a shopping plaza so it can be easy to miss. It's worth the trip. My personal favorites: their bars (cheesecake, brookies) and cake balls (cookie dough is fabulous). Highly recommend if you want a sweet treat for yourself or a special event.
They made my god daughter cake , cookies, cupcakes, cake pops look beautiful. The decorations were amazing delivery on time. Very professional.
We chose The Cakery as part of our wedding package from Factoria at Charles Point in Peekskill. Ashley helped us create a delicious cake based on the flavors of an Italian rainbow cookie and we loved it. Even though they forgot our cake decor (faux florals and personalized cake topper) they immediately acknowledged their mistake and offered a wonderful compromise to make it right. We appreciate the candor and service and would recommend them in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
We chose The Cakery as part of our wedding package from Factoria at Charles Point in Peekskill. Ashley helped us create a delicious cake based on the flavors of an Italian rainbow cookie and we loved it. Even though they forgot our cake decor (faux florals and personalized cake topper) they immediately acknowledged their mistake and offered a wonderful compromise to make it right. We appreciate the candor and service and would recommend them in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
The Cakery was incredibly easy to work with from start to finish!! Their take home kit was such a fun spin on cake tasting as we got to mix and match right from the comfort of our own couch. They absolutely nailed the beautiful design we asked for and their flavors cannot be beat!! Our guests are still talking about our funfetti and raspberry jam cake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered four small specialty anniversary cakes, catering to the dynamics of each couple. Ashley was prompt in her communication and spot on with getting the execution correct. Cakes were delicious, including the gluten-free one ordered. Recommended by a friend that lives in Fishkill. Great experience!Dietary restrictions: Delicious gluten-free cake!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake They Made
Came here looking for a edible gift for my realtor. I'm not from the area so it was nice to find this gem. I ended up coming back to get some cake balls for myself and I was so happy that I did. The cake balls were 10/10 and customer service was top tier. One of the reps also told me where I can get dinner which was also 10/10. I will definitely be going back here when I revisit.
Working with The Cakery - was a phenomenal experience. Ashley listened to what we were looking for and created a simple yet exquisite wedding cake to cut that coordinated with the whole theme of the wedding. The dessert bar was delicious and beautifully executed. Ashely was easy to talk to and gave great advice on quantity, flavors and overall layout. The Gluten free options were a big hit. Oh and everything was DELICIOUS. I am definitely a customer!!
The Cakery did a phenomenal job with our wedding cake! We enjoyed each interaction we had with them.They provided us with a great tasting experience, providing a tasting box for us to sample several flavors of cake and frosting at home. When we sent in our cake design request, they beautifully replicated the design we shared and created an elegant cake. They were happy to answer questions and help guide us through the process. They also worked well with our florist, who added some floral arrangements to the cake at the reception venue. The cake was a big hit with our guests! Several guests approached us with wonderful reviews of how much they enjoyed the taste and look of the cake! We are also thankful to the Cakery for providing us with our own special 10-slice "anniversary" cake that we could bring home. We highly recommend the Cakery, and we will definitely be back for other future events!
We used the Cakery for our wedding this weekend and it was perfect. They worked with our venue and everything was coordinated behind the scenes. We loved the sample boxes when we did the cake tasting and we will be back for our anniversary! Thank you!
Restaurantji Recommends
My wife and I live in Monroe, Connecticut. The Cakery was recommended by my daughter who lives in Beacon, NY. Last year, I had a birthday party for my wife here in Connecticut and asked my daughter to pick-up cupcakes for the party. OMG they were out of this world delicious. This year my wife had a baby shower for her daughter. She asked my daughter to again bring the ordered Cakery cupcakes with an English Garden theme. Not only were the cupcakes delicious, but they were also so beautifully decorated that everyone raved about them. My wife and I give The Cakery Fishkill 10 Stars not just the 5stars Yelp uses.
Ashley was recommended by the venue. She is very professional.The cake was exactly as we wanted, and the flavors were amazing.Thank you so much. ❤️
We just moved to the area and discovered The Cakery. OMG! I’ve never had such amazing, beautiful and delicious cakes!!!! We are pleasantly surprised every time we purchase a cake. The owner and manager are seriously cake masters. I highly recommend for special occasions cakes as well as one just for fun! Cookies and cake balls are phenomenal as well.
The team at The Cakery consistently brings the quality and flavor. Their cake balls are unparalleled and fantastically addictive. The staff is incredibly friendly and wonderful to work with. They are conveniently located and go out of their way to ensure customers are satisfied. Fortunately they are local, but I would travel as many miles as possible were I not nearby. If there was a rating above 5 stars I would surely give it!
We had the best time learning how to decorate a cake. Ashley was a great instructor and made the experience so much fun!