Catcher's Fish House

301 Woodcleft Ave, Freeport
(516) 600-9698

Recent Reviews

Mike Munafo

My first time here and The manager, Armando and the staff greeted us as if we were family! Cozy and beautiful decor. The menu was diverse with unique options to choose from. Reasonable prices for generous portions. Many dining options indoor and outdoor. Seasonable dining experience to cater to all.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oreganata Shrimp Linguini

Leo Rodriguez

The bread was microwaved and the food was over priced . The drinks were all not available due to the timing, however the waiters were very nice and attentive.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Ralph Fraumeni

Easter Sunday Dinner. Can be noisy but it is on the water so. Service was great. Littleneck clams were nicely chilled and fresh. Beware of the cocktail sauce. Very spicy. Filet mignon with spinach and mashed was very good. Oreganato Shrimp Linguine was nice with artichoke hearts and beautiful shrimp. The Crab Linguine was lots of fresh sweet crab meat in a pink cream sauce with fresh halved cherry tomatoes. It was incredible. Top three seafood pasta dishes I've ever had! Finished with excellent carrot cake and cheese cake. Can't wait for the summer menu!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

howard rothenberg

My wife and I never dined here before but we liked the menu on the web page. I am very very glad we went. We were immediately greeted by the manager/host Armando who sat us right away. He began by telking us the specials for the evening and some if the drink specials. Needless to say, my wife and I shared the whole lobster, porter house steak special and it was Great ?. The whole dinner, oysters appetizer, salad were excellent. We will certainly go back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steamed Maine Lobster, Seafood Tower, Steak

janine puglia

Great fresh seafood and the service was wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood Risotto, Oreganata Shrimp Linguini, Baked Clams, Jumbo Lobster Ravioli

Ebony Howell

Good food. Nice atmosphere, a bit pricey. otherwise food was great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

George Johnson

Limited menu, expect more local seafood.....it was a Monday so maybe caught them on an off

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Lola Rod

I love the staff here and the food never disappoints. Do yourself a favor and order the octopus and some oysters and don’t forget a margarita.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crispy Calamari, Seafood Risotto, Baked Clams, Charred Octopus

tawana harris

Limited winter menu, no drink menu offered. $24 for one crab cake when it’s listed as crab cakes on menu.Restaurant was cold. Nice staff but will never return . Could have gotten more for my money else where. Paid with cash and they didn’t even ask if I wanted change they just decided to keep my change as a tip..

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Hatriett Turner

Lisa the best bartender ever. We sat at the bar for lunch. Loved it ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mayann M.

Service was horrible...over charged in Drinks. The Band...Fool Kings was the highlight of the evening.

Meryl M.

The place was small, very overpriced. When we got the bill it was for me and my husband. They automatically charged gratuities which I don't see how they could. food definitely wasn't worth the amount of money. There's no parking would never go there again and would advise anybody if you're looking to go to a nice seafood place that's not the place especially if you can't park and you gotta park 23 blocks away and walk in 10° weather.

Nancy C

Awful service. Food was NOT great, over charged for items, never received pepper, lemon, cheese that we asked for. No one ever cleared plates or empty glasses. No draft beer. BAND WAS GREAT! Will never get food again.

Emily C.

My friends and I were looking for a spot for lunch and came across this restaurant after roaming up and down the block. It stood out cause there was a huge space and there was indoor and outdoor dining. Plenty of tables but fairly empty on the Sunday afternoon that we came. Prices are reasonable considering there's lots of seafood options on the menu and portions are big. We ordered a few appetizers for the table: - Crispy calamari: wish the calamari was thicker. The ones here were the thinnest I've had and not my preferred texture since it was so thin but still fried well. - Crab cake: delicious, good chunks of crabmeat. - Coconut shrimp: 4 big pieces of fried shrimp per order with some kind of fried things in the middle. Good flavor! As for entrees, I got the crab bucatini. I was looking forward to bucatini pasta but unfortunately, they said that it would be served with linguine. The flavor was actually really good. Lovely tomato cream sauce with good amounts of crabmeat. I also got a side of seafood risotto which could be on entree on its own! It had smaller pieces of seafood but still very flavorful. I got to try my friend's seafood paella, which was so yummy. It was a huge portion, good to share for sure, and had lots of seafood and even chicken. The seafood on this was bigger pieces than the ones that came with the risotto. The tomato flavor in it also stood out and was really tasty. I also tried the sides of lobster mashed potatoes and parmesan truffle fries. The fries were just okay, not much truffle flavor and more like shoestring fries but not crispy enough in my opinion. The lobster mashed was delicious and had a good amount of lobster in it too! Overall, a great spot for lunch, dinner, casual meal with friends, or even a date. The menu has a decent variety of items but seemed to be more Italian and seafood focused. Definitely get their seafood items cause they don't skimp on the seafood and everything was cooked nicely! They also season their entrees really well, loved all the flavors.

Patti D.

So disappointed had dinner there in the summer it was very good. So invited a friend to go Saturday night. Horrible!! Burger was over cooked and dry asked for medium and chicken was undercooked. Not cheap either $26 burger bill was $80 and no drinks. Hope you are able to pull it together or close during the fall and winter. Unfortunate for this place

Load More