Emeterio's Pizzeria

59 W 1st St N, Fulton
(315) 598-3333

Recent Reviews

Nicole S.

We like this pizza place! One of the better places in town that isn't a national chain. Reasonable pricing but the sauce changed recently and it's just not as good as before. (Hence the -1 star)

Donna Goss

Their pizza is really good, and their midweek large cheese/garlic pizza deal is fantastic for busy families.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Lovers, NY Style

Bobbiejo Kempston

Pizza was great! Thank you from the Dead End!

Steven Derochie

Ordered a corn beef sandwich on rye with Russian dressing, it was delivered and it's not what I ordered. Tried to call the pizza shop back multiple times and they didn't answer. I even sent text messages to the delivery guy.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: NY Style

Dan Fluer

Very crazy place to eat employees are not employees more like thugs swearing in front of kids and all sorts of stuff threats and so on worst place to go for pizza period the atmosphere sucks so does the service and no one has a clue whats going on may as well shut the doors now before ya lose everything with the employees ya have 10 put of 10 dint recomened

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason Mathews

One of my favorites!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tabatha Woods

Awesome Food Here!! Definitely will be ordering from them again!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zero Love

Just simply absoultely terrible pizza.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

B snyder

The wings are so awesome! The pizza is second to none. Friendly, service and good prices. Love this place!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nick Parkhurst

Don't know how to answer their phone because they're a bunch of ignorant people working there.

Dennis

Shame they went out of business and didn't say anything.. been trying to order but must have closed the doors for good because never open

Doug Venton

They have delivered to my house for years including when it was pie guys and now won't deliver my house is less than 3 in a half miles away and I've always tipped good but they will go across town to volney with is alot farther. Just not happy with this pizza shop. Ps. Was a long time customer and no longer

Nikki Barlow

I’m actually really upset with how down hill the pizza and wings have been lately. The pizza tonight literally has NO dough it is so thin it’s pretty much just the cheese. Wings are undercooked again. I love this place but I’m upset with the lack of interest on who’s making the food that brings in their money. Up the prices to keep the quality which is fine but that’s not the case with the last few times I have ordered. The slices are tiny in the large pizza’s. Hopefully things can go back to how they use to be.

Taylor Clark

The employees are rude and and want to argue about the prices they have posted. I'm sorry but when your prices are listed as such and when I come in to pay and you tell me it's more than what you have it listed as, you are a rip off and scam. Beyond me how this place has lasted as long as it has. That was my first experience with this pizza place and my last.

Mikayla Kemp

We get pizza for our company lunch on occasion, it's almost always last minute and always a rather large order. They always manage to fit us in the time crunch and everyone is always satisfied with the pizza and wings!

Load More