Jersey Mike's Subs

2345 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 619-1400

Recent Reviews

lisa denburg

This team did a top notch job during the day of giving! The staff all had smiles beaming on their faces and they were so happy to be able to give back to the Special Olympics of NY! I loved my tuna sub Mike's Way -- it's my go-to sub!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Club Supreme, Chips, Brownie, Roast Beef, Subs by the Bag, Cookie

JOHN “JMK” Kamamis

Great sandwiches decent prices but the sandwiches got smaller and they're still $20 a piece most of the staff is five star but there are 1 0r 2 people who just don't like their job and they just want to leave early and that's not good for the rest of the store because I love Jersey Mike's always

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: My Philly Cheesesteak, Original Italian Sub

JOHN Kamamis

Great sandwiches decent prices but the sandwiches got smaller and they're still $20 a piece most of the staff is five star but there are 1 0r 2 people who just don't like their job and they just want to leave early and that's not good for the rest of the store because I love Jersey Mike's always

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: My Philly Cheesesteak, Original Italian Sub

Toni Fisk-Reece

The freshly made sandwiches in the store are so much better than ordering for delivery.Vegetarian options: Fresh fresh fresh

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Scott Laine

There is a place in my heart for a good sandwich and Jersey Mike’s fills the void when I am on the road. The sandwiches are consistent and delicious with all the right balance of vinegar and other flavors to elevate even the most basic sandwich.To be fully transparent, I always take out as I don’t find their ambience all that exceptional, even though I love their food

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Go

Great branch of Jersey Mike’s. Always fast to make sandwiches even when the line is long. Online order pickups are also ready before the estimated time. Big Kahuna and the new Portobello sandwich are good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: My Philly Cheesesteak

Adriana Tucker

Sometimes perfect, sometimes too much. But alwyas a good one.

Peter R.

So I keep hearing about this Jersey Mikes and because I was going into Citi Bank to make a deposit I said let me try it. First thing I notice is here's no one in the store and that could be because it was 3:45 in the afternoon. 5 people behind the counter and one of the girls is playfully threatening to smack the other... no big deal but they're all standing around doing absolutely nothing...For 11 years I operated a bagel store ....There's always something to do and believe the place was far from spotless so that falls under who's the manager running the show...In the food business and besides the guy who made my sandwich everyone else just was standing there having a good time. I look at the selection and ordered a roast beef with lettuce and tomatoes...I wanted the roast beef heated up and it was far from hot...the bread he didn't even ask me if I wanted that toasted or heated up. The roast beef was fine but if there was a 1/4 pound of roast beef I was lucky... I realize everything has gone up but 11 dollars for a rubber roll ( horrible) some lettuce & tomatoes and 1/4 pound of roast beef ??? I thought Ivarone was expensive..... Dominicks deli for 8 dollars will give you a hero that if you curl it you can get a pump in your biceps...One and done and send Mike back to Jersey !!!!!!

nathan shaolian

Disgusting attitude by one staff member. Felt rushed as soon as I walked in. Literally threw the bag of food. If you want to go home so bad then don’t work In the food industry . Better yet don’t work at all because thousands of people are looking for a job. What a shame this particular worker made this place. Also I’m sure corporate would love to hear the blasting loud music you have playing at night in the store

Mel F.

Foods good , service is iffy - staff have attitudes and are honestly rude. Tried to give them a second chance after my mother was yelled at but to no avail I left feeling disrespected. Will go to the other location from now on.

Alice P.

I love a great Jersey Sub, Mikes way! I always get the Turkey and Provolone. This was my first time ordering from this location as a result of receiving a T-Mobile Tuesday giveaway. I was easily able to add the coupon to my account and order my sub online. I was delighted to see my order waiting when I arrived. The restaurant was clean, staff friendly. The best part was the sub was prepared exactly how I wanted it. Yum yum

Cindy J.

Delicious sandwich!! I ordered the tuna sandwich on a Parmesan bread. The inside of the bread had lovely spices. The olive oil made it tasty. I was satisfied and would order again. The bread was not rubbery. I love the shredded lettuce - makes a difference. I ordered pickup and the Staff kept my sandwich behind the counter. It was safe there. The eating area was clean.

Jesse Y.

Clean, quick, friendly service of both fresh cold and hot heroes. It's more than adequate to satisfy your sandwich crave without breaking the bank.

Gilbert

ordered online and was ready on time. pick up was quick and convenient. food was good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian C.

Everyone knows Jersey Mike's has the best subs but this location is a mess! Always running out of menu items, ex. white bread!?, turkey?! Subs... that's all you guys do right? Can't be that tuff to stock enough deli meat. Damn, if you can't get that straight maybe you should close this shit down. May need to switch to Subway...

Load More