Otaki Sushi

2136 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 739-8868

Recent Reviews

Linda G.

Went their yesterday for the first time. Food was good and the price was good. However, i would not go back their to eat in. I would order out. They were very receptive to our order and accommodating but there is where it stops. No one greeted us to make us feel welcome, no smiles on anyone's face, to me it was all business. I go out to eat often and I have never encountered not even a smile on the waitress face. It would be a complete turn off to go back and eat in. Too many local restaurants in the area who are more welcoming to go back here.

Val Gurvits

Decided to try this place for the first time yesterday. Largely disappointed with everything. It was just not that great.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Lee Gee

The seaweed salad was a little fishy weird tasting. Maybe not that fresh. The unagi (eel) sashimi also had a weird taste.. The salmon sashimi was good. The Rock shrimp were pretty good just a little greasy. The 2 rolls ordered were ok. Probably won't order from here again unfortunately.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sashimi, Spicy Rock Shrimp, Seaweed Salad, Edamame

Lori v.

Cozy little sushi restaurants with the best Avocado salad and Kani salad anywhere I've ever eaten. Wonderful fresh Sushi. We tried the Valentine roll tonight and loved it.

denise b.

My go to sushi restaurant usually order sushi for 2 which comes with 2 salads and 2 miso soups for take out

Ashley A.

I have only ever ordered take out from here but the sushi is always fresh and delicious. I am very picky when it comes to sushi but this place is great! They have a great lunch special as well

Dan Anderson

Fresh. Clean. Quick. Highly

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Vincent

Tiny portions for okay hibachi takeout. Staff is not very nice. Won't be visiting again and I suggest you don't either.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Christina T.

Great delivery and food is fresh! They are receptive customers request. Thank you. Recommend this place

Cindy B.

7/29/23 went and got takeout. So good !! Never a bad meal!!Delicious !!! ALWAYS !!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie T.

My friends and I came to Otaki Sushi on a Thursday night around 7:00pm. We had made a reservation but it was only after we came in that they grouped the tables together so there was a little of a wait. It is a good sized restaurant with tables and the sushi chef area. I had the Lobster Tango Roll which is spicy lobster, avocado inside, top w. spicy crab meat, crunchy wrapped w. soy bean paper. This was really good. The ingredients tasted really fresh and I liked that there was crunchy pieces on top, differences in texture. Service was great and the wait for the food wasn't long. We were there to almost closing time and they did not push us out or rush us.

Beth Linda

Amazing service, friendly staff, got our food super fast, and they gave us free ice cream for our first time there! Just very welcoming and great, fresh sushi.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

MacBeth Derham

Good food. A bit dingy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Joey Guapo

Excellent sushi eat in or take out, Fresh nice size pieces, got the Sushi for 2, Excellent.Wheelchair accessibility: No problem wheelchairs

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sashimi, Sushi

Icey Cream

THIS FOOD WAS AMAZING!!! I loved the cucumber roll and boston roll. The service was amazing . They got my empty plate as soon as I finished it. As soon as I walked in the waitress was very welcoming. The bathroom is very clean too. I will definitely visit again. I recommend!

Load More