Super Bagel

2337 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 416-4620

Recent Reviews

Jaclyn J.

Love coming here for breakfast every weekend!! Great portions and they have the best bagels!!

Chel P.

Favorite bagel spot on Long Island! I am very picky with my cold salads and they have the best tuna, egg, and chicken salad. Every time I bring it somewhere, it's a huge hit! Definitely recommend when you are hosting a brunch/lunch.

RANIE R.

This is my second time ordering from this bagel place. Everything is very fresh and tasty. Extremely polite staff. They are many bagel places around But this one is the icing on the cake. Besides all this they have the cheapest prices around. I will definitely be ordering again from them and on my next bagel catering order they will be getting my business. Great many thanks goes out to the owner. He himself had brought my delivery the first time. Overall I want thank all the staff for doing an amazing job day in and Day out. Many blessings. Stay healthy.

Kristy T.

A good standard NY bagel joint with great basics. The place is big, clean, and the staff is friendly. I love that they have a variety of flat bagels and it makes it even better that they're good (good crisp, good chew). I also appreciate the adequate amount of ketchup they it on your BEC. There's so many places that just don't give you enough ketchup. Definitely a neighborhood go to!

Arty W.

Your basic bagel joint that does a simple everything bagel with scallion cream cheese pretty well. Bagels are soft when fresh in the morning. Pair it with a sausage egg and cheese on a roll and you're good to go!

Patricia M.

The food is decent but it takes FOREVER to get it. Speed is not the goal at this place.

Katie O.

Dennis is absolutely amazing. The food is fabulous I have catered from them twice. Once for the day after my wedding then for my daughter's first birthday. The bagels, salads and lox are so fresh and delicious. Service A+ and food is A++!! Couldn't recommend them enough.

Big D.

This place has horrible service. I have purchased from them a few times, and the bagels are not the best quality but they usually have no line so I choose to go here.. on my latest visit today I went in for a toasted bagel with cream cheese the kid behind the counter, put it on the toaster and went into the kitchen area. A few other customers came in ordering egg sandwiches and egg platters and my bagel still sitting on the toaster I wasn't sure what this kid was doing in the kitchen, but I figured he was either getting something for another customer or my order. Either way after waiting almost 15 minutes and two other customers after me were completely taken care of by another girl behind the counter, I asked what happened to the kid that was helping me. My bagel is still on the toaster. She went in to get him, after coming out, it seem to me like he totally forgot about my order and said he was in the bathroom after I asked them what happened to my bagel. He obviously had forgotten about my order and then continued toasting my bagel for a second time using only one glove after he just told me he came out of the bathroom. Not sure if he washed his hands or not but either way he should be using two gloves. I will never go to this place again.

Marisa G.

Awesome bagels+bagel chips; Tuna and egg salads are both delicious, too! If you're in the area, I recommend.

Danielle C.

Bagels here are pretty decent. They aren't as dense as some of the other bagels I've had from the NYC area but still tasty. They are still rather doughy compare to most other bagels outside the NYC area.We brought some bagels back to California and they survived the plane ride fine. They go well with lots of cream cheese!If you order a bagel with cream cheese to eat there, they definitely load up on the cream cheese.

Nancy B.

Excellent bagels. I particularly like the sesame and the cinnamon raisin. My granddaughter loves the rainbow. They have Boar's Head meats which are the only cold cuts I ever buy. Easy parking right out front. Nice employees. A winner.

Krissy A.

I come here quite frequently. Honestly today I'm disappointed. The kid that was serving us was a bit rude and messed up a simple order. 1 sesame seed bagel toasted with butter 1 poppy toasted with scallion cream cheese and 1 onion toasted with scallion cream cheese. Gave us the wrong bagel and didn't even toasted any of the bagels....

Janine T.

I have never had a bad experience here. I don't understand the negative reviews. The service is always fast and the orders are always correct and delicious. Last time I went I got the American classic on an everything bagel. Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, bacon and I had then add Russian dressing. They gave me a generous amount of chicken and it was amazing. So what if they aren't bright and bubbly when you walk in. Food and service is good.

Jiovani R.

Last monday me and my girlfriend were in the area and we were craving some good breakfast. I googled near by bagel spot and boom found this spot. A bit hidden since I've been in the area many times before and never seen it. Regardless the bagels were fresh and the eggs with bacon were also yummy and fresh. The breakfast was well priced and place had lots of food and beverages to choose from. Coffee was fresh and that's a big plus for us. I'd recommend to try this spot if around the area.

Marie I.

Wonderful prompt fresh delicious excellent. Had a wedding delivery to Fox Hollow inn. Dennis was amazing. Food was exceptional. And felt like I was dealing with an Uncle. AMAZING!!!! 10 Stars!!!**********

Load More