Greek City Grill

263 Nassau Blvd S, Garden City South
(516) 385-8190

Recent Reviews

Nicole P.

Best Greek food I have ever had. Everything I have e er ordered has always been delicious. The waitress is always great to see and visit with. Great customer service with a cute atmosphere!

M F.

The food here is always delicious, fresh and consistent. The staff here is always pleasant with a smile.

Joe K.

Came in for a quick lunch with my mom. The stuffed grape leaves were a great start and the chicken in the souvlaki was moist and properly seasoned. Good portions as well.

Gina Karp

Great food and excellent service! Anna treated us like family. Warm and friendly atmosphere in this small, cozy restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob Saunders

They must drop grub hub. Ordered with 30 min window order not ready till 40 mins and then grub hub driver went 30 mins in opposite direction. Waiting 90 mins for cold $100 order. Never again. What a joke.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Vittorio Florio

Amazing place. Service was excellent, it’s a small family run place, super clean, food was incredible. Very authentic, would 100% recommend all

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

LaDonna R.

We have ordered from them many of times and have recommended them. BUT.. tonight is different. The food was terrible, no flavor the tiki sauces were questionable. The salad was full of onions... No lettuce if you ask me right now if I would recommend them I would definitely have to say NO...

Angelina Provvisiero

Incredibly homey service and atmosphere!! Everything was delicious and very fresh. The dips and platters were absolutely unforgettable, vibrant flavors and amazing balance in taste — not a single complaint first time going! (those lemon potatoes are nothing less than mind blowing) Everything tasted completely authentic and don’t skip on the Greek hot coffee, made over sand and very rich tasting. The deserts also were an extremely satisfying end to a meal, being very rich and delectable. Service was wonderful, giving all customers a friendly and comforting welcome, making everything feel natural and inviting.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Baklava, Zucchini Chips, Falafel, Fried Zucchini Chips, Lemon Potatoes, Pita, Greek Fries, Grape Leaves

Stacey S.

Heard about a Greek place nearby so we decided to check it out on 2/17/24. There was one hostess/waitress and she was super bubbly and friendly. Service from her was great. We started with the zucchini chips and gigante beans for apps. Both were very good. The chips were thin and crispy, and the beans had a flavorful sauce. Bread/pita should have been given, but we asked for some. We wanted a side order (not an appetizer size) of the hummus and was told they only have one size! Why??? For mains, we had the falafel sandwich, pastichio (with grilled veggies) and octopus platter (with rice). Both platters came with salad or soup. The lemon soup was a hard pass, but the salad was fresh. Portions were nice. My dining companion did not like the falafel because it was a bit spicy. The octopus was tender and delicious, and while the pastichio was tasty, it was a bit drier than we have had before. Tzatziki sauce was a bit bland, could have used more garlic. If dining in, bring a jacket because the place is cold inside!

Michelle C.

Best Greek food around. Excellent food that tastes great. Modern clean and friendly. Everything looks delicious but their custard pastry is unbelievable

gail flynn

We recently discovered this wonderful place! The food is excellent and the portions are really amazing! We ordered spinach pie, chicken gyro and a greek salad with chicken gyro! We also love the zucchini chips- crispy, thin and great! It will be on our regular take out favorites!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Laurie G

My most favorite greek spot. Its Super cute. Most important it's Clean and food is fresh!! The young girl at the front is soooooo nice. Good customer service ! Helpful and pleasant!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Gyro, Chicken Souvlaki, Lemon Potatoes

zboxyplayz 2

The best Greek food I’ve ever had!!!(period!)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Gyro Platter

RoseAnn Vercillo

Absolutely the best. Anna is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Gyro, Chicken Souvlaki, Pork Souvlaki, Grilled Octopus, Baklava, Falafel, Lemon Potatoes

Jon Kortmann

Anna & Joanna are wonderful, the lemon potatoes are the most amazing you’ll ever try! I have yet to have anything that isn’t fantastic, and it’s a nice cozy atmosphere.. You won’t regret giving them a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More