Mighty Quinn's Barbeque

829 Franklin Ave, Garden City
(516) 544-2844

Recent Reviews

Glenn T.

My buddy was craving some bbq and I've never had real bbq outside of the south. Got the 3 meat combo with some sides. I'm not a huge fan of the smoked bbq but the taste did deliver I felt. I wanna go back for some of the sides. The concept is fantastic. The menu is so simple I really want to speak to the guy that did it The place is absolute clean and the staff are super friendly. Def a must return. If you wanna grub it's a must go. I actually split the 3 meat combo w a friend and it was enough if we ordered two plates we would've had a lot to take home. Oh yes the whole place smells delish!

Timothy M.

Excellent BBQ Chicken tasty and good fries Did not like having iced tea in a plastic cup

Myrissa W.

Starting from a 1 star when I first ate from them and going to a 5 IS BASED SOLELY ON THE FOOD! Mighty Quinn's came up as a choice close to home for BBQ. Which is great! However, it lacks the needed BBQ flair. Many of the workers seemed to have been drilled like the fast food workers where when you ask for condiments it's a problem. Attitudes seem too big and their handling of the food also is a big failure. Sloppy, sloppy, sloppy. I go mainly for the burnt ends, Brussels sprouts and broccoli salad. I tried to like the chicken but it lacked flavor. The brisket was good but it would have been better if it had more heat (temperature wise), this is my BIGGEST PET PEAVE, their food is JUST WARM, never hot! I believe it's due to their air condition Orion and the fact they serve you from a buffet style. Honestly, I love to just grab and go cause the atmosphere is terrible. Also, for the price they offer they need to focus on their customer service. But I HIGHLY recommend their BURNT ENDS.

Monique P.

We came here for an early Lunch after my sisters graduation. The food is tasty! All the meats are well seasoned and the bbq sauce is just a little extra kick -but it's not needed. It's hard to find good bbq in New York and this is a great spot.

Rick R.

Overall, decent food, but wasn't great. The ordering process was a little confusing and I had multiple questions for the staff prior to ordering. Ribs were ok. Lacked flavor and a little dry. Chicken was poor and undercooked. When ordering, I asked for 2 breasts and was told "no". I would've paid more it but was denied and the chicken was disappointing. Baked beans were solid. Mac & cheese was solid. Portions were small. Bathrooms could've been a lot cleaner. The lock didn't work and there were no towels to dry my hands. There's potential here but the attention to detail needs some work. Do better, folks!

Totoro T.

Had high hope for this place as the reviews are good. We walked in. The wait staff said to go to the back to look at the food, then order using QR code while we could order in the back. Makes no sense. Everything was insanely salty and they even sprinkled a dash of salt on certain food. I will not return.

Tarek E.

Very interesting set-up at this restaurant. When you walk in you are seated at any open table and greeted by a QR Code sign on your table, below which is your table number. Scan the QR code to get to the menu and order your food and drinks, pay on the spot as a guest, or give your contact information, so you don't have to go through this next time Now comes the wait, and voila a waiter appears with your drinks then followed by your food. The waiter will possibly bring a friend with other plates, if your party is large. The plastic wear and one napkin arrive, or were already on the table, cont remember. Anyway there were plenty of those and wet-naps by the entrance. The food was actually very good, served in a recyclable container (composite paper) and paper cups hold your sides. The spare ribs were a dry rub and perfectly smoked! There is a bottle of bbq sauce provided, pickled onions and cucumbers, are provided as condiments. Those, if you run out, are available at the entrance counter for the asking. The sweet yams, Brussels sprouts and the corn fritters as sides, were great and the Mac and cheese was good as well. The atmosphere is casual with a bar available. I will return, but will skip the QR ordering next time and just order at the entrance counter! Definitely worth a visit.

Jimps Jerome

Food was OK. The bake sweet Potatoes was fabulous but the meat could be better. Didn't have a chance to sit down for a drink, hopefully next time I'll will.

Christyn Murdocco

Not only do I love the food from Mighty Quinn's, but I absolutely adore the staff. I just placed our third catering order with them for a large house party where the GM, John took his personal time to help me curate the perfect menu and even offered to deliver it to us - outside of the normal delivery range! Every experience I've had with Mighty Quinn's has been stellar from start to finish - my guests love the food and the process of ordering and delivery is always smooth. Definitely a great solution for your next party - Big thanks to the whole staff for all their help and the great food!

Jeannie T.

Was craving some BBQ and found this spot on Yelp as I was in the neighborhood. Reviews looked promising and it is a very spacious dining room when you enter. Straight to the back is where you can order directly at a counter or plop yourself tableside and scan the QR code to open the menu and ordering platform. Note: if selecting this option, you'll have to give up your cell and email information. I didn't expect that as many restaurants offer this type of ordering without giving away your details but alas, it is what it is. You can always opt out later if you decide it's not for you. And when submitting the order, you put the tip in as well. Later on, a member of the staff brings you your full order. So once you're done eating, you can just head out. So my family and I are easy when it comes to BBQ, everyone loves brisket and Mac and Cheese. So that's always our go to items to order and a sure way to tell if this place will be a hit or miss for us. And the verdict is in, it's a hit! Onto the food: - brisket, yes that was some damn good brisket. Bold flavor, great color, tender and marbled. Just the right amount of fat and oh so moist. I'm totally a fan. - ribs, equally as good. The meat was not fall off the bone tender but it still had a good body to it. I was able to trim off the meat with a plastic knife and little effort so it's a win. Not too charred and burnt which was perfect for me, a little smoky - just right. Should've eaten it with my fingers but I was being neat. Ha - Mac and Cheese, this was a great "adult" style Mac. Peppery and cheesey. The macaroni was Al dente and not overcooked. Again, picky eater child approved so another win. We liked it so much, we ordered a second serving (the pint not the individual portion)! Yeah, we liked it that much! - pork slider didn't look overwhelmingly special but we ordered it to try it. I'm picky about my pulled pork so I didn't try it but hubby says it was good. - brussel sprouts were the surprise veggie that worked out. It had a hint of sweetness, great char from being roasted and it was not tough to eat. Sometimes you get sprouts that are unevenly cooked but these were cooked alright. Tender and delicious. I can't say enough about these. I'd totally return to get BBQ again. Adding it to my list of favorites. And in these neck of the woods, there's only a handful of places to get great BBQ. This works! Bartender was so nice - she took care of our drink order. Mostly bottled iced tea and sweet tea for us. But the wall of specials listed a lot of good stuff to try. Next time.

Isaiah S.

BE CAREFUL with ordering delivery because when they forget stuff that you ordered, WHICH THEY WILL, you can't just walk into the store and bring it to their attention. Even forgot utensils... However, the spare ribs were good. I'll give them a star for that

MzTina W.

OMG! I came for lunch today with a friend as a last minute decision as I was in the neighborhood. I must say I was not disappointed at all. We both had 2 meats from the menu (ribs and burnt ends) it was tender and flavorful. I am a sweet potato fries snob and they were delicious too. The icing on it all was the service was great. Looking forward to coming back again to try something else on the menu.

Kenny Bautista

First off, we (my wife and I) placed our orders and then we were OVER charged, the place was clean and the staff was friendly and courteous. The food was great one thing though; everytime we dine here I'm expecting the burnt ends baked beans to be exactly as it says on the menu "BURNT ENDS" not an ounce of them in the beans, you go to any other Mighty Quinns in NYC and the "BURNT ENDS" are IN the beans sooo much more flavor. A few days later come to see my statement from my bank and they did not deduct the over charge to my card.

Michelle R.

Always great food at this spot! We have come back a few times and it's consistently good. The mac and cheese is my favorite and all the sandwiches are amazing and flavorful. Our server Bella was attentive and friendly. Will be back soon!

Wilson P.

Was super excited to try this place out as the reviews and pictures look great but we were let down by the service and the some of the items we ordered. We walked in from the back around 6 pm and we were the only customer at the ordering stand. You would think that we would get our orders in and gotten our food within 5 mins but no, waited over 15 mins because once we placed our order, they had one person cut the meats, one person getting the sides and one person to ring you up at the end. No problem getting the meats. But the person who was suppose to get the sides, got our order of mac & cheese, then went to put on his gloves (which he was suppose to be wearing), then just disappeared and left us waiting for the rest. The meat person had to come help. After finally getting all of our food and ready to pay, we had to wait once again as the cashier was taking an order over the phone and there was no one else to step in. We had to wait till he finished taking the order as our food was getting cold. It should not take this long esp when there are no other customers. Now to the food we ordered. We ordered the 3 meat platter with Brisket, Burnt Ends and Pulled Pork. Brisket was tender, juicy with a good portion of fat that makes it melt in your mouth. Pulled pork was also surprisingly good. It pulls apart easily and very juicy as well, but needed BBQ sauce to give it flavor. The Burnt Ends was tougher compared to the rest. For sides, we ordered the burnt end bakes beans, mac & cheese and cornbread. Baked beans were good but there were no burnt ends pieces to be found in there. Mac & cheese was decent. Cornbread could have been better if it was served warm. If you walk in from the front, you can seat yourself and use your phone to scan the QR codes on the table to place your orders. They will then bring the food over to your table but I recommend you to order in the back on your own as you can see what meat and sides look the best and order those.

Load More