Casa D'italia Sandwich Shoppe

265 Halstead Ave, Harrison
(914) 835-6370

Recent Reviews

MARIA SKAMANGAS

A staple in Harrison for over 25 years!! I wish I could give them 10 stars, food is phenomenal and Lucy & Steve, and the boys make you feel like family, they are all so warm and welcoming!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy P.

I stopped in for a sandwich and boy am I glad I did! I decided on the Bronx bomber and my friend got the Bronx tale. All I can say is wow! The sandwiches came out toasted and perfectly crisp. My Bronx bomber,roast beef on a garlic wedge with melted cheddar and onions and peppers was absolutely delicious. Sandwiches are large so I took half home. The Bronx tale, which had chicken cutlet pesto sun-dried peppers and provolone was equally delicious! I loved everything about the sandwiches, but next time, I will definitely get it on the seeded bread! I think that would be outstanding! Everyone working behind the counter is friendly, fast-moving and really nice. It's a really clean establishment and I will be back soon! It definitely fulfilled the craving I was having!

Geoff

Great sandwiches, freshly made. Sometimes there may be a wait.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Virginia C.

Never fails to disappoint. They are so clean, organized and friendly. The order is made to perfection. Feeling lucky to live next to a pretty perfect Italian deli.

Charlotte D.

Great sandwiches and family owned! Doesn't get better then that! Agree with many other reviewers that the chicken used in the sandwiches is great!

Chad Jacobson

The staff is very friendly and welcoming. The food on display is always fresh and appealing. I order a chicken sandwich. It had chicken cutlet, mutz, peppers and pesto. The bread is perfectly toasted and came hot out of the panini press. A nice balance of chicken, sauce, and cheese. There is usually a line but it does more very quickly. I highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Prosciutto, Panini, Pesto, Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

Caroline H.

The best sandwiches!! All of their chicken cutlet sandwiches are great. I love the Husky with balsamic glaze. Highly recommend checking this place out - it's worth going out of your way for it.

Nia A.

Hands down one of, if not the best sandwiches I've ever had. The chicken is fresh and cooked to perfection -- no fake chicken meat. The sauces they use are rich with flavor and I love that for the mozzarella they use fresh mozz, not sliced or overly processed. I could eat one of their sandwiches everyday.

Chris Benner

I ordered a delicious chicken parmesan sandwich on a sub roll. The bread is perfectly toasted and soft. A nice balance of chicken, sauce, and cheese. The shoppe had a line and they were very proficient when it comes to service. I recommend 100%. A+

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Big Beard

First time here. The food is excellent. Beautiful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Panini, Pesto

Chef Sterling Smith

Was my favorite sandwich in Harrison. Hit crispy sandwiches. Great espresso.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Prosciutto, Panini, Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

Mark E.

Sensational subs at this place! Was in town for a business trip and needed a quick bite. This spot came HIGHLY recommend from my coworkers and it was easy to see why. Subs were prepared with live in fresh Italian bread with perfect chew factor, meats were luxuriously tender and supple to the tooth, loved their seasoning on the Italian roast beef inside my Bronxe Bomber. Will DEFINITELY be back soon!

Bobs N.

Great local business, been around for years. Good food. Always busy. Everything is delicious. Parking can be a bit challenging but it's worth the hassle.

Tim Krasniqi

Quick stop in for lunch and it was great!Husky special with some pesto… so yummy!

JT C.

Chicken Cutlet Sandwiches are common, but not like these. Worth the ride, the wait, the fight for parking does suck but call your order in ahead of you don't have the time. Never a bad thing had here, and the freshest homemade ingredients. The owners & workers alike are great and it's all about that one word....Consistent! All the sandwiches are top notch. The Meatballs & Cutlets like grandma's. We've had them do sandwich platters for events as well and nothing lacks whatsoever. Casa is where it's at, a Gem in the Sound Shore on Halstead.

Load More