Papa Johns Pizza

411 Furrows Rd, Holbrook
(631) 471-7272

Recent Reviews

David B. Rockin Music & Anime

A few weeks ago,my Dad decided to order some papadias for lunch but the dude on the phone told him that he would have to use his debit or credit card. Usually my Dad orders in person and well,from the sound of it;this employee does NOT want to make ANY papadias!

Deb Bee

This is the worst place ever. The food is horrible. The customer service is even worse. I saw a bug crawling around and ran right out. Go anywhere but here. ?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Deb Mayo

Stay away!! We ordered food to be delivered and asked for the itemized receipt totaling $54.30. The driver never gave it and when we called the store 2 times to ask if they could kindly send it via phone text or email, the manager refused!! This is illegal. It’s needed for reimbursement. We are entitled by law to receive a receipt for purchases. Will be contacting corporate headquarters.

J K

If cash isn’t accepted then DON’T make it an option on mobile.Started eating here while working in TX and OK.Figured I should try it out up here as well.Placed my carry out order, and received a phone call a minute later. An associate was saying that their boss said since I’ve never purchased at the location that cash isn’t acceptable, I need to pay with my card over the phone or my food won’t be made.I said ‘if cash isn’t acceptable then you can cancel the order’. The kid said “okay” and hung up as I was saying “have a good day”.Went to six or seven different stores in the south and never had this issue.Again, if paying cash is an issue then why is it an option?Definitely going to stick to the “mom and pop’s” around here.

Service: 1

Allen Edgar

The food is Okay. Typical fast food pizza. The problem is the delivery driver. He’s very rude and obnoxious. I’d rather not buy from a store who allows such rudeness. Plus there’s obviously better pizza out there. I’m all for supporting local businesses, but I can’t if you are rude.

Food: 4

Service: 2

Mohammed Zakaria

“I recently ordered from Papa John's Pizza and was thoroughly impressed by both the food and the impeccable service. The attentive and knowledgeable staff ensured that our food arrived hot & on time. Provided excellent recommendations and ensured our satisfaction. I can’t recommend Papa John's Pizza enough for a fantastic ordering experience.”

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Syed Atif Ali (Long Island Nomad)

The best cardboard pizza chains in the neighborhood. After giving the local Domino's too many chances we gave up and only order from this Papa John's.Order from the app as they have local deals and you earn Papa Dough. Pickup is always less expensive than delivery or UberEATS.Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap parking available.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

d teng

Great pizza better taste and price than Dominos. Will always use this location!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Geraldine M.

the food at old city pub is awesome, had a patty melt delicious hot and juicy, wait staff was pleasant never had a bad meal here. A plus plus

Galkin Moltisanti

you guys always are on top of your game. love the food from here. these guys know what theyre doing ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JM Ruthless

Usually really good. First time today though having an incompetent answer to a delivery order. I think the girl answering phones today should be retrained and have a better understanding of promotions

Rahil Shaikh

Ordered pizza 30 min before and called after and said they are canceling order. Terrible service didn’t get anything in return.

Ronkonkomadude R.

Expensive for gross Pizza. What is with the service charges to deliver garbage. These guys should spend less on advertising and spend on a better product. You would be better off buying a box of Ellios Pizza. At least Ellios wont make you vomit after eating it.

Enrico F.

Fantastic establishment. My first time ordering from this location, and the pizza was well made. Delivery was fast, and the entire experience, from order to interaction with the driver, was superb. I highly recommend this establishment. Any negative reviews are absurd, especially the review stating you can give Covid to someone through a pizza because precautions are not followed.

Cristie G.

So we ordered delivery today. Pros: Delivery was fast ..like 30 mins. Pretty good! The cheesy bread was awesome...nummy nummy. The cons, well the pizza was ok. It wasn't horrid but wasn't great. Just mediocre. Maybe it's because I live in NY, and the cornucopia of pizza places with authentic NY pizza are literally everywhere. But, we will go back for cheesy bread.

Load More