Amazing food. Amazing service. I come with my girlfriend for the steak and lobster and shrimp gnocchi. Best food of my life. I mean it. Even the bread is to die for. Can’t stop thinking about this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daphna A
We can’t understand all the excellent reviews. We came on a Saturday night and the restaurant was 1/2 empty. Only 1 server was working but lots of bus boys. We were told the stuffed artichoke appetizer special was 4 pieces - we only got 3 deep fried pieces. The server tried telling us she “thought” it was 4, would we like another order. Um, NO! Two of us ordered salad with shrimp. The salads were mostly kale and 1 came without shrimp. The restaurant was kind enough to take 1 salad and the appetizer off the check. The pappardelle was a nice size but too salty. The steak looked delicious. The table across from us got bottles of after dinner drinks on their table to serve themselves. I didn’t see that on the dessert menu! Don’t play favorites, it makes us common folk feel undeserving. Based on the reviews, if we lived closer, we would have maybe give them another chance. Could have just been an “off” night but there are too many amazing restaurants out there than to go back here and be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
M Williams
Food was good but I was disappointed when I went to order a $40+ steak and it was served with french fries. When I asked for anything other the fries the waitress said no substitutions. I ordered something else. (Fries are good with burgers not steak)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
michaelg
We hadn't been back to Catch 25 in some time, but quickly realized how great the place is. A very warm greeting by the owner, John. James, our server, introduced himself, took our cocktail orders, followed by a wonderful presentation of the specials for the evening. We shared the lump crabmeat salad, served in a martini glass. Each entree was delicious- stuffed shrimp topped with lobster meat, half roasted duck, house special pork chop with roasted Brussels sprouts, and linguine with shrimp and clams in a scampi sauce. During the course of our meal, we were visited by James and John several times to inquire about our meals. It won't be too long before we are back for another great dinner
Hal113
My wife and I were celebrating our anniversary which I advised the restaurant of. The food was ok and the service as well. I found it strange that for a steakhouse they had no bone in meat options. They did nothing special for us and did not even mention our anniversary. I would not return as there was nothing special about this restaurant.
Baybreeze
We enjoyed our dinner. Food was very tasty, portions were fair and really good menu selections. Service was exceptional - thank you James - and prices were what you'd expect these days for a high level dining experience. We would go back - but probably during the week for some of the discounts.
Anna Gemmo
Very friendly, music, great Happy Hour
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
m Fortruth
FRESH TO IMPRESS! JOHNY IS THE BEST! ROBERTO TAKES CARE OF U AT THE BAR!!! CATCH 25 GETS *****STARS!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Clams, Calamari, Rock Shrimp, Stuffed Veal Chop
Dan Maffetone
Excellent food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Veal Chop
Kalliope Haniotis
My husband and I had an amazing meal here last night for my birthday. We had the fried calamari, grilled octopus, Caesar salad, stuffed lobster tail, and the hanger steak with an amazing mushroom sauce. The steak was so tender, it was like butter. The food was all delicious from apps to entrees and we really wanted to try a dessert too but were so full because of their large portions. I highly recommend Catch 25 and we will definitely be back soon!
Just came back from dining at this restaurant and couldn’t wait to write a review! The staff was so attentive and very accommodating, we were a party of 6. The drinks and food did not disappoint. Faith was fantastic and kept us happy and engaged. Food and drinks presentation were all beautiful. All in all, an exceptional night with great company. We will def be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari
The food was mediocre. We had two fish dishes; the quality of the fish was fine but the preparation was lacking. The fish had no flavor. The side dishes were better than the main courses. I don't think I have ever eaten in a restaurant that was louder without piped in music. It was like eating on an airport runway. The tables are too close together. This is not a date night/romantic dinner destination.
SusanG
This was our first time dining at Catch25. We were extremely happy we chose to go here for my husband's birthday. Our server, Faith, was simply wonderful. She was so nice, funny and attentive to us. The restaurant was very pretty, and the singer was very mellow so he didn't drown out our conversation. The food - from start to finish was absolutely delicious. We were given warm bread, with a little olive oil drizzled on top - YUM! I had salmon with veggies and everything was delicious. Same for my daughter's halibut. My husband had the crispy duck, very nice size and crispy on the outside and moist on the inside. Everything was freshly made and came out hot. For dessert we shared the creme brûlée. Also, absolutely delicious. We will definitely be going back!
Rebecca Schneider
Came here for the first time this past Saturday to celebrate Valentine’s Day. Considering how packed the restaurant was, the food came out quickly and was very good. I got the special which was sea bass and it was prepared perfectly. Our waitress was very friendly but not very present. It took me a while to flag her down. Also the tables were a little too close for comfort; a woman sitting next to us was able to point to my plate and nearly touch my food. Overall a great experience but I think it would be more enjoyable with some more space in between tables.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Robert Martin
This peculiar shaped restaurant with no right angel walls makes an acceptable fish and flank steak. Food is generally prepared unimaginably with the feel of a standard diner. Prices are acceptable but better fair is obtainable easily elsewhere at the same costs. Staff is pleasant and accommodating.
Amazing food. Amazing service. I come with my girlfriend for the steak and lobster and shrimp gnocchi. Best food of my life. I mean it. Even the bread is to die for. Can’t stop thinking about this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We can’t understand all the excellent reviews. We came on a Saturday night and the restaurant was 1/2 empty. Only 1 server was working but lots of bus boys. We were told the stuffed artichoke appetizer special was 4 pieces - we only got 3 deep fried pieces. The server tried telling us she “thought” it was 4, would we like another order. Um, NO! Two of us ordered salad with shrimp. The salads were mostly kale and 1 came without shrimp. The restaurant was kind enough to take 1 salad and the appetizer off the check. The pappardelle was a nice size but too salty. The steak looked delicious. The table across from us got bottles of after dinner drinks on their table to serve themselves. I didn’t see that on the dessert menu! Don’t play favorites, it makes us common folk feel undeserving. Based on the reviews, if we lived closer, we would have maybe give them another chance. Could have just been an “off” night but there are too many amazing restaurants out there than to go back here and be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Food was good but I was disappointed when I went to order a $40+ steak and it was served with french fries. When I asked for anything other the fries the waitress said no substitutions. I ordered something else. (Fries are good with burgers not steak)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We hadn't been back to Catch 25 in some time, but quickly realized how great the place is. A very warm greeting by the owner, John. James, our server, introduced himself, took our cocktail orders, followed by a wonderful presentation of the specials for the evening. We shared the lump crabmeat salad, served in a martini glass. Each entree was delicious- stuffed shrimp topped with lobster meat, half roasted duck, house special pork chop with roasted Brussels sprouts, and linguine with shrimp and clams in a scampi sauce. During the course of our meal, we were visited by James and John several times to inquire about our meals. It won't be too long before we are back for another great dinner
My wife and I were celebrating our anniversary which I advised the restaurant of. The food was ok and the service as well. I found it strange that for a steakhouse they had no bone in meat options. They did nothing special for us and did not even mention our anniversary. I would not return as there was nothing special about this restaurant.
We enjoyed our dinner. Food was very tasty, portions were fair and really good menu selections. Service was exceptional - thank you James - and prices were what you'd expect these days for a high level dining experience. We would go back - but probably during the week for some of the discounts.
Very friendly, music, great Happy Hour
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
FRESH TO IMPRESS! JOHNY IS THE BEST! ROBERTO TAKES CARE OF U AT THE BAR!!! CATCH 25 GETS *****STARS!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Clams, Calamari, Rock Shrimp, Stuffed Veal Chop
Excellent food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Veal Chop
My husband and I had an amazing meal here last night for my birthday. We had the fried calamari, grilled octopus, Caesar salad, stuffed lobster tail, and the hanger steak with an amazing mushroom sauce. The steak was so tender, it was like butter. The food was all delicious from apps to entrees and we really wanted to try a dessert too but were so full because of their large portions. I highly recommend Catch 25 and we will definitely be back soon!
Restaurantji Recommends
Just came back from dining at this restaurant and couldn’t wait to write a review! The staff was so attentive and very accommodating, we were a party of 6. The drinks and food did not disappoint. Faith was fantastic and kept us happy and engaged. Food and drinks presentation were all beautiful. All in all, an exceptional night with great company. We will def be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari
The food was mediocre. We had two fish dishes; the quality of the fish was fine but the preparation was lacking. The fish had no flavor. The side dishes were better than the main courses. I don't think I have ever eaten in a restaurant that was louder without piped in music. It was like eating on an airport runway. The tables are too close together. This is not a date night/romantic dinner destination.
This was our first time dining at Catch25. We were extremely happy we chose to go here for my husband's birthday. Our server, Faith, was simply wonderful. She was so nice, funny and attentive to us. The restaurant was very pretty, and the singer was very mellow so he didn't drown out our conversation. The food - from start to finish was absolutely delicious. We were given warm bread, with a little olive oil drizzled on top - YUM! I had salmon with veggies and everything was delicious. Same for my daughter's halibut. My husband had the crispy duck, very nice size and crispy on the outside and moist on the inside. Everything was freshly made and came out hot. For dessert we shared the creme brûlée. Also, absolutely delicious. We will definitely be going back!
Came here for the first time this past Saturday to celebrate Valentine’s Day. Considering how packed the restaurant was, the food came out quickly and was very good. I got the special which was sea bass and it was prepared perfectly. Our waitress was very friendly but not very present. It took me a while to flag her down. Also the tables were a little too close for comfort; a woman sitting next to us was able to point to my plate and nearly touch my food. Overall a great experience but I think it would be more enjoyable with some more space in between tables.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
This peculiar shaped restaurant with no right angel walls makes an acceptable fish and flank steak. Food is generally prepared unimaginably with the feel of a standard diner. Prices are acceptable but better fair is obtainable easily elsewhere at the same costs. Staff is pleasant and accommodating.