Hosted a 40th Birthday party for a friend in their private party room last night. In a word...fantastic! Al and Greg were extremely attentive and made my guests feel welcome. Many commented on how good the food was and the mixed drinks were well balanced and tasty. The room itself is large enough to feel comfortable but not cavernous. I was free to bring my own themed decor. The private bar is so convenient, guests don't have to leave the room to get a drink. Do not hesitate to book your next party or event here, you won't regret it--they make it so easy. Thank you Al and team!
Michael Mackney
Food was amazing with an incredible atmosphere. Everyone is extremely friendly and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leon Zohrabian
My family and I were surprised to see some empty tables on Valentine’s Day and even more surprised after we had an amazing dinner. Fresh and delicious food at reasonable prices. Best chicken parm I ever had (tastefully breaded with tender organic chicken), crispy pizzas and fresh/large fish filet portion. Service was friendly and quick. Chef knows what they’re doing back there. Please come and eat here for the sake of yourselves and us because we want this place to last and you will too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Florentine, Veal Parmigiana, Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
Nora Z.
First, went there for a surprise birthday party and the food was great - salad, eggplant, bread rolls, fish, chicken - all tasted fresh. Second time we came for lunch and the third time we went as a group to dinner and I had the Rigatoni Primavera with organic grilled chicken, not heavy and tasted fresh, my brother had the organic chicken parmigiana and said it was one of the best he had, my sister in law and mother had the sole Francese which came in a generous portion. The kids had pizza and Caesar salad which they liked as well. We were very pleased.
Sandra A
I used to really enjoy this place... But since bad experiences kept me away for a while and decided to give it another try albeit thru take out. Still disappointed... Ordered the cacio e pepe and found it very dry and bland. I had to add olive oil, salt and pepper to lift it up. The boneless chicken scarp was a better dish but I found the size of the cutlets small. Based on other reviews maybe dining in is a better option.
Food: 2
Justin DeMaio
Food was good. Their arugula pizzaette was phenomenal. The bread can be warmed a bit. Overall a good place, with tasty food, and GREAT service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kevin Sullivan
I had eggplant parm, which was nicely plated and delicious. The staff was very friendly, but professional. We will definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexandra Cassidy
Love this place! Food is excellent and everyone working there is really sweet. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tisha Mathlin
Beautiful atmosphere! Compliments to the bartender for providing me with the best lemonade drop ever!Lost a star because our entrees was served at different time, which left an awkward moment on our table, i had my food and my significant other was without for a good 3 minutes.And it wasn’t a busy night!I will visit again. Will update if there is any changes!
Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Crab
Aleia Isoldi
Always such a treat, the salmon is my favorite around. Go out of my way to order it and I don’t even live in Huntington.
what a wonderful and unexpected delight. This is like Huntington's best kept secret. From outside, it looks small and ordinary...but when you enter, you are so pleasantly surprised! Tall ceilings, elegant design, tasteful beauty, and all the ambience of Italy. (Even the music that drew me in from the sidewalk!) THE FOOD IS SUPERB!! mouthwatering . This is an ideal place for a romantic dinner for two or a large group of family and friends. We had a 60th surprise birthday. The way Al the owner set up the room almost made me cry, it was so beautiful . Cannot recommend highly enough
I2167LCbarbaram
We had a surprise 60th Birthday dinner party for my friend. It was wonderful in every way. Al is an excellent host. I was stunned at how lovely the room he prepared looked. Much care and attention! Every single one of the 15 people in attendance remarked on how delicious the food was. (Eggplant melted in my mouth) The service was friendly and congenial. I am so impressed with Eatalia. And so appreciative. Highly recommend!!
Andrea G.
The service is nice and pretty quick. The food is good. Ambiance is nice and pretty spacious.
Marie C.
Had a very good lunch here, sole francese. That wasn't the best part. The service here is extraordinary, friendly, wonderful. This is the second time that they have been very helpful. After lunch one hot day, I was waiting on their outside bench for the HART bus to pick me up--I'm an old lady. The bus was late. The owner or manager came outside and invited me back in, served me a cold drink, and offered to call the bus company. As he was on the phone, the bus appeared outside. A service person, a guy in whites, ran out to hold the bus for me. What more could I want? They are very special people.
John R.
Great food and really nice size portions! Service was great! I will go back!! Baked Clams Chicken Milanese Penne Bolognese All great!!
Hosted a 40th Birthday party for a friend in their private party room last night. In a word...fantastic! Al and Greg were extremely attentive and made my guests feel welcome. Many commented on how good the food was and the mixed drinks were well balanced and tasty. The room itself is large enough to feel comfortable but not cavernous. I was free to bring my own themed decor. The private bar is so convenient, guests don't have to leave the room to get a drink. Do not hesitate to book your next party or event here, you won't regret it--they make it so easy. Thank you Al and team!
Food was amazing with an incredible atmosphere. Everyone is extremely friendly and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I were surprised to see some empty tables on Valentine’s Day and even more surprised after we had an amazing dinner. Fresh and delicious food at reasonable prices. Best chicken parm I ever had (tastefully breaded with tender organic chicken), crispy pizzas and fresh/large fish filet portion. Service was friendly and quick. Chef knows what they’re doing back there. Please come and eat here for the sake of yourselves and us because we want this place to last and you will too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Florentine, Veal Parmigiana, Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
First, went there for a surprise birthday party and the food was great - salad, eggplant, bread rolls, fish, chicken - all tasted fresh. Second time we came for lunch and the third time we went as a group to dinner and I had the Rigatoni Primavera with organic grilled chicken, not heavy and tasted fresh, my brother had the organic chicken parmigiana and said it was one of the best he had, my sister in law and mother had the sole Francese which came in a generous portion. The kids had pizza and Caesar salad which they liked as well. We were very pleased.
I used to really enjoy this place... But since bad experiences kept me away for a while and decided to give it another try albeit thru take out. Still disappointed... Ordered the cacio e pepe and found it very dry and bland. I had to add olive oil, salt and pepper to lift it up. The boneless chicken scarp was a better dish but I found the size of the cutlets small. Based on other reviews maybe dining in is a better option.
Food: 2
Food was good. Their arugula pizzaette was phenomenal. The bread can be warmed a bit. Overall a good place, with tasty food, and GREAT service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I had eggplant parm, which was nicely plated and delicious. The staff was very friendly, but professional. We will definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place! Food is excellent and everyone working there is really sweet. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful atmosphere! Compliments to the bartender for providing me with the best lemonade drop ever!Lost a star because our entrees was served at different time, which left an awkward moment on our table, i had my food and my significant other was without for a good 3 minutes.And it wasn’t a busy night!I will visit again. Will update if there is any changes!
Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Crab
Always such a treat, the salmon is my favorite around. Go out of my way to order it and I don’t even live in Huntington.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
what a wonderful and unexpected delight. This is like Huntington's best kept secret. From outside, it looks small and ordinary...but when you enter, you are so pleasantly surprised! Tall ceilings, elegant design, tasteful beauty, and all the ambience of Italy. (Even the music that drew me in from the sidewalk!) THE FOOD IS SUPERB!! mouthwatering . This is an ideal place for a romantic dinner for two or a large group of family and friends. We had a 60th surprise birthday. The way Al the owner set up the room almost made me cry, it was so beautiful . Cannot recommend highly enough
We had a surprise 60th Birthday dinner party for my friend. It was wonderful in every way. Al is an excellent host. I was stunned at how lovely the room he prepared looked. Much care and attention! Every single one of the 15 people in attendance remarked on how delicious the food was. (Eggplant melted in my mouth) The service was friendly and congenial. I am so impressed with Eatalia. And so appreciative. Highly recommend!!
The service is nice and pretty quick. The food is good. Ambiance is nice and pretty spacious.
Had a very good lunch here, sole francese. That wasn't the best part. The service here is extraordinary, friendly, wonderful. This is the second time that they have been very helpful. After lunch one hot day, I was waiting on their outside bench for the HART bus to pick me up--I'm an old lady. The bus was late. The owner or manager came outside and invited me back in, served me a cold drink, and offered to call the bus company. As he was on the phone, the bus appeared outside. A service person, a guy in whites, ran out to hold the bus for me. What more could I want? They are very special people.
Great food and really nice size portions! Service was great! I will go back!! Baked Clams Chicken Milanese Penne Bolognese All great!!