From the moment I walked in, I felt like this was going to be a special experience.The owner, Deseree didn't disappoint. She was welcoming, helpful, personable and had a real positive energy. You can sense her pride in the store and that she loved her job.The selection of fish was really fresh and proved to be very delicious when I brought it home for dinner. Really, really fantastic!The fresh cooked shrimp and cocktail sauce were some of the best I have ever had eaten. In addition, the seafood pot pie was also outstanding.Btw...there were some really interesting cheeses to buy as well. I will check that out next time!I really enjoyed this shopping experience and will definitely come back!
Bryan K.
I've been going to Marty's for over 10 years now--and if you're local to the Huntington area (or LI for that matter) you know there are no shortage of seafood places (tbh I still frequent some of them))... but what sets Marty's apart is one the customer service is on point--always personable and friendly--two--selection is incredible especially the kebabs!! Three they have an incredible prepared/frozen section including some fresh beautiful artisanal cheeses that are rare and hard to find!! Incredibly solid seafood+ market!!!
John Donegan
The wonderfully accommodating owner handled our minor mix up with aplomb and prepared a poached salmon that looked fabulous and tasted great. Great food, great people.
Claudia Dowling
Always fresh seafood and wonderful service.
Elsa F.
The "seafood salad" is mostly green peppers. Disappointed. First and last trip to Marty's! Of the pint bowl of "seafood salad" his much was pepper and onions. Definitely not worth $15.
J Bar
Always fresh, not the cheapest but you get what you pay for.
Claudia Squillace
The best service! Delicious entrees! Excellent sushi!!
Heather B.
I love this place. All of the staff there especially Jake are so great. Place is always so clean and they always have great fresh food ready to cook. Such a beautiful fish store with much more .
Peter Buffa
Seafood is always the freshest...best shrimp on Long Island. Service is always kind and professional. Desiree continues to do a great job
Mitch M.
It's a shame all of these 5 star reviews seem to be written by 1 person. Truth be told. Clam sauce has zero taste. Salmon in Thai sauce tasteless and my wife and I got upset stomachs. No soft shell crabs in season. Few choices. I love the convenience and deplore writing negative reviews. But this place is terrible.
Best Manhattan clam chowder this side of Manhattan! Always fast and friendly service, freshest fish and an excellent selection of pre-made meals that won't disappoint!
Gary Petruzzelli
Fresh seafood. Absolutely the best shrimp around!
Johnasina Cummings
Great quality seafood
Geri Barnett
The absolute most amazing cooked and cleaned shrimp anywhere!!Their shrimp is plumb and moist and cooked perfectly! A beautiful presentation and everyone commented best shrimp they have ever had.Cannot recommend it more highly. Do not buy anywhere else, located in Huntington their cooked lobster for lobster rolls is also outstanding!
From the moment I walked in, I felt like this was going to be a special experience.The owner, Deseree didn't disappoint. She was welcoming, helpful, personable and had a real positive energy. You can sense her pride in the store and that she loved her job.The selection of fish was really fresh and proved to be very delicious when I brought it home for dinner. Really, really fantastic!The fresh cooked shrimp and cocktail sauce were some of the best I have ever had eaten. In addition, the seafood pot pie was also outstanding.Btw...there were some really interesting cheeses to buy as well. I will check that out next time!I really enjoyed this shopping experience and will definitely come back!
I've been going to Marty's for over 10 years now--and if you're local to the Huntington area (or LI for that matter) you know there are no shortage of seafood places (tbh I still frequent some of them))... but what sets Marty's apart is one the customer service is on point--always personable and friendly--two--selection is incredible especially the kebabs!! Three they have an incredible prepared/frozen section including some fresh beautiful artisanal cheeses that are rare and hard to find!! Incredibly solid seafood+ market!!!
The wonderfully accommodating owner handled our minor mix up with aplomb and prepared a poached salmon that looked fabulous and tasted great. Great food, great people.
Always fresh seafood and wonderful service.
The "seafood salad" is mostly green peppers. Disappointed. First and last trip to Marty's! Of the pint bowl of "seafood salad" his much was pepper and onions. Definitely not worth $15.
Always fresh, not the cheapest but you get what you pay for.
The best service! Delicious entrees! Excellent sushi!!
I love this place. All of the staff there especially Jake are so great. Place is always so clean and they always have great fresh food ready to cook. Such a beautiful fish store with much more .
Seafood is always the freshest...best shrimp on Long Island. Service is always kind and professional. Desiree continues to do a great job
It's a shame all of these 5 star reviews seem to be written by 1 person. Truth be told. Clam sauce has zero taste. Salmon in Thai sauce tasteless and my wife and I got upset stomachs. No soft shell crabs in season. Few choices. I love the convenience and deplore writing negative reviews. But this place is terrible.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best Manhattan clam chowder this side of Manhattan! Always fast and friendly service, freshest fish and an excellent selection of pre-made meals that won't disappoint!
Fresh seafood. Absolutely the best shrimp around!
Great quality seafood
The absolute most amazing cooked and cleaned shrimp anywhere!!Their shrimp is plumb and moist and cooked perfectly! A beautiful presentation and everyone commented best shrimp they have ever had.Cannot recommend it more highly. Do not buy anywhere else, located in Huntington their cooked lobster for lobster rolls is also outstanding!
Good fish