Pete’s Pitaria and Other Fine Foods

4259 Austin Blvd, Island Park
(516) 432-1473

Recent Reviews

Joe Coppola

I get fuel prices being extremely high food shortages ……BUT a gyro dinner, grape leaves and a order of lemon potatoes ( looks like side order) I did use Uber eats there fee was $8.50Even with that fee there is no way my total was $51.00sad part is I enjoyed there food for years until today

Austin A

Best greek around. Portions are huge. Favorite is a greek salad with gyro meat, humus and yogurt sauce with pitas on the side to split with another person. Super friendly and always busy.

Justin Zaleski

Always banging and fresh!!!! Try the bbq marinated lamb gyro. The best in north east America

H Jonathan Brass

Best Greek food around the gyro meat is amazing and the hummus is rich and creamy and loaded with flavor the tahini is fantastic the pitas are fresh and the spinach pie is great

Cooper Duffy

Good quality Greek/Lebanese style food. Owner came over to see how we were doing. They accommodated our large party even though it was near closing time.

Skylar B.

New management but same great food and looks the same. The gyros and hummus are to die for!

Melanie R.

I love food here. The interior is very cute. I ordered the grilled chicken platter with Israeli salad, hummus and tahini. It was fresh and tasty, the taziki was very good. The service was great. I highly recommend this place.

Paul Fetscher

Best Gyro I've had since Istanbul

M K

Salads are always fresh and delish. Reliably delicious every time. This is a family fave :) Bring back the lamb, Leo!

Neil

Good food all of the time...

Герман Гаджикеримов

Great and tasty food, I love the atmosphere the place has, and the employees were helpful. I will definitely come back.

Greg Bones

The food is good, but the staff has often made inappropriate/judgey comments about what I am ordering. When I order take out from them, I usually buy enough food for two meals for two people. On FIVE separate occasions, either the owner, or an employee has remarked “wow that is a lot of food.” These comments have made me feel incredibly uncomfortable, and almost want to cancel the entire order. If it happens again, I do not plan on ordering from them EVER AGAIN. This is the only restaurant that ever makes a comment about the quantity of food I buy.

Bridget K.

How have I not tried here earlier ?!? Holy smokes !!! This is the best Greek food around!! My boyfriend (who is Greek) got the gyro platter with lamb and chicken. I got the same dish but with only chicken. The salad was FRESH, the meat was good, and the pita was homemade!!! Quality food is hard to come by these days. The girls behind the counter were so sweet too! Ps, you MUST try the Baklava

Greg B.

The food is good, but the staff has often made inappropriate/judgey comments about what I am ordering. When I order take out from them, I usually buy enough food for two meals for two people. On FIVE separate occasions, either the owner, or an employee has remarked "wow that is a lot of food." These comments have made me feel incredibly uncomfortable, and almost want to cancel the entire order. If it happens again, I do not plan on ordering from them EVER AGAIN. This is the only restaurant that ever makes a comment about the quantity of food I buy.

Liz W.

Safety precautions are taken according to CDC guidelines. Food is decent depending on what you order; however, the cheese and other pies are very dry. They only give one pita for the platters which is at minimum two needed. Cheap with the yogurt sauce too, all the platters need more than one otherwise it's flavorless. The falafel is impossible to eat without a sauce to go with it because it's so dry. Owner is VERY rude. Doesn't attend to or care about customers needs. Rather curse at a customer than remedy the situation. He is rude to his employees too as I witnessed him yell at one of the girls who work there. Some days restaurant is very dirty-as if the tables aren't cleaned whatsoever and other days it's somewhat clean except the floor. The inconsistency is what will never make me give them my business again. Between the owners attitude, atmosphere, and food, it's not worth the money.

Load More

Pete’s Pitaria and Other Fine Foods

4259 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558
(516) 432-1473