Tellers: An American Chophouse

605 Main St, Islip
(631) 277-7070

Recent Reviews

Claudia Barnes

Very eloquent dining services. Salmon was delicious.Parking: Ample parking in the back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crispy Calamari

Joanne Valeo

Went for lunch. This is the first time we Sat in the lounge area and it very nice. Comfortable and quiet. Food was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Baby Wedge Salad, Tellers Black Label Burger, Duck Fat Fries

Lawrence Galiano

Good steakhouse with excellent service and atmosphere. Sat in upstairs area, very cozy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tellers Duck Fat Fries

Shaun Sharp

I’ll never go back. They undercooked my steak on a Tuesday night back in February and didn’t really care. They recooked it three times and should be embarrassed with what they actually served me - I wish I had pictures. So probably just a gamble but for $69 I expect it to come out how it’s ordered the first time - it ruined the entire experience. Have fun out there. While not perfect I seem to have better luck and more consistency at the Scotto Brothers restaurants.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

George Gentile

The staff was amazing and very kind. The food was awesome can't say enough great things about tellers. We will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patricia Mercer

The food was delicious! The staff was all friendly and welcoming. I felt at home here. I'll definitely come back for my next big event. I got the rack of lamb, and the creamed spinach. They were both delicious and cooked perfectly. My fiancè got the cowgirl ribeye and the duck fat fries. I tried both his steak and fries and they were also delicious. Absolutely no complaints here. If yoh're thinking of going, stop thinking! Just go :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

dk 1057

I tried the Wellington filet mignon and they were good, and then I tried the crème brûlée and it was the best crème brûlée I have ever

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee

KK78

Everything was amazing! Our waiter, Michael, was so friendly and professional. He was always there when he needed something, without being overbearing. The crispy calamari, Wellington, and housemade tator tots were our favorites. Desserts on the house for a birthday celebration was greatly appreciated and thoughtful! The banana cream pie is to die for!

tpick05

Stephanie is the best waitress!!!!

I always love going to Teller's to have a great time and have great food while doing so. Whether it's with the wife or a good time with the boys, Teller's never disappoints.

Amanda Gonzalez

The food was overall DELICIOUS. My favorite was the "tater tots". Waitstaff was proactive and attentive. The atmosphere was very noisy though and just very overwhelming with how loud the dinning room was just from the other guests conversations.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

AndrewT

Always a good experience at Tellers but we haven't been here in a while as we have been trying out other chophouses. We came back last night and the fillet mignon was just good; cooked right but it just lacked the mmmmm factor. The wedge salad and lump crap were our favorites for the night. The mashed potatoes were a bit pasty and the Brussels sprouts were tasty but again not delicious. I'm not sure why they don't cut the bottom of the sprout off like everyone else bc that bottom piece of the sprout should not be served. Drinks were really good. I think the tables are too close together. In our case we had to sit next to a couple who had a baby and that's always annoying. Why take an infant to a high end steak house I just don't get it. Overall we will return to tellers but the steak needs to be better. I can name 5 places with a better fillet.

Evelin

We enjoyed a beautiful birthday lunch for both my parents. The service was unmatched. Rob was kind enough to hand my parents some gift cards towards our next visit, which we cannot wait for! The food was simply delectable. The lunch menu had an option for everyone. We were highly impressed and give this restaurant a 10/10!

Zoe Chiam

We love Tellers. The restaurant is beautiful, the food is delicious, and the servers and staff are wonderful. They go above and beyond to make sure that everything is delightful, and that you feel like warm and welcomed guests. Much of the staff has been there for many years, which adds to the ambiance of the restaurant; it is enjoyable to be in a space where the people working hard to make it an amazing experience seem to enjoy it, and are treated well enough to want to stay. Every time we go, we walk away too full and very happy. We’re grateful for them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Skyler V

Most overrated restaurant in the area. I’ll start off by saying that the staff are absolutely amazing, but the food is not worth the price at all. Last time I was here, they charged for bread! When you walk in here, you’re expecting to pay a lot, but a charge for bread is insane. The food is mediocre at best, never had anything worth coming back for. Over the years, it’s gotten more expensive and the quality is just not up to par. I would save some money and go somewhere else.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Load More

Tellers: An American Chophouse

605 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
(631) 277-7070