Jimmy John's

122 N Aurora St, Ithaca
(607) 645-0075

Recent Reviews

C. Zachary Woods

I’m a big fan of Jimmy John’s. I’ve been to most of the locations in New York. I’ve never been to a Jimmy John’s that didn’t have public restrooms until now. There’s a restroom in there but they won’t let you use it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Pete MacAnanny

This location constantly delivers a solid sandwich, and usually faster than any other option in town. I consider it a hidden gem and its become a regular lunch go-to. They have never screwed up an order and the rewards are pretty solid.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carolann Tracy

I ordered a tuna sandwich. They give you a lot .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slim

Veronica Silverstein

I love this place and Troy is the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Real Potato Chips, Gourmet Veggie Club

James Hundley

Posted hours are not accurate. Be careful of when you arrive.

Food: 3

Service: 2

S P (S.P.)

Perfect combination but the ham just a bit too salty.

Leon

Fast, consistent service. Can’t ask for more.

Charles Hayward

Tried to go last night at 6pm. Google said they were open. They weren't. Went down the street to Shortstop and had a GREAT sub. I like JJ but they are inconsistent.

Anna Briglia

Absolutely awful service. Store closed down and left Uber eats on. Uber Eats said they couldn’t resolve the issue since jimmy johns uses private drivers. Placed order at 5 pm, waited for three hours and no one bothered to cancel the order or reach out. Voicemail not set up in order to resolve issue.

Gabby&Ashton Meade

This location started pulling phantom charges on my card. I started getting random $10 charges on my card from here even though my order was never that expensive. Also there were repeated instances when employees would just be ragging on customers in the back and it just felt like a rude and unprofessional environment.

pat shaffer

Honestly I am a big fan of the brand and the folks at this location... But thier hours are lies. Call before heading over. DO NOT trust thier Google map hours

Bake and Shake

Super rude employees and the food was not great at all. Only 1 type of bread and 1 type of cheese and very overpriced. They don’t accept Apple Pay either. Do not try.

JR Moss

Best healthy option from a fast food place. Try the unwich, you’ll never go back.

P. O.

Jimmy John's has the best subs. Fresh cold cut and toppings. A little pricey. But superb.

Jackie Lewinthal

Fast service and good food but I wish this location accepted rewards.

Load More