Mama Teresa's Pizzeria

139 College Ave, Ithaca
(607) 272-6262

Recent Reviews

Kieran Stewart

I ordered my pizza last year and it still hasn’t shown up. ?Parking: I ordered delivery.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice Pizza, Garlic Knots

Mitchel Schemenauer

Accidentally didn’t read reviews before ordering from here. It’s been 2 hours and we still don’t have our food. The delivery guy finally called and wanted us to give him step by step directions on how to get to our house. We never got our pizza

Lee Zoller

Ordered a pizza at 12:05am for a 12:46am delivery. Pizzeria said it would be 5-10 minutes twice after 12:46am as it was out for delivery. Drive called at 2:08am to deliver. I declined and the pizzeria will not refund the order. Hard to be their inability to delivery a timely pizza is now my loss.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mitch. S.

Accidentally didn’t read reviews before ordering from here. It’s been 2 hours and we still don’t have our food. The delivery guy finally called and wanted us to give him step by step directions on how to get to our house. We never got our pizza

Walker Lee

Great pizza and mozzarella sticks! Our go-to pizza delivery joint on dungeons & dragons night.

Melina Stockton

I ordered from there last night and Will never order again. I figured I'd give it another try since the last time I ordered was 5 years ago but NO. The first time my chicken wings were literally raw, and this time they were bright pink and the pizza was not good either. ? extremely disgusted.

Pedro Sorto III

Great pizza and service

Johan Björck

got wrong order

Michael Pinnisi

Disgusting, unsanitary conditions. Food is terrible to just about any other pizza joint in Ithaca would be a better option.

Zoë L.

Ordered before I read the reviews then was super scared to eat my food by the time it got here. Clam chowder just smelled totally wrong so I didn't eat it, the sandwich I got was fine, and my smoothie tasted like a pixi stick and the cup was just lined with sugar. Unfortunately it is like the reviews said. :(

Athena Ruhl

You will get better quality and tastier food from the gas station.

Aaron Haupt

Wanted to order pizzas on the way through Ithaca, ordered ahead of the time, placed it online. Glad I chose cash. Got there - lights on, food out, even their two "Open" signs flashing... But no one there, doors locked. After I got there- had gotten a call from 'Slice' telling me they couldn't confirm, as no one answered for them either.

William Scharnagle

Restaurant is closed... Enough said

Wilson H Smalls

The worse place EVER! I'm so glad there closed. Wow can't believe a place like that was open.

Leo O'Campo

PIzza is OK, but has declined in quality since the move from Collegetown.

Load More