The next stop on my CertaPro Painters Pizza challenge was Amores in Katonah. Lots of options in the display case. I went with the meat lovers and the caprese. Cookies JUST came out of the oven and the place smelled amazing. Had to grab me one of those. Staff was friendly, a good experience and I’d go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
antonio pullano
I had the pleasure of stopping by to pick up a pie for the family on the way home from work. I was recommended by a friend I work with at CertaPro Painters who had stopped by at an earlier date. I had to try the Sicilian pie, it did not disappoint. It looked so good when I picked it up, I had to sneak in a slice before I made it back to the car. Great customer service and fantastic pizza. I look forward to stopping by again with the crew during the season!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SPD
Had a slice of Nonna’s best, probably one of the best slices I had recently. Staff was friendly and welcoming. Since I work for CertaPro Painters, having a local pizza shop so close to our office is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Chocolate Chip Cookies
Lucas Blair
I’m upgrading my 2 star review from opening week to 4. Pizza is good and service is much improved. Much better experience on second visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lolph
Definitely my new favorite pizza shop, I was a little skeptical at first because it opened on the same block as another restaurant but they are hands down the best pizza in Katonah and they also do very well beyond just pizza, salads sandwiches and many more.
Ordered the vegetable lasagna for Christmas and it was amazing! Half a tray would probably feed ten good eaters. Best we ever had - lots of vegetables and perfectly cooked. Not mushy. Delicious!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathleen Kulwin
AWESOME GOOD!!!!!!Prepared with love Delicious assortment of freshly made pizza!!Grandma’s pizza, Salad pizza etcFettuccine Alfredo with chicken Yum!!!?Chicken Scarpariello with chicken and sausage with sweet and spicy peppers to die for!!!The meat lasagna light and flavorful!!!!!Ciabatta bread and garden salads!!Soups are incredible-Escarole and white bean delicious!!And don’t forget the tiramisu, fresh cannolis and biscottiNever a wrong choice hereKathy Kulwin loyal customer for life……………
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calabrese Square Pizza, Shrimp Wrap, Calzone, Angus Road House Burger, House-Made Coleslaw, Margherita Pizza, San Gennaro Square Pizza, Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sub Hot, Chocolate Chip Cookies, Arugula Pizza Large
After (Finally) Stopping in a few days ago for some (SLAMMING) Slices w/ a Lake Lincolndale Bestie? I got Delivery of one of the BEST Lasagnas I've EVER had - & I'm a Chef - From the girl who took my order, Maren - A Happy, helpful & Smart Camper - I'm in Love, Already! Seriously - Homemade Pasta Sheets? A Solid Bolognese? NOT too much Mozzarella? Over the TOP great. Spoke to Vinny, the Owner after the Slices from Heaven ( Amazing Texture & Crunch on the Dough as well). - Great Guy!This Clean, Mean, Awesome place he has created is really special. 5
Clare Panno
Gluten Free and YUMMY pizza! Enjoyed the florentine (spinach, sausage, ricotta, garlic and mozzarella) with a crunchy but tender GF crust. Vincent even made me a bowl of chicken soup without the pasta. Amore is our new fav for pizza and more. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julianna H.
Their pizza was so good! Fiancé had a delicious spinach roll with tons of very garlicky spinach, I had a pepperoni/ricotta slice and a veggie slice. All three things were fabulous and the wait staff were quick and kind. Very nice place for a slice, good calm ambiance and a clean space.
Billy Turbert
Mmmmmmmmm yeah, it’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gene Jones
Try the warm paninis...they are exceptional!Our favorites are the Chicken Florentine and Grilled Vegetable. We also enjoy the very friendly atmosphere created by the people behind the counter. They truly understand the value of being a community restaurant.
Fantastic!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The next stop on my CertaPro Painters Pizza challenge was Amores in Katonah. Lots of options in the display case. I went with the meat lovers and the caprese. Cookies JUST came out of the oven and the place smelled amazing. Had to grab me one of those. Staff was friendly, a good experience and I’d go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I had the pleasure of stopping by to pick up a pie for the family on the way home from work. I was recommended by a friend I work with at CertaPro Painters who had stopped by at an earlier date. I had to try the Sicilian pie, it did not disappoint. It looked so good when I picked it up, I had to sneak in a slice before I made it back to the car. Great customer service and fantastic pizza. I look forward to stopping by again with the crew during the season!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a slice of Nonna’s best, probably one of the best slices I had recently. Staff was friendly and welcoming. Since I work for CertaPro Painters, having a local pizza shop so close to our office is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Chocolate Chip Cookies
I’m upgrading my 2 star review from opening week to 4. Pizza is good and service is much improved. Much better experience on second visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Definitely my new favorite pizza shop, I was a little skeptical at first because it opened on the same block as another restaurant but they are hands down the best pizza in Katonah and they also do very well beyond just pizza, salads sandwiches and many more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Margherita Pizza
Utterly flavorless dough, sauce, and cheese combined into a pathetic pizza. Skimpy on the cheese too, not that it matters when it was flavorless.
Food: 2
Their Greek salad pizza is amazing. Lots of vegetarian options. Friendly staff.Kid-friendliness: There is a kids' menu. Staff welcomes children
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Melanzane Pizza, Calzone, Garlic Knots, Margherita Pizza
Ordered the vegetable lasagna for Christmas and it was amazing! Half a tray would probably feed ten good eaters. Best we ever had - lots of vegetables and perfectly cooked. Not mushy. Delicious!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AWESOME GOOD!!!!!!Prepared with love Delicious assortment of freshly made pizza!!Grandma’s pizza, Salad pizza etcFettuccine Alfredo with chicken Yum!!!?Chicken Scarpariello with chicken and sausage with sweet and spicy peppers to die for!!!The meat lasagna light and flavorful!!!!!Ciabatta bread and garden salads!!Soups are incredible-Escarole and white bean delicious!!And don’t forget the tiramisu, fresh cannolis and biscottiNever a wrong choice hereKathy Kulwin loyal customer for life……………
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calabrese Square Pizza, Shrimp Wrap, Calzone, Angus Road House Burger, House-Made Coleslaw, Margherita Pizza, San Gennaro Square Pizza, Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sub Hot, Chocolate Chip Cookies, Arugula Pizza Large
Restaurantji Recommends
After (Finally) Stopping in a few days ago for some (SLAMMING) Slices w/ a Lake Lincolndale Bestie? I got Delivery of one of the BEST Lasagnas I've EVER had - & I'm a Chef - From the girl who took my order, Maren - A Happy, helpful & Smart Camper - I'm in Love, Already! Seriously - Homemade Pasta Sheets? A Solid Bolognese? NOT too much Mozzarella? Over the TOP great. Spoke to Vinny, the Owner after the Slices from Heaven ( Amazing Texture & Crunch on the Dough as well). - Great Guy!This Clean, Mean, Awesome place he has created is really special. 5
Gluten Free and YUMMY pizza! Enjoyed the florentine (spinach, sausage, ricotta, garlic and mozzarella) with a crunchy but tender GF crust. Vincent even made me a bowl of chicken soup without the pasta. Amore is our new fav for pizza and more. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their pizza was so good! Fiancé had a delicious spinach roll with tons of very garlicky spinach, I had a pepperoni/ricotta slice and a veggie slice. All three things were fabulous and the wait staff were quick and kind. Very nice place for a slice, good calm ambiance and a clean space.
Mmmmmmmmm yeah, it’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Try the warm paninis...they are exceptional!Our favorites are the Chicken Florentine and Grilled Vegetable. We also enjoy the very friendly atmosphere created by the people behind the counter. They truly understand the value of being a community restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5