Mario's Pizzeria of Levittown

3489 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown
(516) 520-4444

Recent Reviews

Narinder L.

The pizza is excellent. Especially their penne vodka slice. The staff is always friendly and the wait time is always reasonable, plus it's great and affordable pizza.

Geraldine M.

Been coming to Mario's since they opened. Love there pizza. Manager & assistant manager very nice and accommodating for the pizza I ask for. Food is also delicious.

Glen H.

I had two slices and they were just the right mixture of sauce and cheese. The crust could have been thinner, but that's a personal preference. The place is very clean and decently decorated. More than enough tables and they don't hurry you out. Pizza came quick and was delivered to my table. The people who work there are very courteous, helpful and seem to care about their store and customers. Glad I stopped by!

Ruben Q.

Ever since portofinos closed, Mario's has become my go to spot for pizza. Slices are pretty good, nice and big. Sometimes they try to slip in a small slice, pay attention.3.50 a slice get what u pay for. I have tried some of their other specialty slices and all pretty good. I haven't tried any dishes here , so can't say, just the pizza.place gets busy on weekends.

Foteini Papadopoulos

Love the new Mario’s in my neighborhood! Owners and staff are so friendly. The food is delicious and the place is spotless. A nice atmosphere to sit and enjoy a slice or a family meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Greek Salad with Chicken, Chicken Cutlet Panini with Lettuce and Tomato, Eggplant and Pesto Panini, Pizza, Penny Alla Vodka Pizza

Foteini P.

Love the new Mario's in levittown! Staff is so friendly and efficient. The food is yummy and the restaurant so clean. Enjoyed sitting in every time. Take out is always nice and quick when we're on the run.

Dee Marcellino

The best - highly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy L.

Finally a pizza my entire family agrees on! Thin crust that's not doughy and just the right amount of cheese and delicious pizza sauce! Pleasant on the phone and great delivery!

Mindy M.

3 stars for Mario's pizza and one more for the manager Eirini. Stopped by today after a quick visit to the urgent care for an X-ray down the block. I did a pickup order so my husband could rest in the car. Stephen took the order and put in for an extra cheese meatball parm hero, a calzone and a piece of vegetable pizza, the latter that I asked to eat while waiting. The 2 young men couldn't figure out how I wanted that slice. After some explaining to them they put it on a flimsy paper plate which I took to the table to eat. When my order was ready one man considerately asked and did put it on the heat top allowing me to finish eating my slice. I asked if they had coke and Stephen told me yes they have cans. $2.45 a can ( tip here have change with you) 2 cans later( see pix) why a second can? The meatball parm not only didn't have extra cheese, what was there was scarce. I went back into the restaurant and Eirini had said she'd give me a 2.00 credit for next time. I said no. After my husband had not eaten all day, bringing the hero back wasn't an option either. Seems the coke has always been that price , so I asked and received a second can for him for later. Eirini worked hard to satisfy my needs as a customer; signs of a good manager.

Robert Prosa

They were a great help on short notice was able to make me two lasagna trays for a party within a one and a half from the time I called.And it was delicious at that. Money well spent.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Salomon Escandon

Excellent service and very friendly and in SpanishThey serve you with a smile that makes it a pleasure to return

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

RYAN MODESTI

Great pizza. Been here many times and never

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Harvey Saks

A good area pizza place that also makes gluten-free pies.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Criss Pineda

We live so close to this pizzeria and it’s pretty much an every week spot for my family— their chicken vodka slice always hits the spot. And their staff is always friendly and welcoming!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Marsala, Pizza, Penny Alla Vodka Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Al G

I don't know what it is about this place, but the Pizza is sooo..... pizza. Just what I want. It feels strange to write things like gooey or oily, because that might come across as bad. But isn't that what we want when we go for pizza? Like

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Load More