Sweet Serindipty

Online, Lynbrook
(917) 681-8439

Recent Reviews

Mariya Poz

Ordered a pull apart cupcake cake for my daughter's 1st bday. All the guests enjoyed. Tasted fresh and delicious. Thank you !!!

Google user

So happy I found this bakery! Marina is beyond talented and the cake she created for my daughter exceeded my expectations.

rosie hacsi

Marina made the most delicious chocolate and vanilla cupcakes for ny daughters 40th birthday! And they looked beautiful! Thanks Marina!

Cindy Persaud

So happy I found this bakery! Marina is beyond talented and the cake she created for my daughter exceeded my expectations.

Abigail Giubergia

This is an amazing place to get your sweets at!! Not only are the owners very kind, but the products are amazing quality and fairly priced. I can see myself buying baked goods from here for a long time to come.

Erika Molinaro

My coworkers got me a cake from here for my birthday two years ago and I loved it. For my daughters first birthday I came in on a Tuesday and asked for a small 8” cake that could be made for Saturday. She first asked me “how OLD are you?!” I was confused. I told her that I’m 30 year old(in my head wondering WHY would that matter to her?). She basically told me I waited to long to order a custom cake. I didn’t really feel like going to another bakery as I had my mind set that the one cake I did have from here was amazing. I told her my coworkers had gotten my cake the same day, from the counter. She replied she doesn’t make those cakes already done anymore, because she doesn’t have the time. She then complained to me how she hates being there alone and keeps telling her husband she wants her own studio so she doesn’t have to tend to people that keep walking in while she is in the back. Maybe they should get a counter worker if this is a problem ? We went ahead and ordered my 8 inch cake, non custom just colorful Rosettes for $135?!? I put it on my card but as I got into my car I thought why did I just spend $135 on an 8 inch cake?! I drove up the block to another bakery and asked if they could make a custom cake for Saturday , they happily replied “sure!” I asked how much money they said “$60”. Wow! I went back to sweet serendipity and asked why she’s charging more than double for a non custom cake. She was nasty, she was mean. She said “maybe that bakery isn’t as fresh or aren’t as busy as we are” I demanded to cancel The order . After going back and fourth with her , and her nasty comments , She finally credited me back but charged me a 10% service fee!!!!!!!!!! Service fee for what ?!?!?! I’m calling my credit card to dispute this. Just rude and disgusting service. And still wondering why she cared how old I was.

Nitai P.

Closed at 6:41. Shows open till 8:30. Might update if I ever return and it's open... waste of time

Elka Friedman

It was the best cake ever. It was beautiful and it tasted great! Everyone loved it and was fighting for the last piece. We will recommend you to all of our friends❤

Elle Ellachka

Booked them for my wedding! Already did a tasting and can not wait for my big day! Highly recommend. Reasonable prices, delicious and a pleasure to work with !

Riana Lik

Made me the most beautiful and yummy dessert table!

Marta M.

I came across this bakery by accident and it is in fact a serendipity. I ordered cupcakes for my daughter birthday and they were every bit delicious as they were adorably decorated. The cupcakes were light fluffy and the frosting was perfect and not ultra sweet. I am definitely going to come back.

Janeen B.

Amazing customer service! Placed a phone order with Marina for a gift & she went above and beyond to make sure it happened. My family received it & they are so excited to try her beautiful and delicious cupcakes. Was hard to choose which treat to get because everything looked SO good. Thank you very much. Happy holidays!

Garry Kanfer

Get all our sweets here, she is amazing!!

Anna Sharts

I ordered a custom cake for my brother in laws's 30th birthday with SS for 12/7/18. The cake was executed perfectly! It was an absolute show stopper! Marina was a pleasure to work with. The cake was delivered on time to Brooklyn (Orange Grill). Overall an amazing experience. Will be using SS again! Thank you!

Nicole S.

Marina is a true artist and one of a kind baker. From my most basic to most outrageous cake designs Marina surpassed my wildest dreams from disply to taste. Sweet serendipity is your go to for all your sweet treats

Load More