Caesar salad was sour and pizza was extremely soggy. Never had pizza or any kind of bread be this soggy. Bread was soaked. Felt apart. Tried to pick it up and everything fell off. Not even 2 hands was enough to hold the slices up to take a bite. Also server was having lunch when we arrived and on her phone which I didn't mind but then served our food without washing her hands. Mozarella sticks and sauce were good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tiline CRP
The food there is really good and prices are realistic.... It's quiet and you get to focus the people around you. I will definitely go back.
Been waiting 25 minutes for a pizza to get done and it was a
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Richard England
It's a pizzeria, nothing fancy, but the food, especially the pizza is beyond fabulous. If you like tender calamari, you must order it here. You will not find better anywhere. If you are lucky enough to come when Mario make his homemade bread, you are not going to want to share it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ed KoE Rivera
Excellent food, great flavors, great prices. Some of the best pizza in Mahopac. This place is a gem because much of the food is fresh and tastes great not just the pizza. Not fancy looking but that’s ok, the best food places rarely are fancy.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joann Maxwell
The food at Mario’s is always delicious!!Very reasonable prices for a good quality meal.Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Arugula & Prosciutto Pizza
Maria Magyar
This place is so slow. And they told us every time " just couple minutes " I waited for 15-20 minutes. That was the last time. I am done with them.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Bob S.
A cozy Italian-American in Mahopac on Route 6, that is worth a trip from anywhere! The review, may sound like hyperbole, but it's not! A friend mentioned it had good food, great prices, and table service and he was going down there, so we all stopped in for lunch. Great decision. The prices are very reasonable! One of the best Italian-American restaurant/pizzerias I've found in years; and I've eaten more than my share of pizza in many countries. Only top quality ingredients are used! We each ordered a different 12" pizza, one for each of us. In hindsight, we could've ordered one pizza that the three of could have shared and would we have been satiated! My significant other ordered a prosciutto and arugula pizza. She had one at Cancino's in Mexico City November 2019 and LOVED it. We've never seen it on another menu here. So, when she saw it on their menu, she ordered it right away! It was perfect! There was about 4 ounces of arugula and the $20 something a pound prosciutto on it. See the photo. No crispy cremated prosciutto chips nor wilted arugula arrived to the table. My friend had the red meat pizza. It looks like about a pound of sausage meat and a whole pepperoni was sliced and put on his pizza. He kept picking pepperoni off his pizza and putting it on ours. What we had looked like a normal pepperoni pizza; there was that much on his! There was a small group who ordered pasta dishes. They looked great also. Yelpers get a 10% discount.
Silvio D.
Great pizza place at a reasonable price. Went here on a Friday night, and we had made a reservation in advance. We were seated immediately. I thought both the margherita pizza and the diavola pizzas were excellent. I highly recommend this place when you are in the area and looking for a pie!
Wilma H.
We were invited to come here. It's a distance but it was highly recommended. I am glad that we came. They have my favorite pizza arugula and prosciutto. I had it in Mexico and fell in love with it. Thinking never to have it again unless I went to Mexico. I was wrong they have it here. The place is not big. But their pizzas are filing and absolutely delicious. It's a little out of our area but worth it Sheryl is our server. Unfortunately I could not eat it all, but I'll finish it later.
I was really taken back when the girl on the phone said I couldn’t order wings with just bbq sauce they were a mix of hot and bbq and they were pre mixed. I thought how hard could it be to toss them in just bbq. Then I ate them. This wind sauce is so amazing I completely understand why they wouldn’t modify it and kept the integrity of the meal. It wasn’t too spicy or too sweet they were maybe the best wings I’ve ever had in Mahopac and I’ve lived here for years. The mozz sticks were great too! Lesson be learned sometimes the customer isn’t always right, this was an amazing football Sunday snack and I’ll be going back… weekly lol
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Wings
My Umdnj
They only serve individual size pizzas, which doesn’t work for everyone. My onion and pepperoni was tasty but the crust was soggy. My wife’s gluten free toppings were very good but she didn’t find the crust good at all.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Edward D.
Truly a hidden gem. All food is meticulously hand made from scratch. Mario and his staff are very friendly. Hand tossed pizzas are baked in a real wood fired oven. Pastas, veal, mussels and chicken dishes are all excellent and served in plentiful portions. Great dining room. Plenty of parking. I highly recommend this place if you are in Mahopac.
Caesar salad was sour and pizza was extremely soggy. Never had pizza or any kind of bread be this soggy. Bread was soaked. Felt apart. Tried to pick it up and everything fell off. Not even 2 hands was enough to hold the slices up to take a bite. Also server was having lunch when we arrived and on her phone which I didn't mind but then served our food without washing her hands. Mozarella sticks and sauce were good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food there is really good and prices are realistic.... It's quiet and you get to focus the people around you. I will definitely go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Wings, Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza
Been waiting 25 minutes for a pizza to get done and it was a
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
It's a pizzeria, nothing fancy, but the food, especially the pizza is beyond fabulous. If you like tender calamari, you must order it here. You will not find better anywhere. If you are lucky enough to come when Mario make his homemade bread, you are not going to want to share it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food, great flavors, great prices. Some of the best pizza in Mahopac. This place is a gem because much of the food is fresh and tastes great not just the pizza. Not fancy looking but that’s ok, the best food places rarely are fancy.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food at Mario’s is always delicious!!Very reasonable prices for a good quality meal.Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Arugula & Prosciutto Pizza
This place is so slow. And they told us every time " just couple minutes " I waited for 15-20 minutes. That was the last time. I am done with them.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
A cozy Italian-American in Mahopac on Route 6, that is worth a trip from anywhere! The review, may sound like hyperbole, but it's not! A friend mentioned it had good food, great prices, and table service and he was going down there, so we all stopped in for lunch. Great decision. The prices are very reasonable! One of the best Italian-American restaurant/pizzerias I've found in years; and I've eaten more than my share of pizza in many countries. Only top quality ingredients are used! We each ordered a different 12" pizza, one for each of us. In hindsight, we could've ordered one pizza that the three of could have shared and would we have been satiated! My significant other ordered a prosciutto and arugula pizza. She had one at Cancino's in Mexico City November 2019 and LOVED it. We've never seen it on another menu here. So, when she saw it on their menu, she ordered it right away! It was perfect! There was about 4 ounces of arugula and the $20 something a pound prosciutto on it. See the photo. No crispy cremated prosciutto chips nor wilted arugula arrived to the table. My friend had the red meat pizza. It looks like about a pound of sausage meat and a whole pepperoni was sliced and put on his pizza. He kept picking pepperoni off his pizza and putting it on ours. What we had looked like a normal pepperoni pizza; there was that much on his! There was a small group who ordered pasta dishes. They looked great also. Yelpers get a 10% discount.
Great pizza place at a reasonable price. Went here on a Friday night, and we had made a reservation in advance. We were seated immediately. I thought both the margherita pizza and the diavola pizzas were excellent. I highly recommend this place when you are in the area and looking for a pie!
We were invited to come here. It's a distance but it was highly recommended. I am glad that we came. They have my favorite pizza arugula and prosciutto. I had it in Mexico and fell in love with it. Thinking never to have it again unless I went to Mexico. I was wrong they have it here. The place is not big. But their pizzas are filing and absolutely delicious. It's a little out of our area but worth it Sheryl is our server. Unfortunately I could not eat it all, but I'll finish it later.
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza and fried ravioli in Mahopac!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Awesome wood fired food. To did for pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Stuffed Cannoli, Octopus, Baked Clams, Mussels Marinara, Arugula & Prosciutto Pizza
I was really taken back when the girl on the phone said I couldn’t order wings with just bbq sauce they were a mix of hot and bbq and they were pre mixed. I thought how hard could it be to toss them in just bbq. Then I ate them. This wind sauce is so amazing I completely understand why they wouldn’t modify it and kept the integrity of the meal. It wasn’t too spicy or too sweet they were maybe the best wings I’ve ever had in Mahopac and I’ve lived here for years. The mozz sticks were great too! Lesson be learned sometimes the customer isn’t always right, this was an amazing football Sunday snack and I’ll be going back… weekly lol
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Wings
They only serve individual size pizzas, which doesn’t work for everyone. My onion and pepperoni was tasty but the crust was soggy. My wife’s gluten free toppings were very good but she didn’t find the crust good at all.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Truly a hidden gem. All food is meticulously hand made from scratch. Mario and his staff are very friendly. Hand tossed pizzas are baked in a real wood fired oven. Pastas, veal, mussels and chicken dishes are all excellent and served in plentiful portions. Great dining room. Plenty of parking. I highly recommend this place if you are in Mahopac.