Mama Lisa Restaurant

1226 Montauk Hwy, Mastic
(631) 395-4600

Recent Reviews

Barbara Nelson

Ugh hate my fat fingers, should be 4 stars. Today was our first visit. We celebrate Palm Sunday with our married kids and grandkids. Very nice decor, all staff super friendly and attentive. Apps came out hot and well cooked. A large menu selection and everyone was pleased. Kids portions plentiful. The adult portions as well came out hot and food was fresh. Will be coming back in May for uncle birthday. Daughter in law and her friend order pizza from here often. Definitely worth a try. UPDATE..coming here Saturday for daughter in laws birthday, CAN'T WAIT. YUMMMM. Upped my review to 5 stars after todays birthdayndinnernfor ky daughter in law. Appetizer came out hot and entrees were hot,nplentiful and delicious. Will be back soon. UPDATE AGAIN....tonight we went for a so long dinner for my nephew and his son who are going back to Seattle tomorrow. And ONCE AGAIN they did not disappoint. We were 11 people in a totally full house and it was perfect. The service, the food hot and plentiful and the general ambiance is everyone enjoying themselves with a delicious meal. Thank you.ANOTHER UPDATE. Today we again had our family Palm Sunday dinner. Mama Lisa did not disappoint. Staff friendly, food abundant, hot, fresh and delicious. Thank you Mama Lisa.UPDATE 12/5/21 Came with family for my birthday dinner. It was crowded but it did not detract from our service. We were greeted right away and ordered drinks and appetizers. Everything was perfect. The owner stopped by our table several times. The staff came out with my dessert that had a candle and sang happy birthday to me. You are never taken for granted here especially if it's crowded. YOU MYST TRY MAMA LISA, you will not be disappointed!UPDATE APRIL 11 2022. We had our family tradition of Palm Sunday dinner at Mama Lisa. We are 6 adults and 4 children. We were not disappointed. The staff is amazing and accommodating. The food, oh the food, is always perfect. Fresh, hot, and plentiful. We all leave full and happy. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED.UPDATE Palm Sunday 2023 was another we are a family if 10, 6 adults 4 children 12 to 3, and there were two other tables with more and the restaurant was full. Our server Ally was engaging and patient through the entire process. If course the food was PERFECT came out hot and plentiful.If you have a family event, this is the place to go, reasonable prices and delicious and accommodating. ENJOYUPDATE 2024 PALM SUNDAY another perfect celebration. Our waiter Eric was a joy to deal with. We all have our favorites from year to year and they don't disappoint. Our 4 grandkids get the chicken fingers and French fries which are plentiful and perfectly cooked. Thank you again for making our tradition going on perfectly.

Gregory Barandiaran

I would give 4 stars but we were charged a credit card convenience fee of about $15 on a $375 tab and a $6 credit card convenience fee on a $150 tab. We spent over $700 including tips over 2 nights as part of a funeral gathering. We were not informed of the fee. In this day and age, there should be no such fees, the economy is essentially cash less. The fee was not proper nor convenient. Future customers, please review the bill and refuse this fee.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Rob M

We (fam of 4) frequent this place fairly often and I tried to celebrate a bday for my wife but it went south immediately after opening a grandmas pizza box. I ordered online at 11:30am for a 3pm pickup on 3/19. you'd figure they would get it right since they had sooo much time. Grandma's pizza was burnt...literally BURNT...not well done but uhm....BURNT!! How do you mess a pizza up like that regardless!!? They couldnt even get the dressing correct either for the salad that was ordered. I was pissed....still am apparently. Lord says, "joy will come in the morning...NOT this time!! only thing that comes to mind..."Kevin you are what the French call, Laissez Competent". Garlic knots and mozzarella sticks were good lol hence the TWO stars....its a shame, wont happen again thats for sure. BTW, I did have pics but for some reason they're not on my phone!? Cant figure that one out lol. I didnt want to take them out of the garbage this morn to record it again for this review.

dallandyshe selimi

Our first time here and it was wonderful, our waitress Ashely was amazing I’m also sitting down at the restaurant trying this lol. Food was so good will definitely be coming back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mishelle Cardella

Very crowded, but really great food and a large selection!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jennifer McDaniel

The food is really good and great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Barone

Parking: Parking on both sides of the street for the restaurant. Short walk from far end

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Tommaso S.

Fantastic Italian authentic square pizza! I loved each every bite. I got the Grandma / Nonna. I met the owners Nino and Moses are just two friendly down to earth true Italian gentleman. I commend their staff for the service and friendliness. The place is very clean and that's a sign that owner care. The ambiance is open space and plenty of room for small intimate setting to large Italian style family dinning.

Christopher Monaco

The pizza could've been better it was too

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Burton G.

Mama Lisa's is a fantastic restaurant that makes you feel welcome as soon as they walk in. The food is amazing, with classic Italian dishes. Everything tasted fresh and delicious. The place looks nice and cozy, and makes you feel as if you're eating at a friend's house. The staff at Mama Lisa's are super friendly and they're always there to help with anything you need. Would highly recommend this restaurant to everyone.

Sal Bellone

The Pizzas were burnt they forgot half the order the food sucked and everything else was cold they haven't changed the food still sucks never again will I go

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Boris Y.

Great place. Words can not describe how happy I was when the Pizza came out, but long wait times. Well worth it, but don't come here if you are in a rush.

catherine evangelista

I attended a family gathering today and the food was delicious and the service was great.Dietary restrictions: They have glute free options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmen Santos

Excellent service and food. Highly recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

SANTOS !

This was my first time at Mama Lisa Restaurant. 5 ☆☆☆☆s. The staff was amazing and friendly. Food was fantastic. Very relaxing environment. Highly recommend this restaurant!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More