10 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mattituck

Magic Fountain Ice Cream Shop • $
9825 Main Rd, Mattituck

Customers` Favorites

Goat Cheese

“I've been to Magic Fountain a few times and enjoyed it each time. You place your order inside with friendly staff (you can try a flavor or two to be sure you like what you're ordering) and there's an extensive menu of flavors. The outside has a few benches and a cute mural and some vintage inspired signage in front. I can't wait to return this summer!“

4.5 Superb74 Reviews
Gemelli Gelato of Hampton Bays Ice Cream Shop • $$
139 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.95 miles

“Super friendly service and delicious gelato! I have had the pistachio, espresso, banana nutella all of which were phenomenal! Cute little set up outside with many lawn chairs and pinic tables. They even have corn hole boards to play with!! 100% worth a visit.“

4.6 Superb50 Reviews
Star Confectionery Store Confectionery • $$
4 E Main St, Riverhead - 8.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

It's a Burger
French Fries
Home Fries
Coleslaw

“Came here the first time I visited Rivehead and now I make sure I leave time to visit each time I come back! I l always order sandwiches because they have not yet disappointed! I've brought my whole family as well as friends here and every single person has LOVED it. The place is family owned and it looks probably a lot like it did when it first opened. So cute and old fashioned. Also, I love their egg creams and their chocolate shakes! Definitely worth ordering. Everything is reasonably priced and just perfectly made. It's just nice to have some simple foods perfectly made! Highly recommend to anyone in town for the day. (Hours are unpredictable so just give them a call before heading over, but honestly it's part of the charm, it's a family place!)“

4.7 Superb34 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
949 Old Country Rd, Riverhead - 8.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Legendary Honey BBQ Chicken Supermelt
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
New England Fish 'N' Chips
Lil' Scoop Chicken Pops 3
Nuts over Caramel Sundae
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Crispy Chicken Salad
Pancakes and Sausage
Loaded Waffle Fries

“I have been going to Riverhead Friendlys for 25 years from Albert the manager and his successor Ritchie and of course seeing Oscar grow from all positions to the manager now was an awesome privilege. With that said, the crew at Riverhead Friendlys never disappoint. Me and my family will keep coming back for the next 25…..Kid-friendliness: Kids are always welcome at this Friendlys location…..“

4.4 Superb73 Reviews
Dari-Land Ice Cream Shop • $
51 Main Rd, Riverhead - 6.89 miles

“This is my favorite ice cream shop. I’ve been coming here since I was a young child and I still do because their service has always remained the same! The people are so sweet and kind, plus their servings are REASONABLY GREAT portions unlike other places.“

4.5 Superb32 Reviews
Paleteria Mexicandy Ice Cream Shop • $
221 E Main St, Riverhead - 8.24 miles

“Great idea - sweets are super fresh and natural ingredients. But for folks not 100% familiar with menu, English descriptions would be helpful. But maybe that’s the point of being authentic! Loved it - we’ll be back and I hope they remain successful!“

4.7 Superb16 Reviews
Country Corner Cafe Family • $
55765 NY-25, Southold - 7.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

All American Panini
Roast Beef Melt
Grilled Cheese
Egg Sandwich
Mac

“This is a great breakfast spot in an area that I feel is missing it. They’re very diverse in breakfast, lunch, and dinner options, and also have a dairy dip for dessert. The corn beef hash is their highly touted dish, and while it was good, I don’t think it was spectacular. The pancakes were actually surprisingly great with low expectations. Coffee is typical diner coffee, but next door is a great coffee shop to visit if you’d like. Would come again, worth the visit.“

4.4 Superb49 Reviews

8
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
790 County Rd 39, Southampton - 8.88 miles

“(Translated by Google) I worked here during the summer and I can say that if you are lucky enough to have all the soft serve machines working, it is worth itthe ice cream is amazing, and the milkshakes are just as good(Original)am lucrat aici pe timpul verii si pot spune ca daca aveti noroc sa funcționeze toate mașinăriile de soft serve, merităînghețata e extraordinară, și milkshakeurile la fel de bune“

4.6 Superb14 Reviews
Local Burger Southampton Hamburger • $
668 County Rd 39, Southampton - 8.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheese Hot Dog
Crispy Cheddar Bites
Blue Cheese Burger
Chicken Fingers
Pretzel Sticks
Local Burger
French Fries
Cajun Fries

“Stumbled upon this place one day. Hands down the BEST burgers we've had in a long time! Absolutely frickin delicious! I have no problem getting in the car & driving half an hour just to get another one. You will NOT be disappointed!“

4.1 Good40 Reviews

10
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$
73 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.75 miles

“I had the pleasure of visiting a remarkably clean and pristine Carvel establishment where the servers' friendliness and enthusiasm to assist truly stood out. As always, the ice cream surpassed my expectations with its exceptional quality.“

3.8 Good17 Reviews
Loading...
map Map