Pizza Restaurants near Mattituck

“This place has the best pizza in mattituck right now...if you dont mind paying for it.....i got a pie wit sausage and pepper....4$ for 12 slices of sausage and 4$ for 12 slices of green pepper on a 24$ pizza.... almost 40$ for a pie with few toppings...i know it should be more because it a little better. But i am going to Gran or Lenny's from now on.“

“First time dining at aMano and I was back 5 days later. The food was excellent and the staff couldn't have been nicer. This is a very welcoming establishment from the moment you walk in. Last night we ate at the bar and again had An outstanding meal and great service. Looking forward to trying more of the menu.“

“Lovely dinner with my family last night. Waitstaff could have came around to keep drinks full and make sure our needs were met. Food was delicious but someone needs to please clean that pizza oven. Burn bottom and crust was a bummer as everything else was very nice. Photo is my take home slices. All three pies were this way. Such a shame. My family came from MA.“

“Went for a birthday dinner with a group of 6. The service was A1. Very nice and helpful. The table was also a horseshoe shape that was nice for the group to interact.It was restaurant week. The food was good, above average. Nothing blew us away but it was good.I will go back.“

“The owner is so super friendly. The pizza was really good. I like the care taken with the preparation and service. Pro tip: look for the Dunkin Donuts to turn in to the parking lot that is right before the gas station. It is a lovely place to grab a slice and enjoy being in South Hampton.“

“The short rib pizza is a delight for your taste buds! I've never had anything like it! The Panini's are tremendous, and their fries are nice and crispy! Can't wait till they put the fireplace on in the winter. I I was surprised that it wasn't crowded, but I am realizing that I don't think everyone knows about this place. If you haven't been there, then you have to go! Staff is friendly and accommodating. Great place for adults, kids, and families.“

“Been going for years. I usually get the Grandmas pizza extra garlic and basil but this past Saturday the 20th was the best pizza I’ve ever had and I grew up in towns, Scotto’s Port Wash and Queens Graziellas that had made the best pizzas. Lenny’s IMHO is consistent and hasn’t disappointed me yet.“

“We love the spot. The pizza is delicious, I had the mushroom gorgonzola for the first time and it was phenomenal. Super fresh and made the order. The garlic bread is wicked. AND the steak was SO GOOD! Its all good. Everything I’ve had here is great.“

“Don't be fooled; this place is so much more than the best pizzeria in Riverhead! The lunch and dinner entrees are prepared to perfection! The fish and seafood is always the freshest! The wine selection is also quite good! The counter servers and the waitstaff are all epic!! They are friendly and efficient!! Eating in the dining room is a pleasure! Gabriella has created a casual and relaxed atmosphere and it feels like we are family!“

“Ate here last week with friends. The waiter, Brett was great. He made good recommendations and was very attentive. The food was excellent! Three in my party of 4 had fig pizza and clam pizza as an entree. It was excellent. I had the homemade burrata-filled ravioli with tomato sauce. The ravioli were huge but delicious! Great wine list and appetizers! Would definitely come back!“

“A day that was even better than expected! What a treat.Our wine tasting and lunch at Jamesport Vineyards was delightful - from the moment we were greeted warmly at the door to attentive service at the table, to the very gentle reminder that we had been lingering a very, very long time at the table, followed by an invitation to move to the comfortable chairs in the garden. The wines were tasty, The pizzas delicious, and the setting soothing. For a civilized, relaxing day at a winery Jamesport is an excellent choice.“

“Absolutely delicious food surrounded by a beautiful atmosphere! I had the pleasure of eating here after the grand re-opening and I couldn’t have been more pleased. Staff was lovely! My favorite things that I ate were the Hamptons White slice (unreal, roasted garlic flavor), eggplant Parmesan (fried to perfection with the perfect tomato sauce), and of course the Doughknots. Delectable fried dough knots served with dipping sauces. My recommendation would be to have the marscapone dipping sauce. It’s incredible! Well done Uncle Joe’s ???“

“I eat their all the time, salads with chicken is great. Pizza- I take out of staters here or brick oven pizza. Chicken parm is good, their rigatoni is mmm mmm mmm. They're desserts are delicious, kind staff, a little pricey but the portions are big. They've messed up an order a few times over the years but we've probably been there a few hundred times by now so the statistics are pretty good. They did give me old lettuce one time recently which I was pretty shocked about but have since enjoyed their salad once again. Overall I recommend going there, I pick up food pretty often, great service... sometimes food takes a lil longer than they say.“

“The best pizzeria ever seriously!! Super amazing staff, very helpful !! I got a catering order from them delivered all the way to ronkonkoma and couldn't be more happier . The food , the experience, the delivery , the price everything was seriously perfect. 1000x recommend .“

“To Sharon, who decided to complain about a freaking language barrier, grow up. I live nearby, eat here regularly, and have never had an experience like that. English is my only language and they're extremely professional in how they conduct themselves in that situation. It takes very little research to learn "ayuda en Ingles, por favor" laziness on other people's part is their problem.Good pizza, great American/Spanish mix of deli food. There is something for everybody here. Absolutely stop by. I've never seen a roach.“

“We first visited Sophie's about 10 years ago-we were not impressed. Mostly fried food served in styrofoam plates and uncomfortable high-top tables. This past fall, we visited Sophie's again (first time in 10 years). WOW-what an improvement! Delicious marinated steak, fantastic clams-on real plates! Beautifully decorated, comfortable dining table and chairs, friendly staff-great food and drinks. We have returned several times since-always satisfied with our dining experience!! My one complaint-don't serve appys with plastic plates.“

“Ordered a cheese pie for delivery and it was more affordable than the other nearby options. From placing the order to the delivery driver the staff was very friendly. Plus the pie was delicious! Added a picture of the box because it's a nice touch!“

“Had a miscommunication with the delivery driver ordering through hotspot. Was extremely furious but the manager kept his cool, and treated me with respect even while I was getting heated. Ultimately the situation was rectified and I am impressed with the way how professional the employees conducted themselves.“

“My family and I took a walk up main road and Southold, an activity we had been planning for 2+ years We happened upon this little gem. Perfect place to get a snack or a meal with tables and chairs outside to sit and watch people walk by The sorbet was amazing. My daughter will be a super fan for life. Can't wait to try their meals next time.“

“Food was good, we ordered pizza and a burger. Portion sizes vs price was very solid. Fast time from ordering to service.Very nice staff and good restaurant atmosphere. Definitely recommend for lunch or a quick pizza stop.Parking: Parking lot was small and traffic plus parkinglot size made leaving the lot very difficult.“

“I order pizza here pretty regularly but last night I placed an order. They forgot a slice- which they refunded when I called. And I should have checked. However I got the baked pasta trio and the ricotta cheese in the stuffed shells and manicotti and lasagna was sour. It must have gone bad. So that $20 dish was thrown in the garbage. The marina very bland. I admit I was surprised. I chalk it up to life but hope someone checks that cheese because I wasn’t the only one that tasted it. Didn’t feel like calling again to complain after calling during dinner to say I never got a slice. Service is always friendly and prompted. Sometimes it’s busy and some of the reviews here show that they have never worked in a restaurant, especially after 2020- it stresses me out going anywhere. I can’t imagine how it is dealing with these fragile attitudes day in and day out. The ladies up front definitely work hard.“

“Drove past this place almost every other day . Never even thought to stop in , saw a big parking lot and easy access. Went inside a friendly gentleman greeted me kindly. I got 2 slices of Pepperoni and a Coke , fantastic pizza . Good dough and tasty fresh pepperoni, usually places leave those slices left over . I stop a lot now and most staff from Riverhead Schools are now going !!Kid-friendliness: very much so , polite customersParking: Big lot off Harrison Road , no need to jump across route 58 and almost get hit head on .“