Cirella's Restaurant

14 Broadhollow Rd, Melville
(631) 385-7380

Recent Reviews

Marilyn Kaufmann

Dinner was excellent. Everyone had a different dish, all delicious. Dessert was amazing 9 scoop brownie and chocolate chip cookie sundae. Highly recommend especially for a celebration. Hostess,bartender and waitress were professional, accommodating, and kind.

chris c

had a baptism party at this restaurant. The food was excellent, and the staff was great. There’s ample parking in the parking lot. The bathrooms are very clean. We only had the Italian food on the menu. Did not have the Asian fusion part. I would definitely recommend to go there to have lunch or dinner.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

ClaudiaN

Our server was Karen. We requested to sit in her section. Karen is great! Our 3 grandsons are always treated very well by her. By this time, Karen knows the sports they play and always asks how their games are. Very thoughtful and attentive. Dean is great. He knows his customers and is always gracious. The whole staff is hands on. Friendly and courteous. Our food was delicious! Maybe a new chef? It works well.

kgirl

We've eaten here many times and held larger events here as well. The menu, the food and the noise level from having the doors wide open to Rt 110 at rush hour were disappointing to say the least on our visit last night. Our server was very good so no complaints there at all. We will probably choose somewhere else next time. It just wasn't what we are used to at all.

David Scharf

Cirellas is consistently great. Excellent food, fair prices, top notch service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Penne Alla Vodka, Sushi, Traditional Caesasr Salad, Veal Parm, Clam Sauce, Roasted Cauliflower, California Roll

johnb

Everything was great. First time there after having driven past the place for 30 years. Service was the best we've had in years. Quick turn around on the appetizers and entrees. All the food was outstanding. It was refreshing to go to a place that doesn't have a credit card surcharge albeit we paid cash. While we got a parking space in Cirellas lot; parking can be a tough find.

Hoofer

Jennifer and Sandy were quite welcoming to the bar and to top it all off they had a great Multipulciano to go with their great short rib ragu pasta. The crème brûlée was also amazing.

Adam Pullar

Nolan was fantastic andnthe food was even better. This was my second time while traveling for business and I highly recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Consistent

Great Italian.. I have been to Cirella's many times with great experience. This trip did not disappoint and was great for 2 colleagues from California looking for "NY Italian Food" .. Cirella's doesnt disappoint

GandA

Lovely meal asked for something that wasn't on the menu and more than accommodating in making. Was very good and plentiful, shrimp oregano's over sautéed spinach. Hubby had special lasagna which was huge and tasty.Waitress was so sweet and pleasant. Cirella salad to start was excellent!

LarryVIP

Suburban Italian with separate bar area. Seems popular with locals and regulars. Food comes in giant portions; salads were good; main courses not so much. Pleasant service. Desserts were good.

Everything about this place is amazing. Jennifer was our waitress and she gave the best recommendations and attentiveness. We have the artichoke soup, calamari, veal parmigiana and kale/quinoa salad. Everything was delicious!

Gemma L.

Always good food and great service. Who knew a place could serve great sushi and great Italian!

hbbchef

Seated immediately. Drinks arrived promptly. Had to ask for water refills, then they began to be automatic. Appetizers ordered. Good portions and delicious but a tad too much garlic on the baked clams. Salmon a bit dry. Small portion of ice cream for affogato , I've had larger. Noise level a bit high. Will return.

JoyceN

Food was excellent. I had Valentine's special pasta with blackened shrimp and pink sauce. Appetizers were baked clams and fried zucchini and both were delicious. Creme brulle was delicious but should be served warm. Prices were normal for this economy.

Load More