Andrews has been sold. New owner pizzeria is called Eliot Pizzeria & Restaurant
Ellen Sullivan
Love this pizza.
Nicole Kosiec
Andrew’s Pizzeria was my go-to pizzeria walking home everyday. Great workers and the best pizza. Not that cheesy that it falls apart, and just the right amount of crunch in the crust. This place never disappoints. I don’t go that often anymore, but I still love it when ever I go.
Barbara L.
Wow! The pizza and the quality of people in here is amazing! It was my first time eating here with my family and we were all satisfied with such great taste. I had a fresh half cheese and half pepperoni pie, mozzarella sticks and let's not forget the cannolis! My experience was great and I will definately be a regular. Plus, Mr. Andrew and Michael were both very attentive. Thank you so much for existing Andrew's Pizzería! See you soon!
Emma Gukassey
Ordered a chicken bacon slice, chicken broccoli slice and garlic knots. $12 for the driest, most flavorless pieces of cardboard i have ever had! (Still ate it though). Not worth the money, you're better off getting dominos tbh. Staff wasn't great either.
Monte A.
Ordered the baked ziti and the Italian salad. Guys were friendly, the order was ready for pickup in 10 minutes. Ziti was pretty good, salad was fresh. Two kinds of dressing included, I enjoyed both. The very generous section of sliced bread was really good! Paid $18 total, got a lot of food. Good food, good value. Mighy try a pizza next.
John Fraumeni
Tasteless pizza. Chicken, Bacon slice was like eating cardboard.I will not return ! ! !
Drew O.
Ehh. My name is Andrew so after driving past recently I looked the place up on here and perused the menu. So-so reviews, but a pretty solid menu with lots of different choices for pies and slices... so my wife and I drove over to check it out. 7ish on a Sat night. Only a few slices out and they looked hours old. I didn't see the kind of slice I wanted and when I asked they said they were out of it - but didn't offer to make one. At 7 on a Sat... seems like you'd have a fresh pie out where you could throw a few toppings on a slice, or putting a new pie in would seem worth it with so much of the night left. My wife and I exchanged the "should we just leave" look, but we were hungry, so we each got a slice - and while it wasn't that bad, it tasted as old as it looked. Would likely have been much better when it was fresh - like I would have assumed it would be at 7 on a Sat night. I mean they close at 10! Really couldn't throw on a new pie? If they had, we'd have taken two slices each (half the pie) and maybe been back. So, again, ehh. A shame the selection that drew me in wasn't offered.
Crystal Llanos
I’m only a fan of their pepp. pinwheels and their chicken cutlet sandwiches with lettuce, tomato & mayo. What I don’t suggest is their Philly Cheese Steak hero.I ordered it with lettuce, tomato, mayo & cheese on a hero with fries and their free can of soda meal online. The meat taste so gross and it’s barely even a dark color. I couldn’t even take more than 2 bites so I just ate their fries. Next time I’ll just stick with what I usually get.
Juan Ramirez
We'll I ordered a baked zitti with chicken first. The portion is huge enough for two individuals the pasta was a bit hard chicken was good the sauce a bit sallty and a nice peace of bread the price was good 13.00 for the baked zitti not bad. Would I go out of my way to visit this place again if im in the area maybe I would stop by and grab a slice.
Both times I’ve been here the guy just takes the pizza with his bare hand and throws it in the oven, extremely unsanitary. In the middle of a pandemic and you’re touching peoples food with the same hands you use to handle money at the register?? Disgusting! Never coming here again, use a spatula next time! The amount of common sense that is lacking here is unacceptable.
Maria Vecchio
The best ? pizza I have EVER TASTED!!!
Noe C.
Very great Arancini at 4$ a pop/ball, nice and crispy. Pizza is good too very classic nyc crust and great flavor on the sauce. Loved the Pasta Carbonara, good portion for price under 10$. Has small wine options for dine in and some beer. Great guy at the counter, very laid back and courteous. Space is small and clean, cute place for a stop when in the area. Def recommend.
Leila Z.
I hope you are never so hungry that you think the pizza here is good. It's got too much cheese, too little sauce and it's tasteless. The counter help was rude as well. Definitely not a go-to place for anything, frankly. Pricey, too. There are better pizza places in Middle Village. Check those out and leave this one alone.
Crystal L.
I'm only a fan of their pepp. pinwheels and their chicken cutlet sandwiches with lettuce, tomato & mayo. What I don't suggest is their Philly Cheese Steak hero. I ordered it with lettuce, tomato, mayo & cheese on a hero with fries and their free can of soda meal online. The meat taste so gross and it's barely even a dark color. I couldn't even take more than 2 bites so I just ate their fries. Next time I'll just stick with what I usually get.
Andrews has been sold. New owner pizzeria is called Eliot Pizzeria & Restaurant
Love this pizza.
Andrew’s Pizzeria was my go-to pizzeria walking home everyday. Great workers and the best pizza. Not that cheesy that it falls apart, and just the right amount of crunch in the crust. This place never disappoints. I don’t go that often anymore, but I still love it when ever I go.
Wow! The pizza and the quality of people in here is amazing! It was my first time eating here with my family and we were all satisfied with such great taste. I had a fresh half cheese and half pepperoni pie, mozzarella sticks and let's not forget the cannolis! My experience was great and I will definately be a regular. Plus, Mr. Andrew and Michael were both very attentive. Thank you so much for existing Andrew's Pizzería! See you soon!
Ordered a chicken bacon slice, chicken broccoli slice and garlic knots. $12 for the driest, most flavorless pieces of cardboard i have ever had! (Still ate it though). Not worth the money, you're better off getting dominos tbh. Staff wasn't great either.
Ordered the baked ziti and the Italian salad. Guys were friendly, the order was ready for pickup in 10 minutes. Ziti was pretty good, salad was fresh. Two kinds of dressing included, I enjoyed both. The very generous section of sliced bread was really good! Paid $18 total, got a lot of food. Good food, good value. Mighy try a pizza next.
Tasteless pizza. Chicken, Bacon slice was like eating cardboard.I will not return ! ! !
Ehh. My name is Andrew so after driving past recently I looked the place up on here and perused the menu. So-so reviews, but a pretty solid menu with lots of different choices for pies and slices... so my wife and I drove over to check it out. 7ish on a Sat night. Only a few slices out and they looked hours old. I didn't see the kind of slice I wanted and when I asked they said they were out of it - but didn't offer to make one. At 7 on a Sat... seems like you'd have a fresh pie out where you could throw a few toppings on a slice, or putting a new pie in would seem worth it with so much of the night left. My wife and I exchanged the "should we just leave" look, but we were hungry, so we each got a slice - and while it wasn't that bad, it tasted as old as it looked. Would likely have been much better when it was fresh - like I would have assumed it would be at 7 on a Sat night. I mean they close at 10! Really couldn't throw on a new pie? If they had, we'd have taken two slices each (half the pie) and maybe been back. So, again, ehh. A shame the selection that drew me in wasn't offered.
I’m only a fan of their pepp. pinwheels and their chicken cutlet sandwiches with lettuce, tomato & mayo. What I don’t suggest is their Philly Cheese Steak hero.I ordered it with lettuce, tomato, mayo & cheese on a hero with fries and their free can of soda meal online. The meat taste so gross and it’s barely even a dark color. I couldn’t even take more than 2 bites so I just ate their fries. Next time I’ll just stick with what I usually get.
We'll I ordered a baked zitti with chicken first. The portion is huge enough for two individuals the pasta was a bit hard chicken was good the sauce a bit sallty and a nice peace of bread the price was good 13.00 for the baked zitti not bad. Would I go out of my way to visit this place again if im in the area maybe I would stop by and grab a slice.
Restaurantji Recommends
Both times I’ve been here the guy just takes the pizza with his bare hand and throws it in the oven, extremely unsanitary. In the middle of a pandemic and you’re touching peoples food with the same hands you use to handle money at the register?? Disgusting! Never coming here again, use a spatula next time! The amount of common sense that is lacking here is unacceptable.
The best ? pizza I have EVER TASTED!!!
Very great Arancini at 4$ a pop/ball, nice and crispy. Pizza is good too very classic nyc crust and great flavor on the sauce. Loved the Pasta Carbonara, good portion for price under 10$. Has small wine options for dine in and some beer. Great guy at the counter, very laid back and courteous. Space is small and clean, cute place for a stop when in the area. Def recommend.
I hope you are never so hungry that you think the pizza here is good. It's got too much cheese, too little sauce and it's tasteless. The counter help was rude as well. Definitely not a go-to place for anything, frankly. Pricey, too. There are better pizza places in Middle Village. Check those out and leave this one alone.
I'm only a fan of their pepp. pinwheels and their chicken cutlet sandwiches with lettuce, tomato & mayo. What I don't suggest is their Philly Cheese Steak hero. I ordered it with lettuce, tomato, mayo & cheese on a hero with fries and their free can of soda meal online. The meat taste so gross and it's barely even a dark color. I couldn't even take more than 2 bites so I just ate their fries. Next time I'll just stick with what I usually get.