Sicilian Delight

1 Galleria Dr, Middletown
(845) 692-7272

Recent Reviews

irene kegel

5.99 for 1 slice of pepperoni pizza is just nuts !! What a pie is like 40 bucks then !!! Was nothing special but burned pepperoni !!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Kerry Sellers

Used to be decent but now it's probably the worst pizza I've ever had.

Food: 1

Amanda Dickman

this place has the best sauce I ever! I had some Buffalo rolls like the pepperoni rolls they are fire!!!!! I would take a pic but I ate them!!!!!! So here’s a selfie but I did get a homemade brownie those are so good :)

Gabby Abreu

Do not order here for delivery they won’t be responsible of ur order and leave u waiting for a pizza that will never arrive ! Horrible horrible service

Andrea B.

If you like racial profiling and gross old food that sits out all day uncovered then this is your place!! I bring my kids here regularly because they like the pizza and it's convenient. Tonight I brought my two kids there and we waited on line. As the lady ahead of us walked away I walked up to order. At that time a Hispanic girl had walked up to the line and instead of taking my order, the counter girl just ignored us and went onto the girl who just walked up. I said "excuse me we were next" and she just looked at me then continued helping the girl. I honestly couldn't believe someone could be so rude. And for what? Because were not Hispanic and all the workers and counter girl were? I then asked to speak to a manager to which I was presented with a young hispanic guy who had zero idea on what the hell he was doing. He informed me he was a partial owner of this business. I explained the situation to this partial owner and do you know the response I got?!? "Well I didn't see anything wrong, she asked if you wanted anything and you didn't respond so she went onto the next customer." Wait what!!! I was never asked if I could be helped because if I did then why would I be complaining to you!!!! The audacity of this little man!! that is not how you keep customers when owning a business. Needless to say I will never go back and I will let every single person I know along with the better business bureau, what kind of people run this place, the old gross food, the non existent service they offer, the filth, the rude nasty staff, and last but not least the RACISM. If I could give zero stars I would, one star is REALLY stretching it. : )

Kenneth Soto

Ordered 4 chicken parm heros they gave me spaghetti and chicken patty they said they don't do hero's never heard of a pizzeria not selling hero's it was disgusting the chicken was terrible it wasn't chicken cutlets it was a patty never again don't even send forks and knives don't waste your time and money

Max Blagodar

Pizza is extremely burnt and dry on many occasions.This is the second pizza they gave me, after i returned the first one for being completely burnt on the crust and bottom. For the prices they wanna charge, this is unacceptable. Pizza is also very bland

Dorothy Bartomeo

Miss Chuckie Cheese Pizza? This spot is the one for you! They also have a very friendly garlic pie for picky eaters! Good priced and fun for the kiddos (we did take out).

DTN_DoLo 2

They’re all little insects on the food look closely before you prder

jon l.

Okay, clearly you are in the food court of a mall. With this in mind, the pizza here is more than decent. They had a large number of ready to go options and were happy to customize slices. Addition options include gluten free pies, stuffed pizzas, and pastas. Good option if you are in the mall.

Heather Rose

I ordered sausage n pepper Stromboli. It was delicious. I would recommend it.

Rebecca Baumgardner

This is the best pizza place around. I dine in when walking around the mall. Or if I'm passing through Middletown, I will stop to get take out. Staff is quick and friendly.

Frederick Spilka

Greatest Stromboli and pizza

riel doin'

My fiancé and I both got 2 slices each, 4 different varieties of pizza, ALL DELISH!!

Montana McGuire

Amazing food great family restaurant!!

Load More