My Favorite Pizza Place

1745 E Main St, Mohegan Lake
(914) 528-8200

Recent Reviews

Michael McMahon

The name says it all, it’s my favorite pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: My Favorite Pizza

Ken S

Basing the review on the PIZZA only. Plenty of pizza places along the Route 6 corridor. Was driving by and saw a special, buy one slice get the 2nd slice for half price. Ordered 2 plain slices.Pizza was reheated to my liking but it was so bland and that was after applying a copius amount of garlic, oregano, black pepper and parmesan cheese. Crust was crunchy but unfortunately that's just 10% of the experience. I don't care how many slices they give for free, if its tasteless its just extra wasted calories. I'm not here to bash local businesses. What I will say is that there are much more flavorful options in either direction.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Thomas Angelo

Everything about our experience was unpleasant and unforgettable. Food, staff, all of it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

A S

One of the rudest people working in the food business today. The bald guy who had no other customers who was interrupted by helping me made sure I knew it. They have a drive-through there, which I've never seen in my life before, be sure not to ask about it because you're going to be met with someone who obviously has been asked that question a lot, and no longer wants to have friendly banter about it, but I was genuinely genuinely curious about how it would work for an item that would take some time to cook to order, try to ask the guy about it but he kept just rolling his eyes and saying he'll do whatever we want a customer as a customer blah blah blah, but rude eye rolling nasty. We were placing an order for about 10 families and we're looking to spread it around this area, I wouldn't give this guy a penny

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Elayne Wright

They graciously donated pizza for our local Scouts. We were very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Johnathan obrien

Great staff and decent food. Perfect place to grab a quick bite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jacqueline Lisella

Went here for a slice of pizza on Monday November 6th, before heading to a funeral that was nearby. Went with my parents. They had quite a few pizzas and rolls available. I had a slice of BBQ Chicken pizza, my mom had white pizza with a spinach roll, and i forget what my dad had. i enjoyed my pizza, and liked the slice. Was also greeted right away, and everyone seemed very nice. Reasonable price too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacqueline L.

Went here for a slice of pizza on Monday November 6th, before heading to a funeral that was nearby. Went with my parents. They had quite a few pizzas and rolls available. I had a slice of BBQ Chicken pizza, my mom had white pizza with a spinach roll, and i forget what my dad had. i enjoyed my pizza, and liked the slice. Was also greeted right away, and everyone seemed very nice. Reasonable price too.

Linda K

Best pizza in Mohegan Lake! All the pizza is great but our favorites are the Grandma Margherita, Sicilian (light and airy) and the salad pizza is the best. If you've never had salad pizza and want to try it, be sure to get it here. Frank works non stop and we're glad he does!

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 5

Amelia PHW

The interior is quite dated and could use a bit of TLC. There were almost no slices on a Thursday afternoon and no garlic knots. Staff seemed disinterested and looked like they wanted to leave. The server kept touching and rotating some of the slices with her bare hands. Definitely won’t be returning.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Raymond Huey

A couple of salad to go, 30 minutes later...

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

James Campbell

Clean, great food, great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, My Favorite Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Reg Slice

Broconut

This place really does live up to its name. The food is always hand-made with top-notch skill, and they serve exactly the kind of brand drinks that taste great with their menu.Parking: Reserved parking in the complex for customers.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs, no stress!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: My Favorite Pizza

M G.

I honestly can't remember how many years we have been ordering from this pizza place but it's our all time favorite. Consistently delicious, well made, fresh ingredients, does not disappoint! Highly recommend.

Keith M.

The soups! This is your typical pizza joint. Better than average fare. But when my wife had the flu she wanted soup. After trying a few different places I tried 3 of theirs. I waited for a while and wondered what the delay was. They make every soup to order! They were all delicious!!! Who knew?!?

Load More