Be careful when you're ordering through door dash since neither one of them is truthful about their prices. The manager argued with me on the phone until he became irate and made me looking like a jack ass. I'll never make the mistake of ordering from Alfredo's again. The Chicken Frances was flavorless made and was not even prepared properly. I deserve a comp but I just won't order from them again.
Choclet Martian
I'm in town for work. The first time we ordered a pepperoni pizza, it was amazing. This second time, It was bad. The margarita pizza dude had zero flavor. Even the sauce was bland. And the side with pepperoni was okay but the sauce was JUST as bland. ?The garlic bread was burnt.. ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jimmy Morales
Much better than Pizza by Alfredo.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Valerie B.
Great food. Ordered shrimp fra diavolo. I hope I spelled it right. Amazing! Just the the right amount of spice. A healthy amount of shrimp. Although there were only a couple they staff served us, although with paper and plastic utensils...lol! The place is nothing's fancy but the food was great. The smallest most obscure places tend to have the greatest food. I came back the next day and got a couple slices of pizza. That was good as well. Check this spot out. A hidden treasure.
Charlene Purrier
Cute little place the pizza was great and the garlic knots were soooooo amazing and garlicky. Would 100% go back prices are also a lot better than the surrounding area!Vegetarian options: Pizzas, Pastas, Calzones, salads, wedge sandwichesKid-friendliness: It's Pizza what kid doesn't love pizza :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Gina Kingsley
Ever since Canone's closed I've been searching for good pizza in New Rochelle. Alfredo's is the place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Hurtado
We always order from Alfredo’s, one the best pizzerias in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mayra Hernandez
Pizza was delicious, staff is super friendly. My sister swears by this place, doesn’t take her children to any other pizzeria. I will definitely stop by again on my next trip to New York.
danielle b. fuller
We love the pizza, wings, salad, etc. Usually order 1-2 times a week. The staff is friendly. Have been going for at least 15 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BRIONNIE B
I've given this establishment multiple tries before leaving this review. The food tastes like they toss together pre-made ingredients. I've tried the garlic knots, which were not good, and I've never had a bad garlic knot before this. I've tried a plain slice, ceasar salad and penne vodka. None of them were delicious. It's food at the least and the portion sizes are good for the price. The sauce in the penne vodka tasted like it was dumped straight out of a jar.I've tried Alfredo's on different days, different times and none of the times wow'd me.The gentleman that work there however are always nice & pleasant
Ordered my 16 inch well done and they cooked it perfect. Perfect crisp, no flop, good ingredients, good taste. Super hot out of the oven. It burned the roof of my mouth which is what I like. I prefer this place over gemelli's down the road. Nice employees, and I'm surprised more people don't know about this place. I'm new to the area, so I'm guessing this place is new (the building is very modern). Anyways, give them a shot!
Yanni L
Great service! Food is always delivered nice and hot.
Eric Schafer
Deliver hot and on time, every time! Online ordering, free deliver and kind people. Football pizza and great to enjoy with friends
Laura Q.
First take out - Had to wait for order. Pizza okay - Stracciatella soup delicious - tossed salad really good - too much white lettuce, not enough green but otherwise really good. Good switch white onion for red. Baked Penne great. Tiramisu really good - Give it a try!!
Lynellen Nielsen
Great pizza, service and fast delivery. Our go to spot for pizza in New Rochelle.
Be careful when you're ordering through door dash since neither one of them is truthful about their prices. The manager argued with me on the phone until he became irate and made me looking like a jack ass. I'll never make the mistake of ordering from Alfredo's again. The Chicken Frances was flavorless made and was not even prepared properly. I deserve a comp but I just won't order from them again.
I'm in town for work. The first time we ordered a pepperoni pizza, it was amazing. This second time, It was bad. The margarita pizza dude had zero flavor. Even the sauce was bland. And the side with pepperoni was okay but the sauce was JUST as bland. ?The garlic bread was burnt.. ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Much better than Pizza by Alfredo.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great food. Ordered shrimp fra diavolo. I hope I spelled it right. Amazing! Just the the right amount of spice. A healthy amount of shrimp. Although there were only a couple they staff served us, although with paper and plastic utensils...lol! The place is nothing's fancy but the food was great. The smallest most obscure places tend to have the greatest food. I came back the next day and got a couple slices of pizza. That was good as well. Check this spot out. A hidden treasure.
Cute little place the pizza was great and the garlic knots were soooooo amazing and garlicky. Would 100% go back prices are also a lot better than the surrounding area!Vegetarian options: Pizzas, Pastas, Calzones, salads, wedge sandwichesKid-friendliness: It's Pizza what kid doesn't love pizza :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Ever since Canone's closed I've been searching for good pizza in New Rochelle. Alfredo's is the place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We always order from Alfredo’s, one the best pizzerias in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was delicious, staff is super friendly. My sister swears by this place, doesn’t take her children to any other pizzeria. I will definitely stop by again on my next trip to New York.
We love the pizza, wings, salad, etc. Usually order 1-2 times a week. The staff is friendly. Have been going for at least 15 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've given this establishment multiple tries before leaving this review. The food tastes like they toss together pre-made ingredients. I've tried the garlic knots, which were not good, and I've never had a bad garlic knot before this. I've tried a plain slice, ceasar salad and penne vodka. None of them were delicious. It's food at the least and the portion sizes are good for the price. The sauce in the penne vodka tasted like it was dumped straight out of a jar.I've tried Alfredo's on different days, different times and none of the times wow'd me.The gentleman that work there however are always nice & pleasant
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered my 16 inch well done and they cooked it perfect. Perfect crisp, no flop, good ingredients, good taste. Super hot out of the oven. It burned the roof of my mouth which is what I like. I prefer this place over gemelli's down the road. Nice employees, and I'm surprised more people don't know about this place. I'm new to the area, so I'm guessing this place is new (the building is very modern). Anyways, give them a shot!
Great service! Food is always delivered nice and hot.
Deliver hot and on time, every time! Online ordering, free deliver and kind people. Football pizza and great to enjoy with friends
First take out - Had to wait for order. Pizza okay - Stracciatella soup delicious - tossed salad really good - too much white lettuce, not enough green but otherwise really good. Good switch white onion for red. Baked Penne great. Tiramisu really good - Give it a try!!
Great pizza, service and fast delivery. Our go to spot for pizza in New Rochelle.