Best pizzeria in New Rochelle. Great catering food too.
Mister BigGiggles
Great local Pizza joint. Nothing fancy though I do like the sauce as a step up. Sal is on top of it and is always trying new offerings can't go wrong for quick bight or an entree.Wheelchair accessibility: Tight quarters but on sidewalk level.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jasmine C.
The food is incredible. The pizza is authentic and delicious Italian NY pizza. Service was great and friendly. If you want more than a slice order in advance because they get busy.
Laura C.
Ordered delivery on Slice app tonight. Holy guacamole this place is delicious. Not sure why we waited so long! Husband LOVED the clam pie with bacon added. I loved the Late Night Grandma pie (next time I'll ask east on the onion but was easy enough to take it off). Wings were nice and crispy bc the sauce came on the side vs being so soggy when they arrive. Ceasars salad hit the spot too. Thanks for the great pizza, Sal!
jaye murray
RUDE!! The server is yelling loudly at customers rather than pleasant and friendly then as I left he yells "You're welcome very much" having not heard my thank you--but nevertheless--what the heck with the rudeness? Pizza was old and looked like it had been on the unheated counter for hours. Rude, impatient and the pizza was worse than a reheated frozen slice from the supermarket.You can forgive bad pizza in exchange for pleasant service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gary Lucca
Great pies depending.Chicken ceasar is great tasting but need 2 slices at least as they kack bottom bulk. More cheese or something. All slices are $4:50.All in all a great place for eats.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Daniel A.
Great Food! Apps are amazing, soups are delicious, and pizza is fantastic!! Family orientated! Awesome wholesome atmosphere! Decent prices!
Allen S.
The website clearly says $1.00 delivery and no minimum, that's a lie it's a $15 dollar minimum and $5.00 delivery fee.I'd rather lick the backside of a a dog.
Gwendolyn Jasmin
Very Italian local Pizza shop. Friendly service, pizzas where the right temperature, right amount of cheese, and delicious!Kid-friendliness: Our kids enjoyed the food and looking g at the family photos on the wall.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Mazda M.
Hands down my favorite pizza place. I always get my go to which is the white slice. I've tried the chicken, grandma, and garlic knots and they're all so good ! Sal & the crew are extremely friendly and make you feel welcome too! Highly recommend !
Full disclosure...the pizza isn't bad... nothing stellar but definitely decent. The issue is Sal...being rude and aggressive towards customers. Literally watched him in action being aggressive towards a customer and when he was called out for it he started to snap at his staff and then retreated to hide in the kitchen when said customer asked him nicely to step to the side and have a private conversation about the matter. Oh...and there was another time my wife was trying to place a catering order for a birthday party...after calling multiple times and always being told to call back because they were too busy to take an order. Really...too busy 3 or 4 times to take a large order? Do yourself a favor and go somewhere else.
Vladimir Cvijovic
Great place, top of the line Italian specialties, would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Antonio Mastrogiacomo
Sal’s is our go to pizza place in the neighborhood. The grandma pie is top notch!! The Sal salad is also fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jackie M.
Took family for a late lunch on a Wednesday afternoon when visiting NY in May. Not exactly rush hour. The main guy was an absolute ahole from the moment we walked in. We smiled anyway, politely ordered and sat and waited, and waited some more for a friggin' pizza with two other people waiting in the place. he's too busy shootin' his mouth with the other chooch behind the counter and trying to be as funny (obnoxious) as possible...he calls us and...he made the wrong pizza! We told him but didn't argue since we were starving, we took it to our table and bought a bunch more slices since the pizza he gave us was swimming in oil. His pizza was not worth a dime, but we ate it since we were hungry and had to get back on the road. We did not complain to him and he of course still digging at us for unknown reasons. To really ace our experience, the ahole tries to over charge us, not once, but TWICE. Honestly, his pizza was so substandard and there's some nasty pizza out there in the world. Shame on me, I should have found any other pizza joint on North Ave. I'm writing this review since the experience was so unpleasant and so uncalled for. If it wasn't because I was with my family, I would have put him in his place. Take your business and smile elsewhere.
Omar Morales
I know Sal's since 2010 until he move towards New Rochelle and today I found him again, same greate taste, same great food, the best Italian food ever, happy to found him backVegetarian options: They have what you need, just ask, the best foodKid-friendliness: Once your kid try their food they will want to grow up fastDietary restrictions: Just need to ask, best in New York
Best pizzeria in New Rochelle. Great catering food too.
Great local Pizza joint. Nothing fancy though I do like the sauce as a step up. Sal is on top of it and is always trying new offerings can't go wrong for quick bight or an entree.Wheelchair accessibility: Tight quarters but on sidewalk level.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
The food is incredible. The pizza is authentic and delicious Italian NY pizza. Service was great and friendly. If you want more than a slice order in advance because they get busy.
Ordered delivery on Slice app tonight. Holy guacamole this place is delicious. Not sure why we waited so long! Husband LOVED the clam pie with bacon added. I loved the Late Night Grandma pie (next time I'll ask east on the onion but was easy enough to take it off). Wings were nice and crispy bc the sauce came on the side vs being so soggy when they arrive. Ceasars salad hit the spot too. Thanks for the great pizza, Sal!
RUDE!! The server is yelling loudly at customers rather than pleasant and friendly then as I left he yells "You're welcome very much" having not heard my thank you--but nevertheless--what the heck with the rudeness? Pizza was old and looked like it had been on the unheated counter for hours. Rude, impatient and the pizza was worse than a reheated frozen slice from the supermarket.You can forgive bad pizza in exchange for pleasant service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great pies depending.Chicken ceasar is great tasting but need 2 slices at least as they kack bottom bulk. More cheese or something. All slices are $4:50.All in all a great place for eats.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great Food! Apps are amazing, soups are delicious, and pizza is fantastic!! Family orientated! Awesome wholesome atmosphere! Decent prices!
The website clearly says $1.00 delivery and no minimum, that's a lie it's a $15 dollar minimum and $5.00 delivery fee.I'd rather lick the backside of a a dog.
Very Italian local Pizza shop. Friendly service, pizzas where the right temperature, right amount of cheese, and delicious!Kid-friendliness: Our kids enjoyed the food and looking g at the family photos on the wall.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Hands down my favorite pizza place. I always get my go to which is the white slice. I've tried the chicken, grandma, and garlic knots and they're all so good ! Sal & the crew are extremely friendly and make you feel welcome too! Highly recommend !
Restaurantji Recommends
Full disclosure...the pizza isn't bad... nothing stellar but definitely decent. The issue is Sal...being rude and aggressive towards customers. Literally watched him in action being aggressive towards a customer and when he was called out for it he started to snap at his staff and then retreated to hide in the kitchen when said customer asked him nicely to step to the side and have a private conversation about the matter. Oh...and there was another time my wife was trying to place a catering order for a birthday party...after calling multiple times and always being told to call back because they were too busy to take an order. Really...too busy 3 or 4 times to take a large order? Do yourself a favor and go somewhere else.
Great place, top of the line Italian specialties, would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sal’s is our go to pizza place in the neighborhood. The grandma pie is top notch!! The Sal salad is also fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Took family for a late lunch on a Wednesday afternoon when visiting NY in May. Not exactly rush hour. The main guy was an absolute ahole from the moment we walked in. We smiled anyway, politely ordered and sat and waited, and waited some more for a friggin' pizza with two other people waiting in the place. he's too busy shootin' his mouth with the other chooch behind the counter and trying to be as funny (obnoxious) as possible...he calls us and...he made the wrong pizza! We told him but didn't argue since we were starving, we took it to our table and bought a bunch more slices since the pizza he gave us was swimming in oil. His pizza was not worth a dime, but we ate it since we were hungry and had to get back on the road. We did not complain to him and he of course still digging at us for unknown reasons. To really ace our experience, the ahole tries to over charge us, not once, but TWICE. Honestly, his pizza was so substandard and there's some nasty pizza out there in the world. Shame on me, I should have found any other pizza joint on North Ave. I'm writing this review since the experience was so unpleasant and so uncalled for. If it wasn't because I was with my family, I would have put him in his place. Take your business and smile elsewhere.
I know Sal's since 2010 until he move towards New Rochelle and today I found him again, same greate taste, same great food, the best Italian food ever, happy to found him backVegetarian options: They have what you need, just ask, the best foodKid-friendliness: Once your kid try their food they will want to grow up fastDietary restrictions: Just need to ask, best in New York