Excellent pizza. Fresh. Even when reheated it's not dripping with oil. Food looks delicious every time I go in. Friendly staff. Good sized portions and specialty foods. Soups come with a piece of bread.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jae G.
Best pizza shop vibe. Team is very welcoming!! Pizza is delicious and they have a great menu. Everything i've had is super tasty!!!! Get the cookies, they'll warm them up and they are perfection.
Josue Torres
Just walked in to the pizza shop at 7:36pm and asked for a cheese slice and a pepperoni with Extra cheese and the counter guy told me only one cheese slice and what ever other slice I have but I can’t do a pepperoni slice cause I’m not making anymore cheese pies, How you run out of cheese slices at 7:30pm and decide not to make anymore pizza. The owners nephew is much nicer and I’m sure he would’ve gone above and beyond. This was rude and cause of him I would never buy here again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Travis Miller
My new go-to for pizza in New Rochelle. Buffalo chicken slice is legit and the garlic knots are very good. I’ve had the calzone as well which has a nice crispy bake to the outside. Have had fries and calamari as well - nothing has missed the mark yet.
My mistake....Sorry guys! It seems they do have delivery, we have had many meals delivered and every one was outstanding and HOT!
Olga H.
A neighbor recommended this place, and it looks like they have a couple of locations in the Bronx. Meh. I am a die hard grandma pizza fan, and this one was the worst I have ever had. Where the hell is the sauce, man? It's more naked crust than anything with a little sauce and medallions of mozzarella, kind of like an afterthought. I also got a pie with meatballs and sausage. It came to my house a little soggy. The crust did not hold up through transport. I may pop in and try a fresh slice, to see if there is a difference, but aside from that, I won't be ordering delivery from here agin.
Zakiya Philbert
The eggplant pizza is AMAZING!!!! I thought it was a chicken slice, just delicious!!! The costumer service is great!Vegetarian options: All of their food is GREAT & Delicious!!! Vegetarian as well.
Cestra's is the go-to place for great pizza and wonderful service. I just relocated to downtown New Rochelle, and while I love Latin Cusine, it is great to have alternative options. I love that their pizza is thin crust, & just the right proportion of sauce & chesse. I just ordered their Buffalo Chicken Pie & it was a family hit!
Maniac Mafia
Best food in all of westchester bar
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Salad
Moses Kyle McCarter
Just moved to New Rochelle. Looking to find my new ‘local’ spot. Stopped here with the fam. Ordered a slice, a kids pasta, and a Sicilian pie. $50. The Sicilian pie was $34!!! For eight slices. Little baby Sicilian! Lol. Ouch.The staff was cool. But I’m used to a regular sized Sicilian. And definitely NOT for $34!!!The search continues…
Cestra Pizza is amazing! Their pizza is always fresh and delicious. Musa is a fantastic manager who ensures great service.
Aleksei Coss
I’ve been going to this spot for a few years and the service is great Musa always has my order hot and fresh I highly recommend them.
Dante Torres
Cestra’s pizza is the best in New Rochelle. Always comes in clutch with the best food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Lagares
If you’re looking for an official NY slice, this is the spot! The pizza is perfectly crispy and flavorful, good tasting homemade sauce and any topping you can imagine.All other appetizers are on point and the staff is friendly. I honestly can’t get enough of this place! Highly recommended - 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Minestrone Soup, Flatbread, Spinach Pizza, Buffalo Wings, Chicken Francese, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Cutlet, Hawaiian, Grandma, Chicken Wings with Your Choice of Buffalo or BBQ Sauce, Garlic Bread, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Grandma Pizza, Salad, Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parm, Sicilian Pizza, The Buffalo, White
Excellent pizza. Fresh. Even when reheated it's not dripping with oil. Food looks delicious every time I go in. Friendly staff. Good sized portions and specialty foods. Soups come with a piece of bread.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza shop vibe. Team is very welcoming!! Pizza is delicious and they have a great menu. Everything i've had is super tasty!!!! Get the cookies, they'll warm them up and they are perfection.
Just walked in to the pizza shop at 7:36pm and asked for a cheese slice and a pepperoni with Extra cheese and the counter guy told me only one cheese slice and what ever other slice I have but I can’t do a pepperoni slice cause I’m not making anymore cheese pies, How you run out of cheese slices at 7:30pm and decide not to make anymore pizza. The owners nephew is much nicer and I’m sure he would’ve gone above and beyond. This was rude and cause of him I would never buy here again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
My new go-to for pizza in New Rochelle. Buffalo chicken slice is legit and the garlic knots are very good. I’ve had the calzone as well which has a nice crispy bake to the outside. Have had fries and calamari as well - nothing has missed the mark yet.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Garlic Bread, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Garlic Knots
My mistake....Sorry guys! It seems they do have delivery, we have had many meals delivered and every one was outstanding and HOT!
A neighbor recommended this place, and it looks like they have a couple of locations in the Bronx. Meh. I am a die hard grandma pizza fan, and this one was the worst I have ever had. Where the hell is the sauce, man? It's more naked crust than anything with a little sauce and medallions of mozzarella, kind of like an afterthought. I also got a pie with meatballs and sausage. It came to my house a little soggy. The crust did not hold up through transport. I may pop in and try a fresh slice, to see if there is a difference, but aside from that, I won't be ordering delivery from here agin.
The eggplant pizza is AMAZING!!!! I thought it was a chicken slice, just delicious!!! The costumer service is great!Vegetarian options: All of their food is GREAT & Delicious!!! Vegetarian as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Garlic Bread, Salad, Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parm
Cestra's is the go-to place for great pizza and wonderful service. I just relocated to downtown New Rochelle, and while I love Latin Cusine, it is great to have alternative options. I love that their pizza is thin crust, & just the right proportion of sauce & chesse. I just ordered their Buffalo Chicken Pie & it was a family hit!
Best food in all of westchester bar
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Salad
Just moved to New Rochelle. Looking to find my new ‘local’ spot. Stopped here with the fam. Ordered a slice, a kids pasta, and a Sicilian pie. $50. The Sicilian pie was $34!!! For eight slices. Little baby Sicilian! Lol. Ouch.The staff was cool. But I’m used to a regular sized Sicilian. And definitely NOT for $34!!!The search continues…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
It was so delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cestra Pizza is amazing! Their pizza is always fresh and delicious. Musa is a fantastic manager who ensures great service.
I’ve been going to this spot for a few years and the service is great Musa always has my order hot and fresh I highly recommend them.
Cestra’s pizza is the best in New Rochelle. Always comes in clutch with the best food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you’re looking for an official NY slice, this is the spot! The pizza is perfectly crispy and flavorful, good tasting homemade sauce and any topping you can imagine.All other appetizers are on point and the staff is friendly. I honestly can’t get enough of this place! Highly recommended - 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Minestrone Soup, Flatbread, Spinach Pizza, Buffalo Wings, Chicken Francese, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Cutlet, Hawaiian, Grandma, Chicken Wings with Your Choice of Buffalo or BBQ Sauce, Garlic Bread, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Grandma Pizza, Salad, Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parm, Sicilian Pizza, The Buffalo, White