Pizza Boys

9 Clinton St, New York Mills
(315) 520-7111

Recent Reviews

Mosey

I have absolutely no words to describe this place. It is absolutely GODLY and I can’t think of anything bad to say. The food here is awesome af and the people are so friendly, helpful, and mosey. I love coming here!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Pizza

Kimmerly Herring

The ranch is absolutely amazing. The garlic knots are huge and airy. We also got the grande supreme, and it was phenomenal. 10/10. Will definitely order gain.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Josiah A

Great food. Nothing I wouldn't get on the menu.

Kim Docherty

Pizza here is fantastic and the turkey sandwich my mom had looked amazing! She loved it! Very nice staff as well. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everything

Charlene Whaley

Bartender only wants to serve the men in the bar. Didn't get any food just drinks. Bartender came outside and asked me about review. Place needs new

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 1

Christine C.

This place is AMAZING! Not only was the food delicious (Their wings, pizza and specialty salads are phenomenal!) and the prices very reasonable, the staff was also very accommodating to our large group. We had let them know we would be coming there after the American Heart Walk this past weekend and they had three large tables waiting for us when we arrived! We also found being able to order ahead online worked wonderfully for those of us pressed for time. (Others ordered when they arrived and also found their orders were filled in a timely manner.) EVERYONE was pleased with their food! We plan to make this our regular gathering place to meet at after future Heart Walks. THANK YOU!!!

Rick Salek

I've been a customer for close to 10 years now, give or take a year or so. I started when they were located in Littlefalls. I have yet to be disappointed. My favorite here is the CBR pizza or the ceasar salad. Great food at a fair price. Keep up the good work!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Theresa Bolos

We just ordered delivery because I called and I was on hold for 15 minutes so I decided to do an order online. I know they’re busy there’s no school. And this place is always jammin. I guess the delivery came by slice? It must be a company. it was here in 30 minutes. Freaking amazing and everything was perfect. The turkey sub was fresh and the pizza? Hot. Fresh. Delish !!!!! . I love new York style. Thank you pizza boys !!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joyce M.

I have had the chicken riggies on Thursdays when it is a special price. They always make it perfect - not too hot or too mild (I always order it that way). It comes with garlic bread and a side salad with your choice of dressing. The container is large so you have enough for a least 2 servings. I find the staff very friendly. They seem to know me by name because I am there almost every Thursday!

Krystal S.

It's already a shame and disgusting that I've seen and herd employees talking about roaches in the back and on the wall visible from the register if you pay attention. But in addition to that, my friend worked there and she told me all about how they would drop food in their cooler or on their line and pick it up and say they aren't allowed to waste anything. I was also told about the wings smelling rotten and having an off color, but they were told to make them anyway. I've heard so many awful things that would blow anyone awa, but the reason I'm even writing a review is the customer service. The other day, I was ordering while I was waiting for my friend to get off work and had a misunderstanding with the kind of sauce I wanted and after I paid and went to sit down and wait I hear the short skinny girl with piercings in her face day "what a dumb b****". I genuinely hate that dirty place and all the horrible workers that I've dealt with.

Bassima Delduchetto

Delivered our yummy food to the rink and went extra mile to deliver utensils (we forgot to ask for) to our hotel! Super friendly and great food! Love this place! Thank you!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Nagorski

A cool spot for wings and love music. Stopped in the other night and there was a dude jamming on guitar. Ordered a couple types of wing, just amazing. Definitely recommend checking this place out.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Wings

Josh S

Remember when you used to get big old slices of pizza for a dollar on Tuesdays? Anyway... Slices are down to half the size they used to be, but also double the price thanks to shrinkflation and corporate greed. At least the pizza still kind of tastes okay, but you can get a better deal literally anywhere

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Diana H.

My daughter ordered wings from Pizza Boys and when she got home she found a steak knife pointy end out one inch from the foil. She didn't cut herself or anything but she was quite taken aback and felt a bit unnerved. I can see how this could accidentally happen, although I don't know why a knife would be near an order of wings. I called the store to let them know and Since there was no manager on duty at the time they took my phone number and they were going to have her call me back . I never got the call, so I called the second time same thing.. although I did tell the person who answered what had happened. I went into the store twice asking for the manager and there was no manager there and the owner was not there. At this point, the knife itself is not a big deal, but the lack of concern for a customer calling about a problem is very concerning . It feels like nobody wants to take accountability for the problem. It would've been irresponsible of me to not let them know this happened. They have great food and employees are generally very helpful and polite.

MY Upstate NY Marketing M.

We loved the place, it was very clean and the food was great! The wings were excellent and the staff was very nice too.

Load More