eh it was okay. we enjoyed it. maybe didn’t choose the right sandwich we got one of the specials. maybe i’ll go back and try a different sandwich
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Chimuanya Nolisa
Awesome sandwiches
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto, Matthew
MB
This place was good but the sandwiches are very small for the price: maybe sufficient for a woman or a child. Not a grown man.
Peter Lombardo
What has happened to this place??? $20 sandwich with about $2.50 worth of ingredients.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Gothamist
Tomas Janik
Great food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rafa Moterani
I don’t know why this place get all this hype. It’s extremely overpriced and crowded with finance bros. Listen to me: ignore this place and go to Pisillo a few blocks away, you’re welcome.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Grace L.
Bread very good. Flavors pretty typical but wish there was a bit more stuff for the price. Ambiance & service were both nice..
Danielle D'Onofrio
Just walked all the way here in the pouring rain and they were closed because they were filming something. If that was the case you should let your customer know!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sarah S.
One of the best sandwiches I've had in a while! It's a great place to grab food if you work around the lower midtown area... Be aware though, it gets pretty crowded and it can be pretty overwhelming around lunchtime, so the earlier, the better... The pesto mayo is amaaaazing and I love the hot soppressata. It just has a great selections of meats, cheeses, and spreads. As I write this, my mouth is watering... Be warned though, it's pretty ridiculously expensive. I have to limit how frequently I go to avoid going broke, but the sandwiches are unreal and also definitely big enough to spread over more than one meal.
It was a mission for me to come back to NYC to eat a sandwich at Alidoro. I ordered La Porchetta and the excitement grew waiting to hear my name to enjoy my sandwich. Surprisingly, the bread was very cold while its a cold sandwich usually the bread doesn't feel like it came out of cold storage. I took a bite and the bread was too dense, none of the sandwich ingredients were distinguishable all I was eating was bland, thick hard bread.. completely disappointed in the whole experience. Its a shame after seeing Alidoro for several years on IG of this amazing sandwich experience and for what I paid was nothing but a let down in every level .
Gina V.
Enjoyed the choices and taste of the food, but it seems like they are skimping on the fillings compared to photos of sandwiches in the past. Would have been so much better if they adequately stuffed the sandwiches.
Jennifer D.
The sandwiches are delicious, and definitely get the pepper spread. It makes the perfect topping. If you're getting soup to go check to make sure it's full. I got a small soup and it was about half full which was upsetting since it was $6.50. But the soup was delicious. The service is quick in there and it's a good lunch spot.
Tiffany T.
Decided to get lunch here one day as it's close to my office and it was delicious. They have a good selection of sandwiches as well as drinks. I had the Matthew sandwich. The baguette was fresh and crunchy. The checkout line is very organized, but there is quite a wait so in the future I'd probably order ahead. The restaurant itself is pretty but small. There's only a few tables and then bar room.
Derrick Madsen
Wanted a lighter lunch and decided on this venue post NYC library viait. Easy to walk to and find.I understand food prices in 2024 are up, but we spent $44 for 2 sub par sandwiches and the most tasteless chicken noodle soup. $44 for bread, meat, cheese........The meat to bread ratio is bad, it's 2/3 bread. Minimal sauce was used on either sandwich. I swear my Tuna was opened from a can and just placed on bread. Felt like I got bent over and sent home without a kiss after this place. There has to be much better options of sandwiches in NYC .......I hope. I hope I can save someone some money and avoid this.Other than the fold being meh, the staff were great and loved the atmosphere.
Really great sandwich, fast prep. Bread was fresh and it was a well balanced sandwich. Plenty for 2 to share.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Mozzarella, Prosciutto, Arugula
eh it was okay. we enjoyed it. maybe didn’t choose the right sandwich we got one of the specials. maybe i’ll go back and try a different sandwich
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Awesome sandwiches
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto, Matthew
This place was good but the sandwiches are very small for the price: maybe sufficient for a woman or a child. Not a grown man.
What has happened to this place??? $20 sandwich with about $2.50 worth of ingredients.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Gothamist
Great food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don’t know why this place get all this hype. It’s extremely overpriced and crowded with finance bros. Listen to me: ignore this place and go to Pisillo a few blocks away, you’re welcome.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Bread very good. Flavors pretty typical but wish there was a bit more stuff for the price. Ambiance & service were both nice..
Just walked all the way here in the pouring rain and they were closed because they were filming something. If that was the case you should let your customer know!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
One of the best sandwiches I've had in a while! It's a great place to grab food if you work around the lower midtown area... Be aware though, it gets pretty crowded and it can be pretty overwhelming around lunchtime, so the earlier, the better... The pesto mayo is amaaaazing and I love the hot soppressata. It just has a great selections of meats, cheeses, and spreads. As I write this, my mouth is watering... Be warned though, it's pretty ridiculously expensive. I have to limit how frequently I go to avoid going broke, but the sandwiches are unreal and also definitely big enough to spread over more than one meal.
Restaurantji Recommends
It was a mission for me to come back to NYC to eat a sandwich at Alidoro. I ordered La Porchetta and the excitement grew waiting to hear my name to enjoy my sandwich. Surprisingly, the bread was very cold while its a cold sandwich usually the bread doesn't feel like it came out of cold storage. I took a bite and the bread was too dense, none of the sandwich ingredients were distinguishable all I was eating was bland, thick hard bread.. completely disappointed in the whole experience. Its a shame after seeing Alidoro for several years on IG of this amazing sandwich experience and for what I paid was nothing but a let down in every level .
Enjoyed the choices and taste of the food, but it seems like they are skimping on the fillings compared to photos of sandwiches in the past. Would have been so much better if they adequately stuffed the sandwiches.
The sandwiches are delicious, and definitely get the pepper spread. It makes the perfect topping. If you're getting soup to go check to make sure it's full. I got a small soup and it was about half full which was upsetting since it was $6.50. But the soup was delicious. The service is quick in there and it's a good lunch spot.
Decided to get lunch here one day as it's close to my office and it was delicious. They have a good selection of sandwiches as well as drinks. I had the Matthew sandwich. The baguette was fresh and crunchy. The checkout line is very organized, but there is quite a wait so in the future I'd probably order ahead. The restaurant itself is pretty but small. There's only a few tables and then bar room.
Wanted a lighter lunch and decided on this venue post NYC library viait. Easy to walk to and find.I understand food prices in 2024 are up, but we spent $44 for 2 sub par sandwiches and the most tasteless chicken noodle soup. $44 for bread, meat, cheese........The meat to bread ratio is bad, it's 2/3 bread. Minimal sauce was used on either sandwich. I swear my Tuna was opened from a can and just placed on bread. Felt like I got bent over and sent home without a kiss after this place. There has to be much better options of sandwiches in NYC .......I hope. I hope I can save someone some money and avoid this.Other than the fold being meh, the staff were great and loved the atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4