Ample Hills Creamery Upper West Side

526 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(646) 398-9598

Recent Reviews

Courtney

Very good ice cream but the cashier completely ignored me and someone else for three loud men. I did not appreciate the internalized sexism as clearly I was there first. She completely pretended we weren’t and was quite rude. I would not go back due to her behavior. Very disappointed in this.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Kirsten McCann

Delicious ice cream and wonderful scoopers!! So friendly and welcoming here. Will definitely be coming back. Love the vibe.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Butter Cake

Luc Radu

The woman behind the counter was so rude. Seemed really annoyed that we asked for a sample; barely held out the samples so I had to reach all the way over the freezer. In doing so, my scarf slipped down between the counter and the freezer, and she was SO annoyed when I asked if she had anything I could grab it with. And after ALL that, 2 small scoops of ice cream were EIGHTEEN DOLLARS. I'd say overall give this place a skip...

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Sydney Adams

The prices were displayed in a way where my whole group had no idea that we’d be spending about $10 for a small cup (some of which had one scoop while others had 2) and the employees seemed annoyed and disinterested when any of us wanted to ask a question, giving basically no answer. Comparing the taste of the ice cream to the prices, I left wishing I’d just gone to CVS.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Elodia L.

great service, good music and a clean store. the ice cream flavors were also amazing!

Nadia A.

Even in December cannot stop spoke from enjoying delicious ice cream! Me and some friends were walking by and one of my friends persuaded us to trying out some flavors and some of my friends ended up buying. You're able to try out the flavors before purchasing and they have a various amount of mixed favors that was so delicious. The place is buzzing with music and seating is available as well. Service was attentive as well and helped with our asks. I didn't purchase that day but will be back when an ice cream fix is needed!

Samantha Ray

Great ice cream as well as

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexis M.

Vibe: 7/10 - they get extra points because they have seating, but it's nothing special Service: 7.75/10 Value: 7.5/10 - good quantity for the price in NYC! But not the best deal I've ever seen Where this place truly excels is their flavors! There were so many options, I had a hard time choosing. I'll definitely be back! Chocolate milk and cookies: 10/10 Chocolate fudge: 9.5/10 Overall: 8.35/10 (4.18/5)

Jess

I really wanted to love this place. I used to live by a location in Brooklyn & went all the time, and I was so excited to see them make a comeback. However, I took some friends in today and had a pretty sour experience. The employee seemed fairly annoyed with us each asking for 1 sample each (which used to be encouraged at their other location). I got a scoop of the butter cake, which I was really excited for since it’s been like 2 years since I had any Ample Hills, and it was literally just vanilla ice cream. I don’t know how the employee scooped all around the massive chunks, but it was incredibly disappointing considering how much I had talked it up to my friends.I was looking forward to adding this back to my “must see” list for friends and family, but definitely will recommend other dessert places from here out.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Frank Feldman

Ice cream was delicious but the caramel and hot fudge toppings were not: owners should provide hot caramel and hot fudge toppings instead of sugary syrups which added nothing to the ice cream,

Diana Oliveira

Ice cream is great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone

Chirag Desai

Ice cream is extremely good

Davit Barblishvili

Nice neighborhood ice cream place with a lot of ice cream flavors.

Kenna K.

Just came in the shop with my 6 yo and her 2 friends plus the moms, and it was not nice! The woman behind the counter looked bothered and bored to help us and rushed us in our selection of flavors No thank you no nothing Handed the cups and moved on I'm not expecting a dance party or backflips but at least be congenial And the ice cream although it is delicious, cost $7.50 for a small cup so it bothered me that we spent $30 and not so much as a thank you

Michelle Y.

Really liked this ice cream place!! They have a lot of unqiue and special flavors, I'm itching to go back and try more of their ice cream. My little sister is not a fan of dessert that is too sweet so she was skeptical, but we both really loved the fruity pebble ice cream. The guys behind the counter were really nice and let us try out a couple of samples as well!

Load More

Ample Hills Creamery Upper West Side

526 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
(646) 398-9598