Awesome food, pizza was delicious and both the cheesecake and zeppole were amazing. Will definitely come here again next time I'm in Harlem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Claudia R
Had dinner with my family last Thursday. We had about 30 minutes and the service was super fast without my mentioning. Ordered the honey pie and the meat lovers. Would get the meat lovers with honey drizzle on it and the honey pie without blue cheese, personally next time. Service was incredible and thoughtful. Good music and friendly staff! Will be back to this Harlem gem for pasta and other food! Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Honey Pie
Peter Basica
An intimate venue with outstanding food and cocktails.Where else can you get gorgonzola fettuccine with shrimp?Everything was on point.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Premlata
Awesome spot for Italian food and cocktails. Ambiance is EXCELLENT. Highly recommend the outdoor seating
Leon Henry
Went on a Sunday night, the pizza was amazing, and the jazz band was brilliant.
Arlene James
Love this place. The vibe is reminiscent of an old Italian restaurant in the West Village. The food is always good, the cocktails are delicious and the service is great. You should go!
ree riley
I just found a pic of when I dined there in 2018. I live in AZI'm taking my nephews to see a Yankee game in a couple weeks & I told them this is one place we're going to dine while we're there... it's a must.The memory is strong of the ambiance, the smells, the taste, etc.Follow up...I took my nephews, as promised, last week. The dining experience was just as amazing as my first visit. I'm even trying to make brussel sprouts like I had there?The pizza.. the pasta ??What made the experience perfect was our waiter, Souleymane. I think he was the only wait staff that night, and he was hustling. Very polite, good at explaining items & overall a pleasant person to deal with and made our meal complete.
Ifeanyi Nwoke
Always a great time at Babbalucci. Had the Short-rib lasagna which is sooo good. So much flavor. And the Honey pie, which is a perfect combination of sweet and savoryVegetarian options: Plenty of vegetarian options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stu Campbell
We just loved this place. So welcoming and friendly and wow those Pizzas were just incredible. Genuinely the most delicious pizzas we have ever eaten. Good value too. My advice would be a couple of large pizzas to share between four then you can always order more if still hungry (which is very unlikely). Also great drinks selection, good with kids and a lovely vibe in the restaurant and bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
René W.
We came across this restaurant by chance and thought "we'll just have a normal pizza".But what we were then served was excellent!We ordered two different pizzas, both of which couldn't have been better. It's been a long time since we've had such good pizzas (even when travelling in Italy).Plus a super friendly owner and good service! You can tell that this place is run with passion.The evening couldn't have been better :) thank you! Also for the good travel tips ;)We will be back again!
I’ve been in Harlem for long enough but never noticed this place, till was looking for pizza places around. I ordered twice:First time - honey pizza. To be honest it was disgusting and I didn’t expect it will come with ham, didn’t see it in the descriptionSecond time I went safe and ordered Margherita. It was well made pizza
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Kiana T.
This place is so cozy and cute and I LOVE how dim the lights are. My table had the Nina &Yvonne pizza, calamari, & the Brussels sprouts. AMAZING!!! The bartender was very helpful and I would love to come back!!
John D.
I got the "331"pizza, outside of NYC this might get another star, but there's tough competition around here! The flavors are just a bit too bland; the dough, the cheese are pretty mild. The place is nice and had live music which is a bonus - we shouldn't have done takeout! The folks are REALLY nice, I will give them another chance -they deserve it!
Fatuma Hydara
Can't wait to return! Food was so delicious. I had the linguine. Not too expensive. Server was friendly and accommodating.
Joseph Althouse
Great food, nice ambiance. Friendly, courteous service. Fettuccine with mushrooms was delicious. Classic Negroni is my favorite but they serve several variations of the Negroni. Delightful. Glad to see them rebounding from the covid period.
Awesome food, pizza was delicious and both the cheesecake and zeppole were amazing. Will definitely come here again next time I'm in Harlem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Had dinner with my family last Thursday. We had about 30 minutes and the service was super fast without my mentioning. Ordered the honey pie and the meat lovers. Would get the meat lovers with honey drizzle on it and the honey pie without blue cheese, personally next time. Service was incredible and thoughtful. Good music and friendly staff! Will be back to this Harlem gem for pasta and other food! Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Honey Pie
An intimate venue with outstanding food and cocktails.Where else can you get gorgonzola fettuccine with shrimp?Everything was on point.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome spot for Italian food and cocktails. Ambiance is EXCELLENT. Highly recommend the outdoor seating
Went on a Sunday night, the pizza was amazing, and the jazz band was brilliant.
Love this place. The vibe is reminiscent of an old Italian restaurant in the West Village. The food is always good, the cocktails are delicious and the service is great. You should go!
I just found a pic of when I dined there in 2018. I live in AZI'm taking my nephews to see a Yankee game in a couple weeks & I told them this is one place we're going to dine while we're there... it's a must.The memory is strong of the ambiance, the smells, the taste, etc.Follow up...I took my nephews, as promised, last week. The dining experience was just as amazing as my first visit. I'm even trying to make brussel sprouts like I had there?The pizza.. the pasta ??What made the experience perfect was our waiter, Souleymane. I think he was the only wait staff that night, and he was hustling. Very polite, good at explaining items & overall a pleasant person to deal with and made our meal complete.
Always a great time at Babbalucci. Had the Short-rib lasagna which is sooo good. So much flavor. And the Honey pie, which is a perfect combination of sweet and savoryVegetarian options: Plenty of vegetarian options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just loved this place. So welcoming and friendly and wow those Pizzas were just incredible. Genuinely the most delicious pizzas we have ever eaten. Good value too. My advice would be a couple of large pizzas to share between four then you can always order more if still hungry (which is very unlikely). Also great drinks selection, good with kids and a lovely vibe in the restaurant and bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came across this restaurant by chance and thought "we'll just have a normal pizza".But what we were then served was excellent!We ordered two different pizzas, both of which couldn't have been better. It's been a long time since we've had such good pizzas (even when travelling in Italy).Plus a super friendly owner and good service! You can tell that this place is run with passion.The evening couldn't have been better :) thank you! Also for the good travel tips ;)We will be back again!
Restaurantji Recommends
I’ve been in Harlem for long enough but never noticed this place, till was looking for pizza places around. I ordered twice:First time - honey pizza. To be honest it was disgusting and I didn’t expect it will come with ham, didn’t see it in the descriptionSecond time I went safe and ordered Margherita. It was well made pizza
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
This place is so cozy and cute and I LOVE how dim the lights are. My table had the Nina &Yvonne pizza, calamari, & the Brussels sprouts. AMAZING!!! The bartender was very helpful and I would love to come back!!
I got the "331"pizza, outside of NYC this might get another star, but there's tough competition around here! The flavors are just a bit too bland; the dough, the cheese are pretty mild. The place is nice and had live music which is a bonus - we shouldn't have done takeout! The folks are REALLY nice, I will give them another chance -they deserve it!
Can't wait to return! Food was so delicious. I had the linguine. Not too expensive. Server was friendly and accommodating.
Great food, nice ambiance. Friendly, courteous service. Fettuccine with mushrooms was delicious. Classic Negroni is my favorite but they serve several variations of the Negroni. Delightful. Glad to see them rebounding from the covid period.