Came here for a quite bite after walking Times Square. The pizza was good and service was fast. I had a slice of mushroom and spinach and a slice of plain.
Daniel Jeong
Pizza was fine but it was really flimsy, pizza broke halfway while I folded it to eat it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Julia Z.
Must go pizza place whenever we visit NYC. We stay at Hampton inn just next door, easy to grab a slice of pizza when we pass by. Consistent high quality!
John D.
There are so many pizza spots in New York but we tried this one because it was closest to the hotel. They were already made pizzas and they pop them back in the oven to re-heat. Variety of flavors was decent but it wasn't a home run for me. They weren't that friendly and there are 99 cent pizza spots one street over so it's hard to pay more here. There was counter space to sit and eat along with a few tables.
Jocelyn T.
Pretty solid pizza! Lots of options so you'll be able to find a flavor that you like! The grandma slices (square) were very yummy and cheesy. It was nice how they heated up the slices for us too!
AJ L.
Food was okay, I wish it was less oily, but I guess you get what you pay for. It's pretty fast service and the food came fast, we were able to find a table and enjoy our meal.
Guy S.
The pizza didn't felt fresh. The pizza sauce was basic and the taste wasn't good. I wouldn't recommend it.
Solid slice of pep/sausage. Great chew and crust. Friendly guys behind the counter. NYC pizza is no joke. Definitely up there for me in the NY style.
Scott G.
Place is amazing and the pizza is great with a crisp crust! This place is worth the stop and service was great too!
Dimpie S.
Pizza tasted similar to dollar pizza. Very bland. Service wasn't the best either. They charged us credit card pricing despite paying cash. Also very dirty with limited seating despite not being too busy. Overall, will not be returning to the establishment.
Erica E.
Need a late night snack after walking around Time Square? This place was it! My mom and I were looking for some good pizza and surprisingly there was no wait here. The pizza was super good and quickly served to us. Of course got a cheese pizza can't go wrong with that. I also got a slice of Buffalo Chicken and didn't know how it would be but it was delish. The chicken was nicely breaded and juicy. My mom got a cheese and a pepperoni, the only thing I can say about this is the pepperoni was okay. I personally like it a bit crispier but the pizza was good! Also the sauce they use does have a little kick to it. So if you're not into spicey I'd skip. Like most NY spots, it was pretty tight buuuuut did have a lot of stand up spots. There were a few table in the back. Which we did sit, and some spots you could just share the table. Place was super clean and the people working were super nice.
Shannon M.
Carnegie Pizza is the BEST! Jon is the greatest owner of all time. Delish pizza, incredible staff, NYC is so blessed with this spot in Times Square. GO GET A SLICE!
Our first choice!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and music.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Filling portions
Came here for a quite bite after walking Times Square. The pizza was good and service was fast. I had a slice of mushroom and spinach and a slice of plain.
Pizza was fine but it was really flimsy, pizza broke halfway while I folded it to eat it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Must go pizza place whenever we visit NYC. We stay at Hampton inn just next door, easy to grab a slice of pizza when we pass by. Consistent high quality!
There are so many pizza spots in New York but we tried this one because it was closest to the hotel. They were already made pizzas and they pop them back in the oven to re-heat. Variety of flavors was decent but it wasn't a home run for me. They weren't that friendly and there are 99 cent pizza spots one street over so it's hard to pay more here. There was counter space to sit and eat along with a few tables.
Pretty solid pizza! Lots of options so you'll be able to find a flavor that you like! The grandma slices (square) were very yummy and cheesy. It was nice how they heated up the slices for us too!
Food was okay, I wish it was less oily, but I guess you get what you pay for. It's pretty fast service and the food came fast, we were able to find a table and enjoy our meal.
The pizza didn't felt fresh. The pizza sauce was basic and the taste wasn't good. I wouldn't recommend it.
Restaurantji Recommends
Solid slice of pep/sausage. Great chew and crust. Friendly guys behind the counter. NYC pizza is no joke. Definitely up there for me in the NY style.
Place is amazing and the pizza is great with a crisp crust! This place is worth the stop and service was great too!
Pizza tasted similar to dollar pizza. Very bland. Service wasn't the best either. They charged us credit card pricing despite paying cash. Also very dirty with limited seating despite not being too busy. Overall, will not be returning to the establishment.
Need a late night snack after walking around Time Square? This place was it! My mom and I were looking for some good pizza and surprisingly there was no wait here. The pizza was super good and quickly served to us. Of course got a cheese pizza can't go wrong with that. I also got a slice of Buffalo Chicken and didn't know how it would be but it was delish. The chicken was nicely breaded and juicy. My mom got a cheese and a pepperoni, the only thing I can say about this is the pepperoni was okay. I personally like it a bit crispier but the pizza was good! Also the sauce they use does have a little kick to it. So if you're not into spicey I'd skip. Like most NY spots, it was pretty tight buuuuut did have a lot of stand up spots. There were a few table in the back. Which we did sit, and some spots you could just share the table. Place was super clean and the people working were super nice.
Carnegie Pizza is the BEST! Jon is the greatest owner of all time. Delish pizza, incredible staff, NYC is so blessed with this spot in Times Square. GO GET A SLICE!