Food excellent, best pint of Guinness I have had outside home in ireland . Great service .Far bigger than I was expecting in a great way . Couldn’t recommend more .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin Thompson
Only had cocktails- attentive bartenders and great sports bar vibe.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Jamie A.
It was nice coming back to this pub that was the former Irish American Pub. The drinks are still amazing, new pool tables to play and their wings are still good. Love the job the new owners did fixing the place up. Karaoke still rocking on Fridays and the clientele still cool. Staff were very friendly and the service superb. Looking forward to visiting again in the future and most definitely glad to have this pub back in business!
Mark Smith
As a Liverpool FC fan, this was a must visit for me. This bar has an extensive menu for food and beer and this is a busy place because both are excellent. I will definitely return to Carragher's.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Hunter S.
I don't care about sports or Irish stuff. I just got out of a late movie and was looking for a place open. The bouncer was funny and welcoming. He even told me of a place I could go that was open after they closed if I wasn't ready to go home after my meal. The bartender and the server still on duty (there was only one because it was like 11 PM and they closed at 2 AM) were also great. The server gave me the choice of sitting at a table or at the bar and also checked to make sure the kitchen was still open for me. I chose to sit at the bar in hopes of making their life easier. Please keep in mind that this late, the menu is more limited. I ordered the classic beef burger medium. This burger is basic--you can choose your cheese--cheddar, blue, mozzarella (I chose cheddar). Also comes with onions. There was mention of mushrooms and other additions on the menu, but that didn't come on my burger. Probably because of the late hour, and that's ok. Honestly, I was worried I would get the "Waiting" treatment (for elder millennials who have seen the movie)--cold, served with a side of crotch rot and pubes. But I got a super hot, juicy, dripping, fresh burger and some decent waffle fries! I was happily surprised with how good the burger was! The drinks aren't craft, and that's not expected here. I got a couple of the cocktails, but they were pretty meh--this is more of a beer and shot place, and I recognize that. The bartender didn't rush me and was really laid back. As someone who tries to not come into a place less than two hours before closing, I appreciate that. This Irish pub is great for sports fans (lots of final four basketball action on TV). Casual vibe. Their more expanded menu includes things like lamb lollipops, chicken fingers, fried pickles, French onion soup, chicken wraps, steak sammies, multiple types of burger, buffalo Mac n cheese, as well as a few steak/fish/chicken entrees. I wouldn't call this spot a destination, but a nice late night spot in a city that used to be the city that never sleeps, but is now usually in bed by 11 PM.
Carla Cabrera
One of the best sports bars in the city! The atmosphere was great, the food was great, and the staff was so accommodating. Despite it being a busy day, I want to thank Mike for going above and beyond for my boyfriend and I visiting from Canada. I also want to thank the female bartender I didn’t catch her name but she was so sweet and patient with us too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debbie S.
Came here to get out of the rain, Who knew we would have the best time in NY. Sarah was the most amazing bartender ever! Made us feel welcome and was so charming. We will absolutely be back.
John Intrieri Jr
Every time we travel there. Great atmosphere. Great staff. Great food. Let’s Go Reds !!John I. (Exit 68)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karan Kant
Carraghers used to be great when it was located in midtown. I don’t know if ownership has changed, but it’s gone severely downhill since moving here o the Fidi location. Cover charges were added for Liverpool game days this season. I understand charging a $5or $10 cover charge however the charge for the City game was a whopping $20, which is absolutely absurd. I’d encourage the owners to reduce their greed and focus instead on improving service and food quality
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
S. Parmar
Saw a young girl get spat on. Think the owner was in.
I highly recommend this if your wanting to enjoy a good night watching a game. I reserved and they took good care of me. Awesome night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Harker
Best location to watch Liverpool FC in the city. Fun atmosphere and good service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Omar Rivera
Was here during the week of the Carabao Cup Final, the atmosphere was amazing during the game and they had great food and drink. Came in a couple of other times during the evening and the service was amazing, highly recommend you check this place out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: English Breakfast
Evander Holyfield Jr.
Just got off the phone with someone at Carragher's. They very rudely railroaded the conversation and without hearing me out pointed me to their IG page and then abruptly hung up. I despise those moments when people just assume that they know what you are going to ask. I'm disappointed because I wanted to take my scouser friends there. We will be going elsewere.
Food excellent, best pint of Guinness I have had outside home in ireland . Great service .Far bigger than I was expecting in a great way . Couldn’t recommend more .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Only had cocktails- attentive bartenders and great sports bar vibe.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
It was nice coming back to this pub that was the former Irish American Pub. The drinks are still amazing, new pool tables to play and their wings are still good. Love the job the new owners did fixing the place up. Karaoke still rocking on Fridays and the clientele still cool. Staff were very friendly and the service superb. Looking forward to visiting again in the future and most definitely glad to have this pub back in business!
As a Liverpool FC fan, this was a must visit for me. This bar has an extensive menu for food and beer and this is a busy place because both are excellent. I will definitely return to Carragher's.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
I don't care about sports or Irish stuff. I just got out of a late movie and was looking for a place open. The bouncer was funny and welcoming. He even told me of a place I could go that was open after they closed if I wasn't ready to go home after my meal. The bartender and the server still on duty (there was only one because it was like 11 PM and they closed at 2 AM) were also great. The server gave me the choice of sitting at a table or at the bar and also checked to make sure the kitchen was still open for me. I chose to sit at the bar in hopes of making their life easier. Please keep in mind that this late, the menu is more limited. I ordered the classic beef burger medium. This burger is basic--you can choose your cheese--cheddar, blue, mozzarella (I chose cheddar). Also comes with onions. There was mention of mushrooms and other additions on the menu, but that didn't come on my burger. Probably because of the late hour, and that's ok. Honestly, I was worried I would get the "Waiting" treatment (for elder millennials who have seen the movie)--cold, served with a side of crotch rot and pubes. But I got a super hot, juicy, dripping, fresh burger and some decent waffle fries! I was happily surprised with how good the burger was! The drinks aren't craft, and that's not expected here. I got a couple of the cocktails, but they were pretty meh--this is more of a beer and shot place, and I recognize that. The bartender didn't rush me and was really laid back. As someone who tries to not come into a place less than two hours before closing, I appreciate that. This Irish pub is great for sports fans (lots of final four basketball action on TV). Casual vibe. Their more expanded menu includes things like lamb lollipops, chicken fingers, fried pickles, French onion soup, chicken wraps, steak sammies, multiple types of burger, buffalo Mac n cheese, as well as a few steak/fish/chicken entrees. I wouldn't call this spot a destination, but a nice late night spot in a city that used to be the city that never sleeps, but is now usually in bed by 11 PM.
One of the best sports bars in the city! The atmosphere was great, the food was great, and the staff was so accommodating. Despite it being a busy day, I want to thank Mike for going above and beyond for my boyfriend and I visiting from Canada. I also want to thank the female bartender I didn’t catch her name but she was so sweet and patient with us too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came here to get out of the rain, Who knew we would have the best time in NY. Sarah was the most amazing bartender ever! Made us feel welcome and was so charming. We will absolutely be back.
Every time we travel there. Great atmosphere. Great staff. Great food. Let’s Go Reds !!John I. (Exit 68)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carraghers used to be great when it was located in midtown. I don’t know if ownership has changed, but it’s gone severely downhill since moving here o the Fidi location. Cover charges were added for Liverpool game days this season. I understand charging a $5or $10 cover charge however the charge for the City game was a whopping $20, which is absolutely absurd. I’d encourage the owners to reduce their greed and focus instead on improving service and food quality
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Saw a young girl get spat on. Think the owner was in.
Restaurantji Recommends
I highly recommend this if your wanting to enjoy a good night watching a game. I reserved and they took good care of me. Awesome night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best location to watch Liverpool FC in the city. Fun atmosphere and good service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was here during the week of the Carabao Cup Final, the atmosphere was amazing during the game and they had great food and drink. Came in a couple of other times during the evening and the service was amazing, highly recommend you check this place out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: English Breakfast
Just got off the phone with someone at Carragher's. They very rudely railroaded the conversation and without hearing me out pointed me to their IG page and then abruptly hung up. I despise those moments when people just assume that they know what you are going to ask. I'm disappointed because I wanted to take my scouser friends there. We will be going elsewere.
you won’t regret
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5