Bill was AMAZING to work with. He made the most amazing 3D cake for my fiancé’s surprise party. He had it delivered with instructions. And to top it all off - it was DELICIOUS. Not a typical too sweet fondant covered cake. perfectly moist with delicious icing, 3D cake.It was worth 3X the price. Which I say hesitantly because I plan on ordering again. His work is masterful.We are so happy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tracy Yorks Demarchelier
I worked with Bill on my daughter’s birthday party cake. She wanted a themed “Wednesday Addams” cake. He was so easy to work with and baked a wonderful cake. It was exactly what we wanted. Highly recommend Bill.
Service: 5
Ira Haber
This review is a long time coming. Bill, made one of the best cakes I've ever seen for the US Open. Such a pleasure to work with and his creation was amazing! Would definitely use his services again.
Upton Zander
Ordered two cakes for an engagement party. They were a huge hit! My out of town guests came by the next day just to eat leftover cake. The cakes were very flavorful and moist. My favorite was the vanilla with lemon and strawberry filling, and I usually like chocolate more than vanilla. Also love the tasty buttercream frosting and tasteful decoration with fresh flowers. They emailed us a day or two in advance to confirm delivery and easily accommodated a change in address. They delivered the cakes with care and helped me carry them up to the event space. Very satisfied!
Caroline E.
My boyfriend got me a cake from here... best tasting cake i've ever had in my whole life!
jared m.
Outstanding cake for our sons birthday. Bill was very communicative and sent photos throughout the whole process. He was able to alter the ingredients to eliminate nuts. We did a 3D excavator cake - he worked off of a picture and it was perfect. Cake was also delicious. Would HIGHLY recommend. We will be ordering from Bill every year!
Jessie Kaur
I worked with Mr. Bill for a birthday party. He was a pleasure to work with. He was so helpful with his artistic opinion on things and was up front with his entire cake making process. He never got annoyed with the many many questions I had. I really appreciate the hard work he put into the cake and it turned out amazing! Tasted great and looked GREAT!!! The details on the cake were crazy amazing! Everyone at the party could not stop talking about the cake!
Ikey Z.
Great job all around. ordered a cake in the shape of my wife's favorite wine. The cake came out exactly as envisioned and looked just like the bottle, down to the small details and verbiage I added. Looking good was great, but it also tasted great. While the cake is primarily fudge, we added a layer of yellow cake and it was perfect t for us. To make it even easier, Bill was so easy to work with and made the whole experience a pleasure. My wife loved the cake and it was the hit of her celebration. Highly recommend Bill and Creative Cakes if you want to turn an idea into a cake!
Edward Trucco
Extraordinary service!
Jems Mark
All I can say is: BANANA.PUDDING.Located on the busy street of Third St. Parking can difficult, but you'll eventually find a spot and when you do...go enjoy some banana pudding!
Bill was AMAZING to work with. He made the most amazing 3D cake for my fiancé’s surprise party. He had it delivered with instructions. And to top it all off - it was DELICIOUS. Not a typical too sweet fondant covered cake. perfectly moist with delicious icing, 3D cake.It was worth 3X the price. Which I say hesitantly because I plan on ordering again. His work is masterful.We are so happy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I worked with Bill on my daughter’s birthday party cake. She wanted a themed “Wednesday Addams” cake. He was so easy to work with and baked a wonderful cake. It was exactly what we wanted. Highly recommend Bill.
Service: 5
This review is a long time coming. Bill, made one of the best cakes I've ever seen for the US Open. Such a pleasure to work with and his creation was amazing! Would definitely use his services again.
Ordered two cakes for an engagement party. They were a huge hit! My out of town guests came by the next day just to eat leftover cake. The cakes were very flavorful and moist. My favorite was the vanilla with lemon and strawberry filling, and I usually like chocolate more than vanilla. Also love the tasty buttercream frosting and tasteful decoration with fresh flowers. They emailed us a day or two in advance to confirm delivery and easily accommodated a change in address. They delivered the cakes with care and helped me carry them up to the event space. Very satisfied!
My boyfriend got me a cake from here... best tasting cake i've ever had in my whole life!
Outstanding cake for our sons birthday. Bill was very communicative and sent photos throughout the whole process. He was able to alter the ingredients to eliminate nuts. We did a 3D excavator cake - he worked off of a picture and it was perfect. Cake was also delicious. Would HIGHLY recommend. We will be ordering from Bill every year!
I worked with Mr. Bill for a birthday party. He was a pleasure to work with. He was so helpful with his artistic opinion on things and was up front with his entire cake making process. He never got annoyed with the many many questions I had. I really appreciate the hard work he put into the cake and it turned out amazing! Tasted great and looked GREAT!!! The details on the cake were crazy amazing! Everyone at the party could not stop talking about the cake!
Great job all around. ordered a cake in the shape of my wife's favorite wine. The cake came out exactly as envisioned and looked just like the bottle, down to the small details and verbiage I added. Looking good was great, but it also tasted great. While the cake is primarily fudge, we added a layer of yellow cake and it was perfect t for us. To make it even easier, Bill was so easy to work with and made the whole experience a pleasure. My wife loved the cake and it was the hit of her celebration. Highly recommend Bill and Creative Cakes if you want to turn an idea into a cake!
Extraordinary service!
All I can say is: BANANA.PUDDING.Located on the busy street of Third St. Parking can difficult, but you'll eventually find a spot and when you do...go enjoy some banana pudding!
Restaurantji Recommends
It was so fresh. The staff was friendly and observant. Feels similar to a restaurant in Philadelphia that I enjoyed visiting.
Cake, cake...
Not only the most creative they are the best tasting cakes in NYC! We have been customers for 25 years. Bill never disappoints !
NY's premier custom cake maker. Big favourite of all awards shows, celebrities, TV shows. Each cake a work of art.
It's the best!! Bill makes the most amazing cakes..