Absolutely to die for! Amazing pasta and antipasto! Service was ok, place was very different, in between groceries shopping and stores! Lovely ambiancLoved it! I'll totally come back!
Sharyn P.
always a place i enjoy when in NYC. great location near Madison square park and the flatiron building
Shyllon M.
Food was good but we were their last customer to dine-in since we arrived straight from the airport and after finishing our food the manager came to us a few min after closing and threatened us to leave or security would be called. Mind you we just paid over $300 for dinner. This is how their management chooses to speak to their patrons from the get-go? Approached us so unprofessionally and disrespectfully. Server was sweet but tall white manager was a d*ck.
Alyssa V.
Always a good stop! Especially if you're visiting the city. They have many restaurants in this one location so you can choose if you would rather pasta dishes, seafood dishes, etc. they also have a rooftop bar and restaurant which is very cute so we grabbed a cocktail after we ate downstairs. It's also a store filled with fresh finds and packaged goods as well. I love learning looking around at all the different pastas!
Ron G.
Not as clean as other Eataly locations I have been to and wow, busy! Had a nice cappuccino and pastry. All the same amazing selection of other locations and a great location.
Liwen L.
Good varieties! Big fan of their smoked prosciutto! It's better and more flavorful that any prosciutto I've had. Quite exotic cheese! Thumb up. Ravioli is a bit disappointing because it dries out. I cooked longer than instructed but it didn't get the right texture. Still it looks cute.
Kevin B.
We had been to Eataly in Boston previously, so we were excited to stumble upon this one while walking around the Flatiron district. We were hungry, so we ate at Pizza and Pasta and it was a decent meal overall. Service was good and we enjoyed our drinks; I had a glass of wine and my wife had a fun cocktail with sprinkles. Our meal was good too as I had pesto gnocchi and my wife had linguini with clams. The shop is good overall as well and we enjoy grabbing some stuff here that we can't find otherwise. It's a nice place overall and it's worth a stop in if you're in the area.
Felice M.
Rotisserie Chicken always fabulous in the past is now burnt, dry and tasteless. I hope it was just a bad day.
Sara Z.
Eataly combines Italian speciality items and produce with restaurants that you can either grab and go or sit down. My friend and I decided to kill some time and walked around, but then decided to grab dinner at one of the sit down spots, La Pizza & La Pasta. While walking around, we enjoyed looking at all the specialty items but they are extremely pricey. La Pizza & La Pasta had a restaurant week deal where you could get an appetizer, entree, and dessert for $30 (with some items costing slightly more). This is a STEAL as some of the items that were part of the deal cost almost $30 on their own. My friend and I each ordered from the restaurant week menu and shared everything. We got the zucca, insalata, pasta bolognese, margarita pizza, tiramisu and cannoli. The zucca was really good, the insalata was okay. The greens were a little wilty and it could have had a more flavorful dressing but all and all, it was fine. Both the pasta and pizza were excellent - I'd highly recommend both items. They are classics and done very well. I was excited for the desserts because I really like both tiramisu and cannoli but they were disappointing. The cannoli filling was too dense, but the shell was warm and crunchy. The tiramisu had an intense layer of cocoa powder on top, so much so that I coughed while eating it, but the layers underneath were tasty. It was a Friday night in the middle of a snow storm and cold spell, so it was quite crowded, but the service was rather awful. It felt like the server completely forgot about us when we were waiting for the check and almost gave me back the wrong bill and card. That won't deter me, I'm planning on visiting the Chicago location in a few months and I'm sure I'll go back to this location next time I'm in NYC.
John K.
I have not dined here. Let's be clear. But I tried to call in and pay for a dinner with my credit card for my family who is celebrating our niece's birthday and they wouldn't let me. I do this all the time for birthdays and other special occasions all over the country but no. Not this place. Not even the slightest attempt to try to figure out a way to do it other than come in with my card. Yeah, I'm going to come in, pay for dinner for my family but not actually sit down and join them. The stupidity and laziness of that suggestion was astonishing. No could you text a pic of your license with the credit card, or can we run it now for $500 and adjust the bill up or down. Nothing other than come in with the card. I told her I live in Michigan. That's not possible. Sorry she says. Well, sorry I had to leave this review of this aspect of your business. For all I know the food is great and the vibe is wonderful. Based on this experience I'll never find out.
The pasta was mid and expensive, as I ate the pasta I got tired of it after a couple bites. Service was good. There is better pasta elsewhere.
Ivica M.
I come here often for great sandwiches and grocery shopping It use to be my favorite coffee spot but recently coffee here has a burnt after flavor. Milk is over steamed and ruins the flavor of coffee
Harriet ..
It's ok, food wasn't oily and was fresh, lacking in flavour though, and not a great selection
Kassandra G.
If you have ever been to Eatly you know what a good time this place is! Came to this smaller location and even though it looks small form the outside don't let that fool you! The ambiance is fun, refreshing and very farmers market meets luxury food hall! It is a very crowded spot and people are all over the place but the food is great and all the imported products are fun to look at and shop around! They have PLENTY of bar style restaurants all serving different things and if you just want quick grabs the pizza bar is perfection and they have plenty of premade options. Food wise a cannoli at Eatly is a must! They add the filling in the spot making for a super fresh treat! The pizza is delicious and there is plenty of different options! And the sandwiches I couldn't even choose there was so many! Eatly is a fun time every time!
Kettlebell K.
I've been a customer since 2010, when Flatiron was the only Eataly in the city. Some team member have been fabulous. Some have been disappointing. Not bad enough to stop me from returning. I do some grocery shopping and on occasion have had fish and pizza. On Jan 13, I was accused of shoplifting, or at least bagging groceries and not paying for them. I was told a regular customer saw me not pay so at that time I'm being investigated. I payed with Apple Pay and did not take or need a receipt. There wasn't any video to support the accusation and did not face the accuser. Is this what we are reduced to. Security can't do there job so customers are allowed to upend my time without the accuser facing any consequences or the accused. Also now it's a problem if I use my own backpack to bag groceries I paid for or pay a fee for an Eataly bag. As for the receipt, I did not have a receipt in hand but I do not need to. All I need is the card I made the purchase with as proof of purchase. It's all in the meta data of credit card purchases. If this is an issue, the customer should not have the option to recycle bag there own groceries or not have the option to receive a receipt. It is traumatic to be stopped. It's unlawful detention. Just not cool for security to do. I have seen stores put up pictures of people who have shoplifted for future reference. Maybe there should be a wall of false accusers as well. All things being equal.
Absolutely to die for! Amazing pasta and antipasto! Service was ok, place was very different, in between groceries shopping and stores! Lovely ambiancLoved it! I'll totally come back!
always a place i enjoy when in NYC. great location near Madison square park and the flatiron building
Food was good but we were their last customer to dine-in since we arrived straight from the airport and after finishing our food the manager came to us a few min after closing and threatened us to leave or security would be called. Mind you we just paid over $300 for dinner. This is how their management chooses to speak to their patrons from the get-go? Approached us so unprofessionally and disrespectfully. Server was sweet but tall white manager was a d*ck.
Always a good stop! Especially if you're visiting the city. They have many restaurants in this one location so you can choose if you would rather pasta dishes, seafood dishes, etc. they also have a rooftop bar and restaurant which is very cute so we grabbed a cocktail after we ate downstairs. It's also a store filled with fresh finds and packaged goods as well. I love learning looking around at all the different pastas!
Not as clean as other Eataly locations I have been to and wow, busy! Had a nice cappuccino and pastry. All the same amazing selection of other locations and a great location.
Good varieties! Big fan of their smoked prosciutto! It's better and more flavorful that any prosciutto I've had. Quite exotic cheese! Thumb up. Ravioli is a bit disappointing because it dries out. I cooked longer than instructed but it didn't get the right texture. Still it looks cute.
We had been to Eataly in Boston previously, so we were excited to stumble upon this one while walking around the Flatiron district. We were hungry, so we ate at Pizza and Pasta and it was a decent meal overall. Service was good and we enjoyed our drinks; I had a glass of wine and my wife had a fun cocktail with sprinkles. Our meal was good too as I had pesto gnocchi and my wife had linguini with clams. The shop is good overall as well and we enjoy grabbing some stuff here that we can't find otherwise. It's a nice place overall and it's worth a stop in if you're in the area.
Rotisserie Chicken always fabulous in the past is now burnt, dry and tasteless. I hope it was just a bad day.
Eataly combines Italian speciality items and produce with restaurants that you can either grab and go or sit down. My friend and I decided to kill some time and walked around, but then decided to grab dinner at one of the sit down spots, La Pizza & La Pasta. While walking around, we enjoyed looking at all the specialty items but they are extremely pricey. La Pizza & La Pasta had a restaurant week deal where you could get an appetizer, entree, and dessert for $30 (with some items costing slightly more). This is a STEAL as some of the items that were part of the deal cost almost $30 on their own. My friend and I each ordered from the restaurant week menu and shared everything. We got the zucca, insalata, pasta bolognese, margarita pizza, tiramisu and cannoli. The zucca was really good, the insalata was okay. The greens were a little wilty and it could have had a more flavorful dressing but all and all, it was fine. Both the pasta and pizza were excellent - I'd highly recommend both items. They are classics and done very well. I was excited for the desserts because I really like both tiramisu and cannoli but they were disappointing. The cannoli filling was too dense, but the shell was warm and crunchy. The tiramisu had an intense layer of cocoa powder on top, so much so that I coughed while eating it, but the layers underneath were tasty. It was a Friday night in the middle of a snow storm and cold spell, so it was quite crowded, but the service was rather awful. It felt like the server completely forgot about us when we were waiting for the check and almost gave me back the wrong bill and card. That won't deter me, I'm planning on visiting the Chicago location in a few months and I'm sure I'll go back to this location next time I'm in NYC.
I have not dined here. Let's be clear. But I tried to call in and pay for a dinner with my credit card for my family who is celebrating our niece's birthday and they wouldn't let me. I do this all the time for birthdays and other special occasions all over the country but no. Not this place. Not even the slightest attempt to try to figure out a way to do it other than come in with my card. Yeah, I'm going to come in, pay for dinner for my family but not actually sit down and join them. The stupidity and laziness of that suggestion was astonishing. No could you text a pic of your license with the credit card, or can we run it now for $500 and adjust the bill up or down. Nothing other than come in with the card. I told her I live in Michigan. That's not possible. Sorry she says. Well, sorry I had to leave this review of this aspect of your business. For all I know the food is great and the vibe is wonderful. Based on this experience I'll never find out.
Restaurantji Recommends
The pasta was mid and expensive, as I ate the pasta I got tired of it after a couple bites. Service was good. There is better pasta elsewhere.
I come here often for great sandwiches and grocery shopping It use to be my favorite coffee spot but recently coffee here has a burnt after flavor. Milk is over steamed and ruins the flavor of coffee
It's ok, food wasn't oily and was fresh, lacking in flavour though, and not a great selection
If you have ever been to Eatly you know what a good time this place is! Came to this smaller location and even though it looks small form the outside don't let that fool you! The ambiance is fun, refreshing and very farmers market meets luxury food hall! It is a very crowded spot and people are all over the place but the food is great and all the imported products are fun to look at and shop around! They have PLENTY of bar style restaurants all serving different things and if you just want quick grabs the pizza bar is perfection and they have plenty of premade options. Food wise a cannoli at Eatly is a must! They add the filling in the spot making for a super fresh treat! The pizza is delicious and there is plenty of different options! And the sandwiches I couldn't even choose there was so many! Eatly is a fun time every time!
I've been a customer since 2010, when Flatiron was the only Eataly in the city. Some team member have been fabulous. Some have been disappointing. Not bad enough to stop me from returning. I do some grocery shopping and on occasion have had fish and pizza. On Jan 13, I was accused of shoplifting, or at least bagging groceries and not paying for them. I was told a regular customer saw me not pay so at that time I'm being investigated. I payed with Apple Pay and did not take or need a receipt. There wasn't any video to support the accusation and did not face the accuser. Is this what we are reduced to. Security can't do there job so customers are allowed to upend my time without the accuser facing any consequences or the accused. Also now it's a problem if I use my own backpack to bag groceries I paid for or pay a fee for an Eataly bag. As for the receipt, I did not have a receipt in hand but I do not need to. All I need is the card I made the purchase with as proof of purchase. It's all in the meta data of credit card purchases. If this is an issue, the customer should not have the option to recycle bag there own groceries or not have the option to receive a receipt. It is traumatic to be stopped. It's unlawful detention. Just not cool for security to do. I have seen stores put up pictures of people who have shoplifted for future reference. Maybe there should be a wall of false accusers as well. All things being equal.