Fat Witch Bakery

75 9th Ave, New York
(212) 807-1335

Recent Reviews

Lyn N.

I've been to this bakery a couple of years ago. I was happy to receive a mixed pack of their brownies today. The brownies are not dry. They're moist and flavorful. The bakery is located inside Chelsea Market. It's clean and their employees are very helpful. Looking forward to my future visit.

Johanna Herman

Stopped in for a few treats to bring home with me. OMG!!! So glad I did. These brownies are the best! Sad I don’t just live around the corner from this lovely shop.Flavors I tried (all amazing and true to their description):- Almond baby- Walnut baby- Citrus baby

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brownies

Totoro T.

Really wish it offered variety more than brownies! Cute logo and we really want to patronize this bakery, but the selection is just too limited.

Janice T.

I don't know much about this bakery, but we stumbled upon it exploring CHelsea Market. Packaging is cute. Evidently it's a different textured thick brownie that is really good. I'm glad they offer samples. Otherwise I don't think I would have purchased any because it was around $6-7 for one tiny square. I purchased a matcha brownie & a double chocolate chip? one. The matcha one was delicious, but short lived. The double chocolate chip I took home to my husband and he evidently enjoyed his as well. They had a sign advertising that they were in an episode of Sex andThe City. Although that didn't have any influence on me making a purchase.

Linda Huang

Delicious?Easy to carry and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Parisdoesrock

Unwelcoming vibe! FW hire people who can @least smile, and have some enthusiasm. The older lady has zero, including basic customer service skills. The product does not measure up to the price, size or flavor. Nothing memorable.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

A M

Just the best brownies, worth the trek to Chelsea Market every time I am in NYC

Debbie Lowe (3jamigos)

Best thing is the cute logo. I had the classic brownie which lacked chocolate flavor. Texturally if you like cakey, it's on point. It's a pretty boring brownie.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Tracy Hipp

Cute & small bakery.I give 3 stars because I prefer an ooey-gooey brownie, these are more cake-like. We purchased several flavors, all tasty. If you love a cakey brownie, you'll be pleased. If you're like me and want dense & decadent, look elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Brownies, All Chocolate Witch Brownie

goim kim

One of the shops that I always visit when in Chelsea market. I love how they sell many different flavors in two sizes. My favorites are the original and the coffee one☕️

S S

When I go to Chelsea Market, I often buy it.Since I'm going to eat it myself, I'm buying a value pack of cut-off pieces.Every time I go, there are several groups of customers.It seems that you can also eat freshly made brownies.Unfortunately, there is also a store in Shibuya, so I don't think it would be useful as a souvenir.My recommendation is the Cut Off Value Pack.I often buy this when I go to Chelsea Market.I think everyone will like it because it's not too sweet.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Rocio F.

This is one of my go-to places for simple but reliable souvenirs. The different packaging options make it convenient to right size it to the group. I usually go for Fat Witch or Double Chocolate brownies

James Wiggins

Talk about price gouging. Their unwrapped brownies at end of day used to be one of the best deals around at $1.75. Now they have raised the price for one brownie to $5. No thanks. They've lost my business forever.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

James W.

Talk about price gouging! Their brownies at end of day used to be one of the best deals in town at $1.75. Now they've raised the price nearly 300% to $5 for a single brownie. Ridiculous. They've lost my business forever. People ought to boycott this place to punish this kind of price gouging.

Greer Armandroff

Dry and flavorless. Totally overrated.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Brownies

Load More