The food was fabulous. Special shout out to Roman Artichokes. Service is good. It's much more than the name would suggest, from a menu perspective, but about right from an ambiance/decor point of view.
B J
Got a four cheese without blue cheese
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Genesis Rodriguez
I ordered a lasagna last night and I couldn’t eat it because it was too acid, the sauce had a terrible taste.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Oliver Willis
Dined here on a Friday night. Restaurant was busy and we had a great time! The food is very very good and the atmosphere is very intimate and fun. I very much recommend you visit this restaurant - there is a cozy feel and the people are so nice. I happen to know the owner well and he is such a great guy. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yam B
Good pizza in my opinion, but I encountered a very unpleasant and cold experience from their workers recently.*Reply: OK - I may reach out laterWheelchair accessibility: Accessible
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Ben Gulla
The staff at LPP really go above and beyond. We had our son's first birthday party lunch here this past weekend and we were treated spectacularly by the hosts and and staff. The service was courteous and attentive and we always felt welcome, even when we took up a whole corener of the restaurant. Thank you for such great work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob B.
We had a great meal - and were surprised by the breadth and depth of the menu. Yes, there is pizza, with some interesting combinations of toppings, but we had loads of options. The duck specials and my pork chop specials were wonderful - one of the best pork chops I have ever eaten. Our pasta dishes were nice - perfectly cooked - - "al dente." Try the deserts - all from The Harlem Baking Company and all delicious. Our service was wonderful; the servers all helpful and friendly and the owner came around constantly making sure that everyone was happy. The setting is quite quaint - it has a '60's casual place vibe. There are two covered but outdoor seating areas;; they looked inviting. Overall a great dinner.
Mike Seven
Outrageously over priced. And way to upscale for the area. Have to make at least 100k a year to eat
Food: 3
Eddie Spartan
A few days back I visited the establishment with my partner and a friend for a quick lunch. The food was average, the service was above average. Given the latter, my partner, who covered the bill, wrote-in a 25% tip while paying the full bill with a credit card. The next day we checked the cerdit card account to find the bill was posted but without the offered tip. He visisted the establishment to apologize to the wiater for the misshap and handed him his well deserved tip in cash. However, a day later the credit card bill was reposted inclusive of the tip. He approached the credit card company with the facts requesting a credit for the tip which he had already honored in cash. The establishment denied the facts and Bank of America (the credit card company) dismiss the claim based on his honesty and integrity. Sad! Honesty is so little valued in our society these days.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Y Nunez
I love this little gem in my neighborhood, such good food, space is perfect, service also on point. I recommend anything on the menu.
Thanks Paul for the recommendation and Patrick for making us feel like we were regulars! We had the blackened lemon shrimp appetizer, braised lamb special, and key lime fried ice-cream for dessert. Everything was to die for and service could not be more friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamison Levy
Olive Garden quality for double the price. I got the eggplant parmigiana and some broccoli rabe. Both were disappointing. The eggplant parmigiana was deep fried, which I guess is fine if you’re into that, but I don’t. The sauce on the spaghetti it came with was way too sweet. That’s also preference but it’s not to my taste. Also the broccoli rabe was weirdly chopped up, oddly sour, and also oddly spicy. It’s not that I don’t like spice, I just found it mismatched for the dish.
Lena Maria S.
Amazing food and super friendly service. Meatballs, pizza, mussels are all recommended!
Ilana R.
Excellent food. Well prepared Italian dishes and very good service. Have eaten here several times.
CindyR
We loved our dinner at Lexington Pizza Parlour! We ordered a few pizzas and the eggplant parmesan, and everything was very fresh and delicious! The portions were large and the service was very fast. We look forward to eating here again soon!
The food was fabulous. Special shout out to Roman Artichokes. Service is good. It's much more than the name would suggest, from a menu perspective, but about right from an ambiance/decor point of view.
Got a four cheese without blue cheese
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
I ordered a lasagna last night and I couldn’t eat it because it was too acid, the sauce had a terrible taste.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Dined here on a Friday night. Restaurant was busy and we had a great time! The food is very very good and the atmosphere is very intimate and fun. I very much recommend you visit this restaurant - there is a cozy feel and the people are so nice. I happen to know the owner well and he is such a great guy. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza in my opinion, but I encountered a very unpleasant and cold experience from their workers recently.*Reply: OK - I may reach out laterWheelchair accessibility: Accessible
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
The staff at LPP really go above and beyond. We had our son's first birthday party lunch here this past weekend and we were treated spectacularly by the hosts and and staff. The service was courteous and attentive and we always felt welcome, even when we took up a whole corener of the restaurant. Thank you for such great work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a great meal - and were surprised by the breadth and depth of the menu. Yes, there is pizza, with some interesting combinations of toppings, but we had loads of options. The duck specials and my pork chop specials were wonderful - one of the best pork chops I have ever eaten. Our pasta dishes were nice - perfectly cooked - - "al dente." Try the deserts - all from The Harlem Baking Company and all delicious. Our service was wonderful; the servers all helpful and friendly and the owner came around constantly making sure that everyone was happy. The setting is quite quaint - it has a '60's casual place vibe. There are two covered but outdoor seating areas;; they looked inviting. Overall a great dinner.
Outrageously over priced. And way to upscale for the area. Have to make at least 100k a year to eat
Food: 3
A few days back I visited the establishment with my partner and a friend for a quick lunch. The food was average, the service was above average. Given the latter, my partner, who covered the bill, wrote-in a 25% tip while paying the full bill with a credit card. The next day we checked the cerdit card account to find the bill was posted but without the offered tip. He visisted the establishment to apologize to the wiater for the misshap and handed him his well deserved tip in cash. However, a day later the credit card bill was reposted inclusive of the tip. He approached the credit card company with the facts requesting a credit for the tip which he had already honored in cash. The establishment denied the facts and Bank of America (the credit card company) dismiss the claim based on his honesty and integrity. Sad! Honesty is so little valued in our society these days.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
I love this little gem in my neighborhood, such good food, space is perfect, service also on point. I recommend anything on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Thanks Paul for the recommendation and Patrick for making us feel like we were regulars! We had the blackened lemon shrimp appetizer, braised lamb special, and key lime fried ice-cream for dessert. Everything was to die for and service could not be more friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Olive Garden quality for double the price. I got the eggplant parmigiana and some broccoli rabe. Both were disappointing. The eggplant parmigiana was deep fried, which I guess is fine if you’re into that, but I don’t. The sauce on the spaghetti it came with was way too sweet. That’s also preference but it’s not to my taste. Also the broccoli rabe was weirdly chopped up, oddly sour, and also oddly spicy. It’s not that I don’t like spice, I just found it mismatched for the dish.
Amazing food and super friendly service. Meatballs, pizza, mussels are all recommended!
Excellent food. Well prepared Italian dishes and very good service. Have eaten here several times.
We loved our dinner at Lexington Pizza Parlour! We ordered a few pizzas and the eggplant parmesan, and everything was very fresh and delicious! The portions were large and the service was very fast. We look forward to eating here again soon!