Magnolia Bakery

$ • Bakery, Cupcakes, Gluten-Free

Hours:
200 Columbus Ave, New York
(212) 724-8101

Customers' Favorites

Magnolia Bakery Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
3.9 (481)
Restaurantji Rating

A bakery famous for its banana pudding, we had tried banana pudding before and it was good. It has a taste quite different from Magnolia’s in Turkey. Today, we tried cupcakes and cheesecake. Red velvet cake is famous here, but I wouldn’t say I loved it, it’s okay. We liked the lemon-flavored cupcake. In summary, it’s a taste that can be liked, but the treats are really high in sugar content. I think it’s worth trying, but eating them constantly might not be a good idea.

Restaurantji Rating

Magnolia Bakery on Columbus Ave is a place to grab a quick bite and go. The atmosphere is poor and not suitable for a romantic date. Cheesecakes, good but too sweet for me, even though I like sweets.

Restaurantji Rating

Sweet tooth? Go here immediately. Although they are known for their banana pudding, I opted for their carrot cake pudding as I am a carrot cake lover through and through, and let me tell you - my choice did not disappoint. Decedent, fluffy pudding with a cream cheese flavor chock full of carrot cake crumbles and raisins. This will be a repeat every time I am in the city!!

More Reviews(481)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
Magnolia Bakery Menu
Magnolia Bakery Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Magnolia Bakery
Magnolia Bakery
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 8:30AM - 10PM
Tuesday 8:30AM - 10PM
Wednesday 8:30AM - 10PM
Thursday 8:30AM - 10PM
Friday 8:30AM - 10PM
Saturday 8:30AM - 10PM
Sunday 8:30AM - 10PM
Updated on: