Mermaid Oyster Bar

$$$ • Seafood, Cocktail Bar

Hours:
89 MacDougal St, New York
(212) 260-0100

Customers' Favorites

Mermaid Oyster Bar Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.4 (222)
Restaurantji Rating

Went in on a Friday night without a reservation. Thankfully they were able to accommodate us! We ordered the chowder, shishito peppers, and kale Caesar to start. We had the Friday lobster past special and the steak. Everything was delicious!! The chowder and steak were special standouts. Will return.

Restaurantji Rating

Had dinner here but tragically forgot to take pictures of everything, their tuna crudo was fine but not a must-order, their shaved kale salad however was fabulous and should not be missed. I remembered to photograph our mains- my father enjoyed the Thursday special of linguini and clams and my jumbo shrimp skewer with jalapeño cornbread was an absolute delight. The beachy interior is pretty fun and the counter seats were good for people-watching. There's also a large photograph...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

I’m obsessed with this place. I’ve been here like four times this month. I have wet dreams about the hot n dirty martini. I learned to like oysters here. One time I mumbled my order and the waiter brought out the wrong dish, and then proficiently apologized and brought the other dish immediately and gave us complimentary sides and mousse at the end! And now we laugh about it because we are old friends! I am moving in as soon as they’ll let me.

More Reviews(492)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 4:30 - 9PM
Tuesday 4:30 - 9PM
Wednesday 4:30 - 9PM
Thursday 4:30 - 9PM
Friday 4:30 - 10PM
Saturday 4:30 - 10PM
Sunday 4:30 - 9PM
Updated on: