Your breakfast menu should be available on the weekends!!!!!! Which is primetime for breakfast for those who work
Peter Novak
Absolutely great quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Avocado, Turkey Club
voldie12music
Phenomenal sandwiches and atmosphere, could not give higher reviews! Definitely try out the Rachel if you’re a Rueben fan looking for something a little lighter
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natalie L.
Popped in for a quick lunch on a trip to NYC, and Pickler hit the spot. These are simple sandwiches with top-notch quality ingredients. Absolutely delicious. Quick, straightforward service. Small, lil hole-in-the-wall type of ambiance, but man, great sandwiches. Definitely recommend!
Dianna A.
I just love this place. Best breakfast sandwich that is not on a bagel or from a bagel shop: scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, slice of tomato, and avocado with chipotle mayo and I sub sourdough for multigrain - all good fresh baked breads from a tristate bakery. They toast it in a panini press. yum. all orders more than $8 get 2 pickle halves. I love the half sour. The tuna melt is good as well. They have good deli sandwiches too. This is a small business and everyone working there is so nice! it's small and has a few tables if you wish to order and eat there. I hope everyone will go here. We've lost a lot of businesses in Turtle Bay and this is one not to miss please support them!
Al H.
This is a take out place in midtown catering to mostly office workers. Sandwiches are the rule. Mine was a hot pastrami sandwich that came with melted swiss cheese and mustard. It was fine, and although not as thick with pastrami as some well known delis, the price was easy to take. It was only after I returned the tray that I noticed you can self serve a dill pickle that goes with your sandwich. The sandwich sign outside promotes the coffee for a dollar when you spend for lunch. Overall a solid choice for lunch.
Julian R.
I'm thrilled that Pickler has reopened, ensuring I don't have to miss out on my mid-week sandwich fix. What's even better now is that they offer a pickup window for contactless takeout and provide delivery service. On this occasion, I ordered the Avocado Sandwich with added smoked turkey and chipotle mayo on multigrain bread, while my partner went for the Egg Salad Sandwich with cheddar cheese, also on multigrain bread. We were both delighted with our sandwich choices. Pickler continues to be a fantastic lunch spot!
S Krouse
Short walk from the United Nations.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susanne K
Short walk from the United Nations.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristie Y
If you go to the shop to order they have 4 types of free pickle spears and you're allowed to select 2. If you order online it doesn't come with the free pickles. Their sandwiches are good but their fries are amazing. I got the prosciutto with fig jam on sourdough. Very unique flavors, it was on the sweeter side.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Pastrami, blt, Rachel, Pickles, Prosciutto Grilled Cheese
The food was tasty, I had the tuna sandwich. It was a bit thin with the fillings. The delivery was super quick! I have not gone in, ordered through GrubHub so I can't speak to the ambience.
Liam M.
This place is fantastic, best sandwiches in the area and are ready in 5 minutes every time. Hidden gem on a side street so never crowded and they give away variations of free pickles which are awesome. I don't normally write reviews (good or bad) but this place needs to be talked about. Keep up the good work.
Yara F.
Tried this spot for lunch while working from my office today and loved it! Reasonable prices and very fresh sandwiches that came out quickly. I loved my BLT! Will definitely be back.
Suzanne Pechtol
Was a little confused when we first walked in - (order on the right side of store at kiosk - receive from opposite) but food was prepared quickly and absolutely one of the most delicious sandwiches (turkey club) I've had. Doesn't come with a pickle, tho. Limited seating.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taber McFarlin
The sandwich was great, but was underwhelmed by the
Your breakfast menu should be available on the weekends!!!!!! Which is primetime for breakfast for those who work
Absolutely great quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Avocado, Turkey Club
Phenomenal sandwiches and atmosphere, could not give higher reviews! Definitely try out the Rachel if you’re a Rueben fan looking for something a little lighter
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Popped in for a quick lunch on a trip to NYC, and Pickler hit the spot. These are simple sandwiches with top-notch quality ingredients. Absolutely delicious. Quick, straightforward service. Small, lil hole-in-the-wall type of ambiance, but man, great sandwiches. Definitely recommend!
I just love this place. Best breakfast sandwich that is not on a bagel or from a bagel shop: scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, slice of tomato, and avocado with chipotle mayo and I sub sourdough for multigrain - all good fresh baked breads from a tristate bakery. They toast it in a panini press. yum. all orders more than $8 get 2 pickle halves. I love the half sour. The tuna melt is good as well. They have good deli sandwiches too. This is a small business and everyone working there is so nice! it's small and has a few tables if you wish to order and eat there. I hope everyone will go here. We've lost a lot of businesses in Turtle Bay and this is one not to miss please support them!
This is a take out place in midtown catering to mostly office workers. Sandwiches are the rule. Mine was a hot pastrami sandwich that came with melted swiss cheese and mustard. It was fine, and although not as thick with pastrami as some well known delis, the price was easy to take. It was only after I returned the tray that I noticed you can self serve a dill pickle that goes with your sandwich. The sandwich sign outside promotes the coffee for a dollar when you spend for lunch. Overall a solid choice for lunch.
I'm thrilled that Pickler has reopened, ensuring I don't have to miss out on my mid-week sandwich fix. What's even better now is that they offer a pickup window for contactless takeout and provide delivery service. On this occasion, I ordered the Avocado Sandwich with added smoked turkey and chipotle mayo on multigrain bread, while my partner went for the Egg Salad Sandwich with cheddar cheese, also on multigrain bread. We were both delighted with our sandwich choices. Pickler continues to be a fantastic lunch spot!
Short walk from the United Nations.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Short walk from the United Nations.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you go to the shop to order they have 4 types of free pickle spears and you're allowed to select 2. If you order online it doesn't come with the free pickles. Their sandwiches are good but their fries are amazing. I got the prosciutto with fig jam on sourdough. Very unique flavors, it was on the sweeter side.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Pastrami, blt, Rachel, Pickles, Prosciutto Grilled Cheese
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was tasty, I had the tuna sandwich. It was a bit thin with the fillings. The delivery was super quick! I have not gone in, ordered through GrubHub so I can't speak to the ambience.
This place is fantastic, best sandwiches in the area and are ready in 5 minutes every time. Hidden gem on a side street so never crowded and they give away variations of free pickles which are awesome. I don't normally write reviews (good or bad) but this place needs to be talked about. Keep up the good work.
Tried this spot for lunch while working from my office today and loved it! Reasonable prices and very fresh sandwiches that came out quickly. I loved my BLT! Will definitely be back.
Was a little confused when we first walked in - (order on the right side of store at kiosk - receive from opposite) but food was prepared quickly and absolutely one of the most delicious sandwiches (turkey club) I've had. Doesn't come with a pickle, tho. Limited seating.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The sandwich was great, but was underwhelmed by the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Rachel Sandwich