We did a slice tour by ourselves and this one won.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Chapin
Really tasty
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kay Kay
Came and only saw dry stale pizza asked how often it was made the owner said every 3-4 days! Don't waste your time at this garbage establishment as he laughed in my face & thought selling old pizza was funny.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
David Brown
Great place for a late night slice. Surprisingly tasty pizza for the price. Two slices and a drink for $4. If you order anything other than straight up cheese, the deal is broken and you’ll pay al a carte… Then the second time you’ll order right ;)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yimei lin
The cashier is always nice and fast. The pizza is always good for the price!!! However, today I dropped by to get three slices and was shocked to see the cashier went straight to grab cheese to make pizza right after touching money!!!!! I might have to come here less often!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Javaye Latrice
My first time in NY I stopped by and got two slices it was so good and will definitely be back next year!!
Teresa Konopelko
No details of my experience my Grandchildren refer to me as Gaga… I’ll be coming to taste ..!!!
Eve G
Sign says $1 from a distance, up close it says $1.50. The .50 part is dimmed & the man behind the counter asked me to point out where is says $1. I pointed it out only to realize it actually says $1.50 UP CLOSE. He says everyone says the same thing I said, so it's a scam. 2 Bros is waaay better for the $1.50 price. It was bland, not hot for being "fresh out of the oven", & the texture was similar to wet cardboard. I do not recommend.
Reymi Hernandez
Rude and really bad service old guy is disrespecful
Thin crust cheese pizza with served cold with no flavor due to very little tomato sause or cheese. And no sign that says Pizza Gaga? Maybe it's under new management? It's OK but hardly worth a 4-star rating.
Josh J.D. “Sage” Howard
Everything was pleasant. Needed a 6 menu brochures or flyers or whatever they had for a whole pie. If you ask for Parmesan cheese they will tell you. Don’t bother they don’t have any. They don’t cater to everyone.
Justin W
I have stopped in Pizza Gaga several times over the years and their slices are very good. It depends on how fresh the pie is at the time you get there. Sometimes it is really good, and you can really taste the spices in the sauce. Sometimes it can taste dried out if the pizza has been sitting too long. Overall, the consistency is really good and the pizza tastes good. It is good if you need a good cheap snack.
Drew Paik
The only good part is how cheap the slices are, but that should also be a warning. This is worse than Chuck E Cheese pizza. Even after warming up, the crust was warm but not crunchy and the cheese wasn't even melted.
David H Bebawy
Best dollar pizza. It open late for the late night bite. 2:30am on weeknights and 4:00am on the weekends.
Regular slice is too good and addicting here.
Food: 5
We did a slice tour by ourselves and this one won.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really tasty
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came and only saw dry stale pizza asked how often it was made the owner said every 3-4 days! Don't waste your time at this garbage establishment as he laughed in my face & thought selling old pizza was funny.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great place for a late night slice. Surprisingly tasty pizza for the price. Two slices and a drink for $4. If you order anything other than straight up cheese, the deal is broken and you’ll pay al a carte… Then the second time you’ll order right ;)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cashier is always nice and fast. The pizza is always good for the price!!! However, today I dropped by to get three slices and was shocked to see the cashier went straight to grab cheese to make pizza right after touching money!!!!! I might have to come here less often!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
My first time in NY I stopped by and got two slices it was so good and will definitely be back next year!!
No details of my experience my Grandchildren refer to me as Gaga… I’ll be coming to taste ..!!!
Sign says $1 from a distance, up close it says $1.50. The .50 part is dimmed & the man behind the counter asked me to point out where is says $1. I pointed it out only to realize it actually says $1.50 UP CLOSE. He says everyone says the same thing I said, so it's a scam. 2 Bros is waaay better for the $1.50 price. It was bland, not hot for being "fresh out of the oven", & the texture was similar to wet cardboard. I do not recommend.
Rude and really bad service old guy is disrespecful
Restaurantji Recommends
Thin crust cheese pizza with served cold with no flavor due to very little tomato sause or cheese. And no sign that says Pizza Gaga? Maybe it's under new management? It's OK but hardly worth a 4-star rating.
Everything was pleasant. Needed a 6 menu brochures or flyers or whatever they had for a whole pie. If you ask for Parmesan cheese they will tell you. Don’t bother they don’t have any. They don’t cater to everyone.
I have stopped in Pizza Gaga several times over the years and their slices are very good. It depends on how fresh the pie is at the time you get there. Sometimes it is really good, and you can really taste the spices in the sauce. Sometimes it can taste dried out if the pizza has been sitting too long. Overall, the consistency is really good and the pizza tastes good. It is good if you need a good cheap snack.
The only good part is how cheap the slices are, but that should also be a warning. This is worse than Chuck E Cheese pizza. Even after warming up, the crust was warm but not crunchy and the cheese wasn't even melted.
Best dollar pizza. It open late for the late night bite. 2:30am on weeknights and 4:00am on the weekends.