Recommended dishes: Sicilian and Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Slices, Slice of Pizza, Beef Pepperoni
Eva Monroe
Pizza is mid
Food: 2
Thomas Carr
Beef pepperoni pizza was top notch. Great crust and great crust
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian and Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Kim Caplan
This place is known for their classic thin pizza and square thick pizza. We had the pepperoni and Margherita pizza. Amazing! Perfect crispy crust with a light sauce. Long line for take out but we sat ate the bar to eat slices in air condition.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
santamacx
Been on the list for awhile. Got a table in the back, plenty of space which was really refreshing for the area.Ordered two pies, classic and hot boy. While the hot boy was indeed to salty for my taste, the classic slice deserves the hype. The sauce has a slight sweetness which I loved.Plenty of nice beer and wine options too. Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Shivaun McGuckin
Visited here on the basis of some TikTok research and it definitely lived up to the hype. We ate in with my husband going for a pepperoni slice while I had the Hot Boi with hot honey sauce - easily the best slice of pizza I’ve ever had and a must have. $4.95 for a slice and we sat in the small back room which was also a fully stocked bar. If you’re in the Lower Easy Side this is a must do.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotboy Slice, Beef Pepperoni
Phillip Green
Coming from Chicago, this place had a high bar to reach for me. It was Saturday night. Line was out the door so I was excited thinking this must be THE spot. Got to the front and find out they closing and whatever pie slices they had, was it. Slices looked a bit old and dried out. We took the cheese slice and the hot boy. I was impressed by that sicilian style crust. But going there and not being able to order a variety for my family was a let down. I'll try some other spot next time. They should have had someone out there announcing they are gonna close for a private party. There was barely any food left and they still let all them people wait in line.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Luna AC
perfect pizza in NYC, perfect for take out and dine in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian and Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Slice of Pizza
Chris N
One of the best slices in the city in addition to amazing service. The bar is cozy and attracts a great crowd. When I went Trent was behind the bar, extremely warm and hospitable.Also, after leaving my backpack the night before they kept it for me. I’m incredibly grateful for this place and the team. Will be back soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jesse
This review is for dine-in. We didn't get a slice from the to-go line, which was pretty long out the door. We were seated inside right away and got the hotboi pizza. Very very impressed. Pizza holds up, no flop despite the toppings, fresh, crispy, exactly what you'd want in a New York pie. Definitely recommend.
Jake at the bar was super kind and helpful, the pizza was incredible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Jammy Jams
Overrated. I’ve tried almost half of their menu. Completely avg, flavors lacked complexity and slices were oily. Def not worth waiting in the long line lmao
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Alex e
been told by many their vegan slice is one of the best in the city. it was good, not the best I’ve had but certainly far from the worst. like a slice I’d enjoy if I am in the neighborhood, but not one I’d seek out if I’m closer to another spot yknow? kind of plain and a little flavorless but the crust was delicious lol. nice atmosphere inside
Amani
Hotboi tastes good, but wish the slice was a bit more robust. A little dry. Seating at the bar is open if you get a slice. Can't get a table if you don't order a whole pie.
Food: 4
Terry K.
Scarr's is one of my favorite slices in New York! Both times I've came here was after drinking at Reception Bar next door and it's just so good. This time we got the pepperoni slice to share and the crust was crispy, appropriate amount of cheese, and salty pepperoni. The lines aren't too bad and usually moves petty quickly, this is definitely worth a visit.
The best pizza slice in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian and Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Slices, Slice of Pizza, Beef Pepperoni
Pizza is mid
Food: 2
Beef pepperoni pizza was top notch. Great crust and great crust
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian and Pepperoni Pizza Slice
This place is known for their classic thin pizza and square thick pizza. We had the pepperoni and Margherita pizza. Amazing! Perfect crispy crust with a light sauce. Long line for take out but we sat ate the bar to eat slices in air condition.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been on the list for awhile. Got a table in the back, plenty of space which was really refreshing for the area.Ordered two pies, classic and hot boy. While the hot boy was indeed to salty for my taste, the classic slice deserves the hype. The sauce has a slight sweetness which I loved.Plenty of nice beer and wine options too. Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Visited here on the basis of some TikTok research and it definitely lived up to the hype. We ate in with my husband going for a pepperoni slice while I had the Hot Boi with hot honey sauce - easily the best slice of pizza I’ve ever had and a must have. $4.95 for a slice and we sat in the small back room which was also a fully stocked bar. If you’re in the Lower Easy Side this is a must do.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotboy Slice, Beef Pepperoni
Coming from Chicago, this place had a high bar to reach for me. It was Saturday night. Line was out the door so I was excited thinking this must be THE spot. Got to the front and find out they closing and whatever pie slices they had, was it. Slices looked a bit old and dried out. We took the cheese slice and the hot boy. I was impressed by that sicilian style crust. But going there and not being able to order a variety for my family was a let down. I'll try some other spot next time. They should have had someone out there announcing they are gonna close for a private party. There was barely any food left and they still let all them people wait in line.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
perfect pizza in NYC, perfect for take out and dine in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian and Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Slice of Pizza
One of the best slices in the city in addition to amazing service. The bar is cozy and attracts a great crowd. When I went Trent was behind the bar, extremely warm and hospitable.Also, after leaving my backpack the night before they kept it for me. I’m incredibly grateful for this place and the team. Will be back soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This review is for dine-in. We didn't get a slice from the to-go line, which was pretty long out the door. We were seated inside right away and got the hotboi pizza. Very very impressed. Pizza holds up, no flop despite the toppings, fresh, crispy, exactly what you'd want in a New York pie. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Jake at the bar was super kind and helpful, the pizza was incredible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Overrated. I’ve tried almost half of their menu. Completely avg, flavors lacked complexity and slices were oily. Def not worth waiting in the long line lmao
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
been told by many their vegan slice is one of the best in the city. it was good, not the best I’ve had but certainly far from the worst. like a slice I’d enjoy if I am in the neighborhood, but not one I’d seek out if I’m closer to another spot yknow? kind of plain and a little flavorless but the crust was delicious lol. nice atmosphere inside
Hotboi tastes good, but wish the slice was a bit more robust. A little dry. Seating at the bar is open if you get a slice. Can't get a table if you don't order a whole pie.
Food: 4
Scarr's is one of my favorite slices in New York! Both times I've came here was after drinking at Reception Bar next door and it's just so good. This time we got the pepperoni slice to share and the crust was crispy, appropriate amount of cheese, and salty pepperoni. The lines aren't too bad and usually moves petty quickly, this is definitely worth a visit.