The pizza is very taste and came out hot. The dining area is small yet cozy, 1 TV with sports play, light music in the background. Definitely recommended if you're in the Manhattan NY area. We're from Chicago and wanted to compare New York style pizza versus what we're use to at home. Chicago wins AGAIN ?Vegetarian options: Several veggies only topingsParking: No parking streets are congested
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza by the Slice
Gonz R (Gonz)
Small place with a tasty pizza option near Wall Street.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Patricia V
Stumbled across this place while exploring, and really appreciated that there's a cozy seating area. I couldn't help but grab two different types of slices; not because I was that hungry, but because they looked so good. No regrets. Amazing pizza I continue to think about. ❤️ ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anita lawson
HOW I GOT CURED FROM HPV & diabetes I can't be glad enough to thank you Doc Harry for healing me of this HPV that have been disturbing me for 3 years now. Facebook.com/herbalistharryherbs
Nancy G.
Food was Super amazing! The service was great. The chef really pours his heart into the meals. We got the chicken Alfredo pasta. The pizza was delicious .
Fanny Elias See
Huge portion of food at a really affordable price in a cosy basement restaurant. Everything was delicious and their toilet is very clean as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Amanda M.
Loved this place! I got the margarita pizza and garlic knots -- both were amazing! Workers are super sweet and helped with suggestions :)
Jezebel Roman
Had an amazing time from coming in the door the Latin man was amazing taking our orders to recommended what’s good walk us to our table help us with our stroller bringing our food to the table telling us if we need anything else don’t hesitate in asking. The food was delicious haven’t had real authentic pizza in years definitely recommend this place hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Grandma Pizza
Kelsey C.
Authentic New York slice, frequented by the workers of Wall Street. Floppy, foldable slices at an affordable price. Stick with the original. The mushroom is pretty good but not as good and definitely not necessary. Service is authentic as well - they literally don't listen you. Cash only, fine for a quick bite, good for carryout as well.
Grace Rampling - Thanks a lot.Continue doing an amazing job!!I really enjoyed our dine with my family earlier. The staff was very nice and accommodating and the food is like no other. Will definitely be back again!
Nicole Kunst
I have been getting to go orders from Grotto for many years now as I work in the area. Stopping in is literally always a pleasure - the staff are genuinely good people and I have never been disappointed in my meal. Big fan of their chicken Caesar salad (love their homemade dressing & garlicky croutons) and really any pasta dish or sandwich, their sauce is great. I would recommend Grotto to anyone in the area that would like a yummy Italian treat without a big hit to your pocket
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
O6126AVdaryls
Neat little pizza place right by the NYSE, I’m sure a popular lunch spot for Wall Street traders. Tightly packed inside.
pammie_stone
Friendly staff, willing to accommodate dietary requirements. Portions were large and they gave us carry boxes as too much food. Pasta sauce was fresh and tasty.
Nolan
Pizza had too much cheese. Also please clean the oven when you get a chance. The pizza tasted like every slice available.
Friendly staff.Solid pizza.Decent value.Steep steps, tight quarters.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
The pizza is very taste and came out hot. The dining area is small yet cozy, 1 TV with sports play, light music in the background. Definitely recommended if you're in the Manhattan NY area. We're from Chicago and wanted to compare New York style pizza versus what we're use to at home. Chicago wins AGAIN ?Vegetarian options: Several veggies only topingsParking: No parking streets are congested
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza by the Slice
Small place with a tasty pizza option near Wall Street.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Stumbled across this place while exploring, and really appreciated that there's a cozy seating area. I couldn't help but grab two different types of slices; not because I was that hungry, but because they looked so good. No regrets. Amazing pizza I continue to think about. ❤️ ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
HOW I GOT CURED FROM HPV & diabetes I can't be glad enough to thank you Doc Harry for healing me of this HPV that have been disturbing me for 3 years now. Facebook.com/herbalistharryherbs
Food was Super amazing! The service was great. The chef really pours his heart into the meals. We got the chicken Alfredo pasta. The pizza was delicious .
Huge portion of food at a really affordable price in a cosy basement restaurant. Everything was delicious and their toilet is very clean as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loved this place! I got the margarita pizza and garlic knots -- both were amazing! Workers are super sweet and helped with suggestions :)
Had an amazing time from coming in the door the Latin man was amazing taking our orders to recommended what’s good walk us to our table help us with our stroller bringing our food to the table telling us if we need anything else don’t hesitate in asking. The food was delicious haven’t had real authentic pizza in years definitely recommend this place hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Grandma Pizza
Authentic New York slice, frequented by the workers of Wall Street. Floppy, foldable slices at an affordable price. Stick with the original. The mushroom is pretty good but not as good and definitely not necessary. Service is authentic as well - they literally don't listen you. Cash only, fine for a quick bite, good for carryout as well.
Restaurantji Recommends
Grace Rampling - Thanks a lot.Continue doing an amazing job!!I really enjoyed our dine with my family earlier. The staff was very nice and accommodating and the food is like no other. Will definitely be back again!
I have been getting to go orders from Grotto for many years now as I work in the area. Stopping in is literally always a pleasure - the staff are genuinely good people and I have never been disappointed in my meal. Big fan of their chicken Caesar salad (love their homemade dressing & garlicky croutons) and really any pasta dish or sandwich, their sauce is great. I would recommend Grotto to anyone in the area that would like a yummy Italian treat without a big hit to your pocket
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Neat little pizza place right by the NYSE, I’m sure a popular lunch spot for Wall Street traders. Tightly packed inside.
Friendly staff, willing to accommodate dietary requirements. Portions were large and they gave us carry boxes as too much food. Pasta sauce was fresh and tasty.
Pizza had too much cheese. Also please clean the oven when you get a chance. The pizza tasted like every slice available.